Édouard Manet, Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers, 1865. Art Institute of Chicago. Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 30, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet: Introduction

A pale, bound body occupies the centre of a dark painting. Three men crowd around it, but their different poses make the encounter difficult to settle into a single action. One kneels close to the seated figure; another stands behind with a spear; the third holds a rose-purple cloth. The physical presence of these four bodies is immediate. Their relationships take longer to read.

Édouard Manet painted Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers in 1865. It belongs to the Art Institute of Chicago. [1]

The picture rewards attention to small differences: the direction of a gaze, the angle of a wrist, the interval between two hands. Its religious subject is recognisable, yet the people do not combine into a neatly explained demonstration. Manet places the viewer close to a scene whose gestures remain troublingly open.

At a Glance

  • ArtistÉdouard Manet
  • Date1865
  • MediumOil on canvas
  • Dimensions190.8 × 148.3 cm
  • CollectionArt Institute of Chicago
  • CreditGift of James Deering
  • Accession1925.703

This work across Édouard Manet’s career

Contents

  1. The Bound Body
  2. Three Different Encounters
  3. Cloth, Colour and Close Space
  4. A Subject from the Passion
  5. An Old Master Subject Recast
  6. At the Salon of 1865
  7. Beside The Dead Christ with Angels
  8. Annotated details

The Bound Body

Christ sits on a low, block-like support, with his hands crossed together in front of his lap. A rope binds the wrists. The arms descend from the shoulders to this compact knot of hands, giving the upper body a long, enclosed shape. A white cloth passes around the hips and falls down beside the legs. Its broad pale folds extend the light of the torso towards the lower edge.

The body is neither squarely upright nor completely collapsed. The shoulders slope, the head turns, and the legs angle across one another. These departures from a rigid frontal pose create an uneasy balance. The figure seems to occupy the seat with real weight, while the binding limits what its hands can do.

The feet bring that bodily presence especially close. They lie near the bottom of the picture, separated from the dark upper field by a long passage of exposed skin and white fabric. The nearer knee makes a broad diagonal across the lower body. Such changes of direction keep the figure from reading as a simple vertical column of light.

Above the reddish beard, Christ's eyes turn towards the left side of the image. The crown of thorns presses into the hair. Small reddish marks interrupt the forehead, but the expression does not supply a complete account of pain or resignation. The turned head opens a line of attention that the surrounding figures do not straightforwardly return.

Three Different Encounters

The kneeling man at the left brings his face close to Christ's body. His head is seen in profile, and one hand rises beneath the long diagonal reed. His other hand rests near his knee. The pale shirt, dark vest and bent leg make him a substantial foreground figure. He occupies space that might otherwise separate the viewer from the prisoner.

Behind him stands an older, grey-bearded man in a dark helmet. A spear rises towards the upper-left corner. The bare chest and the strap across it give this figure a different silhouette from the kneeling man's layered clothing. His head inclines towards the centre, but the weapon carries the eye away from the faces into the nearly black field above them.

At the right, the standing man wears a yellow head covering and a fur-like garment around his shoulders and waist. His hands hold the purple cloth behind Christ. Their placement can be followed more readily than the purpose of the gesture. The fabric stretches between his fingers and the central body without resolving exactly what is happening to it.

The Art Institute reads the captors' behaviour as ambivalent. It suggests that the standing man may be covering Christ rather than stripping him. This is an interpretation of the gesture, rather than an action conclusively explained by the image. [1]

The contrast between the men matters as much as their shared position around Christ. The kneeling head is close and low; the helmeted head inclines from behind; the standing face at the right turns more towards the viewer's side of the encounter. Their gazes do not form one continuous circuit. The scene holds several kinds of attention together.

Cloth, Colour and Close Space

The white cloth has a structural role beyond identifying a garment. It divides the lower body from the darker clothing around it, then carries a sequence of sharp folds towards the floor. Its edges move between the hands, thigh and seat. Looking along them makes the bound figure feel both strongly outlined and physically entangled with its surroundings.

The purple cloth works differently. Its broad, comparatively quiet surface stretches behind the pale torso and provides a coloured interval between the people. It also connects Christ to the standing man's hands. The viewer can read it as a shape within the composition before deciding what its movement might mean.

Warm yellow, brown and reddish passages gather around the central body. The standing man's head covering is particularly conspicuous against the dark background. The kneeling man's shirt and the older man's skin create related patches of warmth at the opposite side. These colours keep the surrounding figures active, even when the pale torso first commands attention.

