Édouard Manet, Christ as a Gardener, about 1856–1859. Oil on canvas. Privately held in published accounts; Rouart–Wildenstein I, 14. Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 30, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet: Introduction

A pale hand rises from a dark sleeve, while a long shaft crosses the figure’s shoulder. Above the hands, a golden halo surrounds a lowered head. Édouard Manet gives Christ as a Gardener the closeness of a portrait, bringing face, clothing and gesture into a compact religious image. The dealer M.S. Rau dates the oil painting to about 1856–1859.[1]

At a Glance

  • ArtistÉdouard Manet
  • TitleChrist as a Gardener
  • DateAbout 1856–1859 in the M.S. Rau dossier.[1]
  • MediumOil on canvas.[1]
  • CollectionPrivately held in published accounts.[1]
  • Catalogue numberRouart–Wildenstein I, 14.[2]

This work across Édouard Manet’s career

Contents

  1. The Turning Figure
  2. Face and Downward Gaze
  3. Halo and Sky
  4. The Raised Palm
  5. The Tool across the Shoulder
  6. Robe and Broad Folds
  7. An Early Religious Study
  8. The Absent Mary Magdalene
  9. An Earlier Reproduction
  10. Annotated details

The Turning Figure

Christ’s upper body fills most of the oval image. One shoulder projects towards the left, while the other recedes towards the hand holding the tool at the right. The clothing makes this turn clear: a broad brown expanse covers the nearer arm, then narrows towards the opposite side of the chest.

His head turns and lowers towards the left of the picture. This movement carries the face away from the direction of the shaft across his shoulder. Looking between those directions makes the pose feel less settled than a straightforward frontal likeness. Their arrangement leaves the figure poised between carrying something and addressing someone beyond the image.

Face and Downward Gaze

Long dark hair frames the face and reaches the shoulder. Its outer shape is relatively simple, but small changes in the contour distinguish the crown, the waves beside the cheek and the ends against the robe. Below, a reddish-brown beard joins the moustache and the darker area beneath the mouth.

The face is unevenly lit. One cheek and the bridge of the nose are comparatively pale; the opposite side falls into a substantial dark patch. Heavy brows and lowered eyelids give the eyes a downward direction. These are small marks within a large surrounding mass of hair, yet they strongly affect how the whole figure faces us. The gaze does not meet ours, even though the open hand turns towards the foreground.

Halo and Sky

A warm golden area surrounds the head, spreading beyond the dark hair into the lighter background. It has a broad, irregular outer boundary. The contrast makes the head conspicuous without enclosing it in a sharply drawn circular line. The gold occupies a region of its own between the figure and the sky.

Blue patches cross the background below and beside the halo. Pale cloudlike areas break their edges, while warmer tones appear towards the left. The changing light and dark patches give the background movement, but remain broad enough to leave the face legible. There is no elaborate garden architecture or distant crowd competing with the figure.

The Raised Palm

The nearer hand emerges from a loose sleeve in the lower part of the image. Its palm faces outwards, and the fingers bend and separate rather than forming a flat, regular fan. Pale strokes describe the rounded pads and changing surfaces. Warm reddish-brown marks sit between them and around the wrist, joining the hand to the darker clothing.

This small light shape interrupts the much larger brown area of the torso. It also brings the action towards us: the projecting palm occupies a different plane from the shoulder and lowered face. The sleeve expands behind it, so the hand seems to arrive at the end of a substantial covered arm. Seen before considering the subject’s story, the gesture already creates a boundary in front of the figure.

The Tool across the Shoulder

The second hand has a different task. At the right, fingers close around a long shaft that passes across the shoulder and continues behind the head towards the left. Its oblique course crosses the downward movement of the face. The shaft’s lighter strip remains visible against the surrounding blue and brown areas.

This implement is central to the gardener identification. Rouart and Wildenstein recorded both Le Christ jardinier and Le Christ à la Pioche as alternative titles to Tête de Christ in their catalogue.[2] The working object brings an ordinary physical action into the religious image. The gripping hand and the outward-facing palm make a telling contrast: one holds the carried object firmly, while the other opens into the space before Christ.

Robe and Broad Folds

Brown clothing spreads across the lower half of the composition. Darker lines follow the nearer arm and gather around the elbow and waist, breaking that broad area into folds. Some edges remain clear, especially where the sleeve meets the pale hand; elsewhere neighbouring brown passages merge. The different degrees of definition keep the robe substantial without describing every seam.

A blue-grey strip follows the outer shoulder at the left. Near the neck, a narrow pale opening separates the beard from the darker crossing fabric. These smaller areas interrupt the robe’s dominant colour and help the eye travel through it.

