Three nude women carry garlands in Rubens's red-chalk study after Primaticcio's Fontainebleau designs Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 14, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Three bodies, two routes to Fontainebleau

Three women fill this small sheet from foot to raised hand. The pair at left stand close together, their bodies turning in different directions as they lift heavy garlands. The woman at right stands apart, one arm above her head and the other carrying the decorative form at her shoulder. Red chalk gives the figures their warm outlines; darker passages suggest depth; light marks pick out their raised surfaces. At first glance the drawing seems to record one sculptural group. Its sources are more complicated.

The Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen catalogue[1] names the work Three Women Holding Garlands (after Francesco Primaticcio) and identifies Peter Paul Rubens as its draughtsman. It dates the sheet circa 1622–27, gives its materials as red chalk, brown wash and white heightening, and measures it at 269 × 253 millimetres. The museum's object number is V 6 recto (PK). The inherited route calls it “Three Caryatids,” a useful pointer to the decorative figures, but the current catalogue title is clearer about the women and their garlands.

“After Primaticcio” does not mean that Primaticcio drew this sheet. It names the earlier artist whose designs Rubens studied. Boijmans makes that distinction explicitly in its artist fields: Rubens is the draughtsman; Francesco Primaticcio is the artist after whom the work was made. That distinction matters because the drawing once had a very different explanation. The museum now uses the physical evidence of the sheet to challenge that older view.

At a Glance

  • DraughtsmanPeter Paul Rubens [1]
  • AfterFrancesco Primaticcio [1]
  • DateCirca 1622–27 [1]
  • MediumRed chalk, brown wash, white heightening [1]
  • Dimensions269 × 253 mm [1]
  • CollectionMuseum Boijmans Van Beuningen, V 6 recto (PK) [1]

Where this work sits in Rubens's career

Rubens's career
16001610162016301640

Contents

  1. What can be seen in the drawing?
  2. The two women at left: probable sculptural studies
  3. The right-hand woman: a printed source
  4. An older theory revised by looking at the sheet
  5. Why make a study after another artist?
  6. Collection identity and access

What can be seen in the drawing?

The figures almost reach the edges of the square format. Their raised arms and suspended garlands make a rhythm across the top, while their legs and feet bring the gaze back down. The left woman leans and turns, the middle figure twists, and the right woman stretches more openly. Their poses are related without being identical. Rubens records a sequence of bodies rather than repeating one fixed outline three times.

In the retained image, the contours are especially clear around shoulders, hips and knees. Areas of wash deepen the shadows beside limbs and below the hanging decoration. White heightening, listed in the museum's technique field, gives selected surfaces more light. These effects do not turn the drawing into a finished painting. They help a viewer understand how a drawn figure can recall the volume and illumination of relief sculpture.

The garlands are not small accessories. They determine the raised arms and connect the women's bodies with the decorative frame that their source designs once served. A viewer can follow the weight from hand to shoulder, then down through the turning torso to the legs. This is one reason “caryatids” became a plausible short name for the sheet: the bodies participate in architecture and ornament. Yet the museum's chosen title avoids implying that all three figures were copied together from one surviving architectural group.

It is tempting to label them as the Three Graces because there are three women. Boijmans does not give this drawing that title or identify these figures as a specific mythological trio. The garlands and the decorative source are better evidence for what the sheet is studying. A three-figure grouping alone does not establish a named myth.

The two women at left: probable sculptural studies

Boijmans curator Albert Elen relates the two standing figures at left to stucco caryatids designed by Primaticcio for the Escalier du Roi at the Palace of Fontainebleau, around 1545. His catalogue wording is qualified: Rubens probably made these studies during a visit to the palace. That is a persuasive explanation for the figures' sculptural quality, but the museum does not present an itinerary document proving the exact encounter.