The setting offers little relief from this concentration. There is no distant landscape, crowd or clearly furnished room into which the eye can escape. A narrow floor supports the feet, ropes and rods near the lower edge. Above the heads, darkness occupies a large part of the canvas. It makes the bodies feel gathered into a restricted space without giving that space an easily measurable depth.

A Subject from the Passion

The crown, reed and purple cloth identify the mocking of Christ before the Crucifixion. Mark 15:16–20 describes soldiers dressing Jesus in purple, placing a thorn crown on him, striking him with a reed and kneeling in mock homage. The passage then describes the removal of the purple clothing before he is led away. [2]

Manet's picture does not arrange these elements into a sequence that can be read from one side to the other. The reed crosses the composition, but no blow is visibly completed. The kneeling posture is clear, while the man's expression is harder to assign. The cloth is held, yet the direction and purpose of its movement remain uncertain.

This suspension gives the subject its particular pressure. A viewer familiar with the story knows what will follow, but the painted encounter demands attention to a moment before that outcome. The rope constrains the hands, the figures surround the body, and the weapons remain present. The uncertainty of the gestures does not remove the unequal power between the people.

The religious meaning also depends on how the body is presented. Christ is exposed, bound and placed close to the front of the picture. His face and feet occupy the same tangible world as the soldiers' clothing and hands. The painting makes that bodily proximity available to viewers before they settle on an explanation of any individual expression.

An Old Master Subject Recast

The 2013 Venice exhibition guide identifies Titian's treatment of the subject in the Louvre as one of Manet's sources. It places the picture within an account of his engagement with Italian religious painting. That is a proposed artistic relationship, rather than proof that Manet copied a particular passage directly. [3]

The Louvre work is Titian's The Crowning with Thorns, painted on poplar and dated in its collection history to about 1540–1543. [4]

The connection helps explain why an established religious subject could remain a demanding pictorial choice. Manet had to organise several bodies, several directions of attention and a scene of violence whose outcome his audience already knew. In his own painting, the close grouping and interrupted gestures give those problems a force that can be followed through the visible arrangement.

The soldiers' different clothing also prevents the group from becoming a uniform surround. Helmet, shirt, head covering and fur-like material create separate textures and outlines. The pale central figure is exposed against this accumulation of things worn, held and carried. Colour and material differences do part of the work that a more emphatic sequence of actions might otherwise perform.

At the Salon of 1865

Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers appeared at the Paris Salon of 1865 alongside Olympia. The Venice guide discusses the hostile reception of both paintings, placing the religious work beside the much more familiar controversy over its companion. [3]

The pairing matters when reading later criticism. In his 1867 essay, Émile Zola names both pictures but directs his extended praise towards Olympia. His discussion of the earlier Dead Christ with Angels belongs to the preceding year's Salon. Those passages should not be combined into a single tribute to Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers. [5]

Writing retrospectively in 1906, Théodore Duret recalls the two 1865 submissions together and describes the public's renewed mockery of Manet. His account helps recover the pairing's importance in the artist's reputation, although it is a later assessment by a supporter rather than a transcript of every response at the exhibition. [6]

Kathryn Kremnitzer's published study adds another view of Manet's public presence that year. For L'Autographe au Salon et dans les ateliers, he supplied a drawing recalling The Gypsies, The Spanish Ballet and Lola de Valence, rather than either of his Salon paintings. The drawing appeared in the July 8 issue. His representation in print therefore reached beyond the two controversial canvases on the exhibition walls. [7]

Beside The Dead Christ with Angels

The closest comparison within Manet's work is The Dead Christ with Angels, painted in 1864 and now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art. [8]

Both compositions place a pale body near the front of a dark setting, surrounded by figures whose gestures direct attention towards it. In the earlier painting, two winged figures attend the dead Christ. One hand supports his upper arm; the other angel bends a head towards a hand raised beside the face. Broad white fabric gathers around the body and seat.

The hands produce an especially revealing difference. In the earlier picture, Christ's palms open towards the viewer, with wounds visible. In Jesus Mocked, the hands are crossed, bound and gathered together. One figure is being supported after death; the other remains alive within an enclosing group. The difference can be read through what the arms and hands are physically able to do.