Annotated Details from Christ as a Gardener

The numbered points identify visible features discussed in this article. Return from each detail to the whole composition. Édouard Manet, Christ as a Gardener, about 1856–1859. Oil on canvas. Privately held in published accounts; Rouart–Wildenstein I, 14. Bellecour1, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source. CC BY-SA 4.0. Numbered overview resized and annotated from Bellecour1’s photograph; detail crops made from the same photograph. Overview and crop image derivatives: CC BY-SA 4.0.

Annotated details from Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet

Details from CHRIST AS A GARDENER

Compare the lowered face and halo with the open palm, then follow the shaft towards the gripping hand at the right.

1

Head and halo

Dark hair frames the lowered face. A warm golden area surrounds the head, with blue and pale patches of sky beyond its irregular outer edge.

Head and halo detail from Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet
2

The raised palm

The pale palm turns outwards from a loose dark sleeve. Separated, bent fingers make an irregular light shape against the larger brown robe.

The raised palm detail from Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet
3

The hand and diagonal shaft

Fingers close around the long shaft at the right. Its diagonal course crosses the shoulder and continues behind the head, contrasting with the open foreground hand.

The hand and diagonal shaft detail from Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet

An Early Religious Study

Rouart and Wildenstein dated the painting to about 1856 and described it as a study for an abandoned picture.[2] Their account places it among Manet’s early experiments with religious subjects. The later M.S. Rau dossier uses the broader approximate range 1856–1859.[1] These datings locate the work in the same early period without establishing a precise year of completion.

The different titles also draw attention to different aspects of the image. Tête de Christ emphasises the head and its portrait-like presence; the gardener titles direct attention towards the implement and the possible narrative. Both approaches suit a painting that combines an individually described face with the halo, clothing and gesture of a religious figure.

The Absent Mary Magdalene

The gardener subject belongs to Mary Magdalene’s encounter with the risen Christ, commonly called Noli me tangere, or “Touch me not.”[1] Mary herself is absent from this image. The lifted hand therefore addresses an open space rather than another figure whose answering movement we can see.

Nancy Locke connects this study with an apparently uncompleted Noli me tangere project. She interprets the viewer as occupying the Magdalen’s position, with Christ’s prohibitive hand creating a charged relationship across the picture’s boundary. She also draws attention to the contrast between the gaze here and the more focused expression in Manet’s early Christ with a Reed.[3] Her reading makes the combination of an averted face and an outward gesture particularly significant: the figure remains close to us while establishing distance through his hand.

An Earlier Reproduction

The rectangular black-and-white view reproduced in the 1975 catalogue shows more surrounding space than the oval colour image. The same central figure, raised hand and diagonal tool remain recognisable, but additional background opens around the head and shoulders. A separate digital reproduction of this view is attributed to the photographer Lochard.[2][4]

The comparison changes how the composition feels. In the rectangle, the figure stands within a broader setting; the oval brings its curved boundary close to the shoulder, hair and hands. These reproductions alone do not establish a history of physical cutting or alteration. They do show how strongly the surrounding space affects the balance between a religious scene and the concentrated presence of a single figure.

Édouard Manet, Christ as a Gardener, earlier rectangular reproduction corresponding to Rouart–Wildenstein I, 14. The photograph is attributed to Lochard in the Wikimedia Commons record.
Édouard Manet, Christ as a Gardener, earlier rectangular reproduction corresponding to Rouart–Wildenstein I, 14. The photograph is attributed to Lochard in the Wikimedia Commons record. Historical photograph attributed to Lochard; uploaded by Rlbberlin, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source. Public domain. Historical reproduction resized without cropping.

Artworks directory

Explore selected paintings, drawings and prints by Édouard Manet. Search by title or another recorded name.