The earlier picture also spreads the attending figures' wings through the background. The blue and grey feathered forms establish a surrounding presence distinct from the exposed human body. In the later work, the men bring weapons, clothing and a held cloth into the same close space. The figures on either side become harder to read as a single, clearly defined kind of attendance.

Returning to Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers, the central hands remain a useful point of entry. The rope is explicit; the gestures around it are less so. Light makes the body strongly visible, while the differences between the surrounding faces resist a simple collective expression. The painting holds those unequal certainties together, making a familiar subject demand a fresh act of looking.

Édouard Manet, The Dead Christ with Angels, 1864. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 29.100.51.
Édouard Manet, The Dead Christ with Angels, 1864. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 29.100.51. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Image source. CC0 / Public domain. Photographic surround trimmed from the native image before proportional resizing; no enlargement or retouching.

Annotated Details from Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers and The Dead Christ with Angels

The numbered points identify visible features discussed in this article. Return from each detail to the whole composition. Each caption identifies the work shown.

Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers

Édouard Manet, Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers, 1865. Art Institute of Chicago. Art Institute of Chicago / Google Art Project. Image source. Public domain. Numbers added to a separate resized whole supplied overview. Detail crops from the unchanged original; no enlargement or retouching.

Annotated details from Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet

The Dead Christ with Angels — 1864

Édouard Manet, The Dead Christ with Angels, 1864. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 29.100.51. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Image source. CC0 / Public domain. Numbers added to a separate resized whole supplied overview, retaining its photographic border. Detail crops from the unchanged original; no enlargement or retouching.

Annotated details from The Dead Christ with Angels — 1864 by Édouard Manet

Details from JESUS MOCKED BY THE SOLDIERS AND THE DEAD CHRIST WITH ANGELS

Compare the turned face, bound hands, kneeling profile and purple cloth with the earlier painting’s open palms and attending angel.

Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers

1

The Face and Crown

The turned face, reddish beard and crown of thorns sit above the pale shoulders.

The Face and Crown detail from Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet
2

The Bound Wrists and White Cloth

The rope gathers the wrists together above the white cloth; the two hands occupy different angles.

The Bound Wrists and White Cloth detail from Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet
3

The Kneeling Profile and Raised Hand

The kneeling profile and raised hand turn towards the seated figure, beside the long diagonal reed.

The Kneeling Profile and Raised Hand detail from Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet
4

Holding the Purple Cloth

The fingers grip the purple cloth beside the pale shoulder, above a fur-like garment.

Holding the Purple Cloth detail from Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet

The Dead Christ with Angels — 1864

5

Earlier Painting: Two Open Palms

The open palms spread to either side of the body in The Dead Christ with Angels; compare them with the bound hands in Jesus Mocked.

Earlier Painting: Two Open Palms detail from The Dead Christ with Angels — 1864 by Édouard Manet
6

Earlier Painting: The Angel’s Face and Blue Wing

The angel’s head and blue wing rise above orange drapery and a pale sleeve, beside Christ’s upper body.

Earlier Painting: The Angel’s Face and Blue Wing detail from The Dead Christ with Angels — 1864 by Édouard Manet

Artworks directory

Explore selected paintings, drawings and prints by Édouard Manet. Search by title or another recorded name.