167 artworks

NameDateMedium
A Bar at the Folies-Bergère1882Painting
A Boy with a Pitcher1862–72Painting
A Cat Curled Up, Sleeping1861Drawing
A Game of Croquet1873Painting
A Good Glass of Beer1873Painting
A Letter to Eugène Maus, Decorated with Two Apples2 August 1880Drawing
A Man on Crutches1878Drawing
A Matador1866–67Painting
A Path in the Garden at Rueil (Bern)1882Painting
A Plum with an Accompanying Letter1880Drawing
A Woman Pouring Water1858–1860Painting
A Young Man Peeling a PearAbout 1868Painting
Alabama and Kearsarge1864Painting
Argenteuil1874Painting
Asparagus1880Painting
At the Café1878, signed and datedPainting
Autumn (Portrait of Méry Laurent)1882Painting
Basket of FruitsAbout 1864Painting
Beggar with Oysters1865–67Painting
Berthe Morisot with a Bouquet of Violets1872Painting
Boating1874Painting
Boats at Berck-sur-Mer1873Painting
Boy Blowing Bubbles1867Painting
Boy with a Sword1861Painting
Boy with CherriesAbout 1858Painting
Bunch of AsparagusAbout 1880Painting
Carnations and Clematis in a Crystal VaseAbout 1882Painting
Chez le Père Lathuille1879Painting
Children in the Tuileries GardensAbout 1861–1862Painting
Christ as a GardenerAbout 1856–1859Painting
Corner of a Café-ConcertProbably 1878–80Painting
Dead Christ with Angels1864Painting
Dead ToreadorProbably 1864Painting
Dead Toreador (1905 impression)Design 1867–68; printed 1905Etching
Effect of Snow at Petit Montrouge1870Painting
Eva Gonzalès1870Painting
FishingAbout 1862–63Painting
Flowers in a Crystal VaseCirca 1882Painting
Fruits on a Table1864Painting
George Moore at the Café1878 or 1879Painting
Head of a DogAbout 1876Painting
Head of ChristAbout 1864–65Painting
Head of Jean-Baptiste Faure1882–83Painting
In the Bar1878–79Painting
In the Conservatory1878/79Painting
Interior at Arcachon1871Painting
Isabelle Lemonnier with a MuffAbout 1879–80Painting
Jean-Baptiste Faure (Met companion study)1882–83Painting
Jeanne (Spring)1881Painting
Jesus Mocked by the Soldiers1865Painting
La Parisienne: Study of Ellen Andrée1875 / 1883 (records differ)Painting
Laundry1875Painting
Le Ballet Espagnol1862Painting
Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe1863Painting
Le SuicideAbout 1877Painting
Lola de Valence1862Painting
Lola de Valence (first-state etching)1863Etching
Lola de Valence (sixth-state etching)1863Etching
Luncheon in the Studio1868Painting
Madame Edouard Manet (Suzanne Leenhoff)About 1873Painting
Madame Manet at Bellevue1880Painting
Madame Manet at the Piano1868Painting
Madame Manet in the Conservatory1879Painting
Mademoiselle Isabelle Lemonnier (pastel)1879–82Drawing
Mademoiselle Victorine in the Costume of a Matador1862Painting
Marguerite de Conflans (Toulouse oval portrait)About1875–76Painting
Marguerite de Conflans Wearing a Hood1873Painting
Masked Ball at the Opera1873Painting
Mlle. Victorine in the Costume of an Espada (drawing)1862Drawing
Monet Painting in His Studio Boat1874Painting
Monk at Prayer1865Painting
Monsieur Pertuiset the Lion Hunter1881Painting
Moonlight Harbor at Boulogne1869Painting
Music in the Tuileries1862Painting
Music Lesson1870Painting
Nana1877Painting
Olympia1863Painting
On the Beach1873Painting
On the Bust, from Le Corbeau1875Lithograph
Pears (NGA, 1880)1880Painting
Peonies (Met)1864–65Painting
Plum BrandyAbout 1877Painting
Polichinelle1873Painting
Polichinelle (colour lithograph)1874Lithograph
Portrait of Antonin Proust1880Painting
Portrait of George Moore1879Drawing
Portrait of Jeanne Duval1862Painting
Portrait of LaureAbout 1862Painting
Portrait of Madame BrunetAbout 1861–63; reworked by 1867Painting
Portrait of Méry Laurent (Dijon pastel)1882Drawing
Portrait of Victorine MeurentAbout 1862Painting
Portrait of Zacharie Astruc1866Painting
Portrait of Émile Zola1868Painting
Race Course at Longchamp1864Drawing
Rochefort’s Escape (Orsay version)Circa 1881Painting
Rochefort’s Escape (Zürich version)1880–1881Painting
Rue Mosnier Decorated with Flags1878Painting
Self-Portrait with PaletteAbout 1878–79Painting
Self-Portrait with Skull Cap1878–79Painting
Sketch of a Seated WomanAbout 1864–68Drawing
Spanish Ballet (Budapest drawing)1862–63Drawing
Steamboat Leaving Boulogne1864Painting
Still Life with Brioche1880Painting
Still Life with Carp1864Painting
Still Life with Fish and Shrimp1864Painting
Still Life with Melon and PeachesAbout 1866Painting
Street SingerAbout 1862Painting
Study for Interior at Arcachon1871Drawing
Study of Three Monks1853–56Drawing
Stéphane Mallarmé1876Painting
Surprised Nymph1861Painting
Suzanne Manet at Bellevue (related drawing)1880Drawing
Tama, the Japanese DogAbout 1875Painting
Tarring the BoatJuly–August 1873Painting
The Absinthe Drinker1858–59, subsequently reworked around 1868–72Painting
The AmazonAbout 1882Painting
The Balcony1868–69Painting
The Bench1881Painting
The Blonde with Bare BreastsAbout 1878Painting
The Brioche1870Painting
The Bugler1882Painting
The Bullfight1864Painting
The Croquet Party1871Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (Boston)1867Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (Copenhagen study)1867Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (London fragments)About 1867–8Painting
The Execution of Maximilian (Mannheim)1868–69Painting
The Execution of the Emperor Maximilian (Met lithograph)1868; published 1884Lithograph
The Fifer1866Painting
The Folkestone Boat, BoulogneAbout 1868–1872Painting
The FuneralAbout 1867Painting
The Garden around Manet’s House1882Painting
The Grand Canal of Venice1875Painting
The HamAbout 1875–80Painting
The Horsewoman1870–75Painting
The House at Rueil1882Painting
The House at Rueil (Melbourne)1882Painting
The Italian1860Painting
The Kearsarge at Boulogne1864Painting
The Lady with Fans1873Painting
The Lemon1880Painting
The Milliner1881, also dated about 1881Painting
The Monet Family in Their Garden at Argenteuil1874Painting
The Old Musician1862Painting
The Races at Longchamp1866Painting
The RagpickerAbout 1865–1870Painting
The Railway1873Painting
The ReadingAbout 1866, probably reworked about 1873Painting
The Road Menders Rue de Berne1878, the usual catalogue datePainting
The Spanish Singer1860Painting
The Swallows1873Painting
The Tragic Actor1866Painting
The Tragic Actor (Met etching, 1905 impression)Design 1865–66; printed 1905Etching
Two Pears1864Painting
Vase of Peonies1864Painting
Vase of White Lilacs and Roses1883Painting
View of the 1867 Exposition Universelle1867Painting
Waitress Serving Beer1878–79Painting
Woman Before a Mirror1876, according to the GuggenheimPainting
Woman in Furs1882Drawing
Woman with a CigaretteAbout 1878–80Painting
Women at the Races1866Painting
Young Bull in a Meadow1881Painting
Young Lady in 18661866Painting
Young Woman in a Round HatCirca 1877–79Painting
Young Woman Reclining in Spanish Costume1862–63Painting
Young Woman with a BookCirca 1875Painting