167 artworks

NameDateMedium
A Bar at the Folies-Bergère1882Painting
A Boy with a Pitcher1862–72Painting
A Cat Curled Up, Sleeping1861Drawing
A Game of Croquet1873Painting
A Good Glass of Beer1873Painting
A Letter to Eugène Maus, Decorated with Two Apples2 August 1880Drawing
A Man on Crutches1878Drawing
A Matador1866–67Painting
A Path in the Garden at Rueil (Bern)1882Painting
A Plum with an Accompanying Letter1880Drawing
A Woman Pouring Water1858–1860Painting
A Young Man Peeling a PearAbout 1868Painting
Alabama and Kearsarge1864Painting
Argenteuil1874Painting
Asparagus1880Painting
At the Café1878, signed and datedPainting
Autumn (Portrait of Méry Laurent)1882Painting
Basket of FruitsAbout 1864Painting
Beggar with Oysters1865–67Painting
Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets1872Painting
Boating1874Painting
Boats at Berck-sur-Mer1873Painting
Boy Blowing Bubbles1867Painting
Boy with a Sword1861Painting
Boy with CherriesAbout 1858Painting
Bunch of AsparagusAbout 1880Painting
Carnations and Clematis in a Crystal VaseAbout 1882Painting
Chez le Père Lathuille1879Painting
Children in the Tuileries GardensAbout 1861–1862Painting
Christ as a GardenerAbout 1856–1859Painting
Corner of a Café-ConcertProbably 1878–80Painting
Dead Christ with Angels1864Painting
Dead ToreadorProbably 1864Painting
Dead Toreador (1905 impression)Design 1867–68; printed 1905Etching
Effect of Snow at Petit Montrouge1870Painting
Eva Gonzalès1870Painting
FishingAbout 1862–63Painting
Flowers in a Crystal VaseCirca 1882Painting
Fruits on a Table1864Painting
George Moore at the Café1878 or 1879Painting
Head of a DogAbout 1876Painting
Head of ChristAbout 1864–65Painting
Head of Jean-Baptiste Faure1882–83Painting
In the Bar1878–79Painting
In the Conservatory1878/79Painting
Interior at Arcachon1871Painting
Isabelle Lemonnier with a MuffAbout 1879–80Painting
Jean-Baptiste Faure (Met companion study)1882–83Painting
Jeanne (Spring)1881Painting
Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers1865Painting
La Parisienne: Study of Ellen Andrée1875 / 1883 (records differ)Painting
Laundry1875Painting
Le Ballet Espagnol1862Painting
Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe1863Painting
Le SuicideAbout 1877Painting
Lola de Valence1862Painting
Lola de Valence (first-state etching)1863Etching
Lola de Valence (sixth-state etching)1863Etching
Luncheon in the Studio1868Painting
Madame Edouard Manet (Suzanne Leenhoff)About 1873Painting
Madame Manet at Bellevue1880Painting
Madame Manet at the Piano1868Painting
Madame Manet in the Conservatory1879Painting
Mademoiselle Isabelle Lemonnier (pastel)1879–82Drawing
Mademoiselle Victorine in the Costume of a Matador1862Painting
Marguerite de Conflans (Toulouse oval portrait)About1875–76Painting
Marguerite de Conflans Wearing a Hood1873Painting
Masked Ball at the Opera1873Painting
Mlle. Victorine in the Costume of an Espada (drawing)1862Drawing
Monet Painting in His Studio Boat1874Painting
Monk at Prayer1865Painting
Monsieur Pertuiset the Lion Hunter1881Painting
Moonlight Harbor at Boulogne1869Painting
Music in the Tuileries1862Painting
Music Lesson1870Painting
Nana1877Painting
Olympia1863Painting
On the Beach1873Painting
On the Bust, from Le Corbeau1875Lithograph
Pears (NGA, 1880)1880Painting
Peonies (Met)1864–65Painting
Plum BrandyAbout 1877Painting
Polichinelle1873Painting
Polichinelle (colour lithograph)1874Lithograph
Portrait of Antonin Proust1880Painting
Portrait of George Moore1879Drawing
Portrait of Jeanne Duval1862Painting
Portrait of LaureAbout 1862Painting
Portrait of Madame BrunetAbout 1861–63; reworked by 1867Painting
Portrait of Méry Laurent (Dijon pastel)1882Drawing
Portrait of Victorine MeurentAbout 1862Painting
Portrait of Zacharie Astruc1866Painting
Portrait of Émile Zola1868Painting
Race Course at Longchamp1864Drawing
Rochefort’s Escape (Orsay version)Circa 1881Painting
Rochefort’s Escape (Zürich version)1880–1881Painting
Rue Mosnier Decorated with Flags1878Painting
Self-Portrait with PaletteAbout 1878–79Painting
Self-Portrait with Skull Cap1878–79Painting
Sketch of a Seated WomanAbout 1864–68Drawing
Spanish Ballet (Budapest drawing)1862–63Drawing
Steamboat Leaving Boulogne1864Painting
Still Life with Brioche1880Painting
Still Life with Carp1864Painting
Still Life with Fish and Shrimp1864Painting
Still Life with Melon and PeachesAbout 1866Painting
Street SingerAbout 1862Painting
Study for Interior at Arcachon1871Drawing
Study of Three Monks1853–56Drawing
Stéphane Mallarmé1876Painting
Surprised Nymph1861Painting
Suzanne Manet at Bellevue (related drawing)1880Drawing
Tama, the Japanese DogAbout 1875Painting
Tarring the BoatJuly–August 1873Painting
The Absinthe Drinker1858–59, subsequently reworked around 1868–72Painting
The AmazonAbout 1882Painting
The Balcony1868–69Painting
The Bench1881Painting
The Blonde with Bare BreastsAbout 1878Painting
The Brioche1870Painting
The Bugler1882Painting
The Bullfight1864Painting
The Croquet Party1871Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (Boston)1867Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (Copenhagen study)1867Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (London fragments)About 1867–8Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (Mannheim)1868–69Painting
The Execution of the Emperor Maximilian (Met lithograph)1868; published 1884Lithograph
The Fifer1866Painting
The Folkestone Boat, BoulogneAbout 1868–1872Painting
The FuneralAbout 1867Painting
The Garden around Manet’s House1882Painting
The Grand Canal of Venice1875Painting
The HamAbout 1875–80Painting
The Horsewoman1870–75Painting
The House at Rueil1882Painting
The House at Rueil (Melbourne)1882Painting
The Italian1860Painting
The Kearsarge at Boulogne1864Painting
The Lady with Fans1873Painting
The Lemon1880Painting
The Milliner1881, also dated about 1881Painting
The Monet Family in Their Garden at Argenteuil1874Painting
The Old Musician1862Painting
The Races at Longchamp1866Painting
The RagpickerAbout 1865–1870Painting
The Railway1873Painting
The ReadingAbout 1866, probably reworked about 1873Painting
The Road Menders Rue de Berne1878, the usual catalogue datePainting
The Spanish Singer1860Painting
The Swallows1873Painting
The Tragic Actor1866Painting
The Tragic Actor (Met etching, 1905 impression)Design 1865–66; printed 1905Etching
Two Pears1864Painting
Vase of Peonies1864Painting
Vase of White Lilacs and Roses1883Painting
View of the 1867 Exposition Universelle1867Painting
Waitress Serving Beer1878–79Painting
Woman Before a Mirror1876, according to the GuggenheimPainting
Woman in Furs1882Drawing
Woman with a CigaretteAbout 1878–80Painting
Women at the Races1866Painting
Young Bull in a Meadow1881Painting
Young Lady in 18661866Painting
Young Woman in a Round HatCirca 1877–79Painting
Young Woman Reclining in Spanish Costume1862–63Painting
Young Woman with a BookCirca 1875Painting