Frequently Asked Questions

When was Christ as a Gardener painted?

The M.S. Rau dossier gives about 1856–1859. Rouart and Wildenstein dated it to about 1856.[1][2]

Why does Christ carry a gardening tool?

The subject relates to the risen Christ’s encounter with Mary Magdalene, known as Noli me tangere. The tool supports the gardener identification.[1][2]

Is Mary Magdalene shown in the painting?

No. Nancy Locke interprets the viewer as taking her position before the figure and his raised hand.[3]

Discussion

Look again at the images and ideas explored in Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet. These editorial prompts invite your observations.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Two hands

Compare the open foreground palm with the hand holding the shaft. How does each action affect your sense of distance from the figure?

Editorial prompt · Head and halo

Follow the boundaries between dark hair, warm gold and pale sky. Which edge first draws your attention towards the face?

Editorial prompt · Surrounding space

Compare the oval colour image with the earlier rectangular reproduction. How does the additional background change the figure’s apparent scale?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Christ as a Gardener by Édouard Manet below.

References

  1. M.S. Rau, Christ as a Gardener, object facts and subject discussion, pp.2–5. Public painting dossier. View source.
  2. Denis Rouart and Daniel Wildenstein, Édouard Manet: Catalogue raisonné, tomeI,1975,p.38,no.14 and accompanying illustration. Wildenstein Plattner Institute digitisation. French. View source.
  3. Nancy Locke, Manet and the Family Romance, Princeton University Press,2001,p.136,figs.67–68; page reproduced on p.12 of the M.S. Rau dossier. Publication details. View source 1. View source 2.
  4. Le Christ jardinier, historical rectangular reproduction attributed to Lochard, uploaded by Rlbberlin. Wikimedia Commons file and image history. View source.
  5. Splash image, Édouard Manet, Christ as a Gardener, about 1856–1859. Oil on canvas. Privately held in published accounts; Rouart–Wildenstein I, 14. Bellecour1, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source. CC BY-SA 4.0. Photograph resized without cropping. Image derivative: CC BY-SA 4.0.