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is the painting?

It belongs to the Art Institute of Chicago. [1]

Was it exhibited with Olympia?

Yes. Both paintings appeared at the Paris Salon of 1865. [3]

Is the purple cloth being removed?

The gesture is ambiguous; the Art Institute suggests it may instead be covering Christ. [1]

Discussion

Look again at the images and ideas explored in Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet. These editorial prompts invite your observations.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Follow the hands

Compare the bound wrists with the hands holding the reed and cloth. Notice which actions are clear and which remain difficult to settle.

Editorial prompt · Move between the faces

Follow the direction of each gaze. Consider whether the four figures appear to share one encounter or to occupy different kinds of attention.

Editorial prompt · Compare the two Christs

Look at the palms, white cloth and surrounding figures in the two religious paintings. Describe their differences before proposing an emotional or biographical explanation.

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers by Édouard Manet below.

References

  1. Art Institute of Chicago, Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers, museum-authored record on Google Arts & Culture. View source.
  2. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Mark 15:16–20, the mocking of Jesus. View source.
  3. Fondazione Musei Civici di Venezia, Manet: Ritorno a Venezia, 2013 Italian exhibition guide, section IV and cat. 30, printed pp. 13–14. In Italian. View source. (in Italian).
  4. Musée du Louvre, Titian, Le Couronnement d'épines, INV 748 / MR 515, collection record. In French. View source. (in French).
  5. Émile Zola, Édouard Manet: étude biographique et critique, 1867, passages on the 1864 and 1865 Salons. In French. View source. (in French).
  6. Théodore Duret, Histoire d'Édouard Manet et de son œuvre, 1906, pp. 50–51. In French. View source. (in French).
  7. Kathryn Kremnitzer, “Manet Across Media: Looking at Lola de Valence”, Materia, issue 2, 2022, “L'Autographe au Salon.” View source.
  8. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Dead Christ with Angels, 1864, collection record. View source.
  9. Splash image, Édouard Manet, Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers, 1865. Art Institute of Chicago. Art Institute of Chicago / Google Art Project. Image source. Public domain. Whole supplied public-domain reproduction resized without enlargement or retouching.