Stucco is a mouldable material used to make relief ornament on a wall or ceiling. At Fontainebleau, such ornament was part of an ambitious court setting in which painting, sculpture and architecture worked together. The Metropolitan Museum's account of Fontainebleau[2] explains that the palace decorations developed under Rosso Fiorentino and Primaticcio as a coordinated interior art. This context helps explain why Rubens might treat the women as more than isolated figure poses. They belonged to a decorative language of bodies, frames and garlands.

The Met's separate Primaticcio drawing, Two Nymphs Carrying a Third[3], concerns another Fontainebleau stucco scheme, the Appartement des Bains. It is not a source sheet for Rubens's three garland bearers. It does, however, document Primaticcio's work in a medium that could move between paper and palace decoration. Keeping it separate prevents a general historical parallel from becoming a false one-to-one model.

The two left figures can be read as Rubens's translation of sculpted forms back into drawing. A wall relief has its own scale, depth and lighting; a sheet of paper offers line, wash and selected highlights. Their limbs remain closely tied to decorative action, but Rubens can adjust how they meet the page. The result preserves the energy of architectural figures without reproducing an entire staircase wall.

The right-hand woman: a printed source

The woman at right has a different route into Rubens's sheet. According to Boijmans's catalogue[1], she is based on a print by Léon Davent after Primaticcio. The same underlying artistic world connects her to the other women, but the immediate model identified by the museum is a printed image rather than the palace stucco. That is why the drawing can look unified while holding more than one type of source.

The Met's history of the School of Fontainebleau[2] describes the production of prints after drawings by Primaticcio and others in the 1540s and names Davent among the important printmakers in that circle. Such prints spread Fontainebleau designs beyond the palace. Their existence offers a practical explanation for how an artist could study a French court design without needing every part of it to be present on the same wall or in the same original drawing.

The source difference also changes how we look at the right-hand figure. A print fixes a pose in line and makes it portable; the stucco figures have physical relief and a site. Rubens could bring them into one drawn field, adjusting their scale and spacing so they converse. The sheet need not be a literal record of one moment spent looking at three figures together. Boijmans's account instead points to selection and combination.

We should not assume the exact print impression Rubens held, when he obtained it, or whether it was in his collection. The museum identifies a Davent print type as the model for the third figure; it does not provide a documented purchase or a surviving copy owned by Rubens. The supported point is the visual relationship and the differing source medium.

An older theory revised by looking at the sheet

Boijmans says the drawing was once thought to be an existing Primaticcio drawing that Rubens had reworked. Such an explanation would make the sheet a collaboration across decades: an earlier drawing physically altered by a later artist. The museum says, however, that no traces of an underdrawing are visible. On that basis, it no longer sustains the old account of Rubens working over a pre-existing Primaticcio sheet.

The revision is important because Rubens did alter some drawings by earlier artists. Boijmans notes that he owned drawings, including sixteenth-century Italian works, and sometimes changed them drastically. A practice established elsewhere in his collection can suggest a hypothesis for this object, but it cannot prove that this particular sheet was made in the same way. The material inspection narrows the claim. Here, the museum attributes the drawing itself to Rubens after Primaticcio's designs.

“No traces of an underdrawing” does not establish every movement of Rubens's hand or explain every line. It is evidence against the specific older proposal that an identifiable Primaticcio drawing lies beneath his intervention. It leaves room for normal uncertainty about how he prepared the sheet, which earlier images he had available at the same time, and whether the work was made over one sitting or several.

The museum's circa 1622–27 date is also a range, not a year written on the paper. It places the drawing in Rubens's mature career, long after the Fontainebleau caryatids were made. The time gap is part of the story: a design created for a sixteenth-century French royal palace became material for a seventeenth-century Flemish artist's study. The route from palace decoration through print and drawing shows how visual ideas could survive in new forms.

Why make a study after another artist?

Copying and adapting earlier art was a way to learn from it. In this sheet Rubens could examine the twist of a body, the lift of an arm, and the relation of figures to ornament. The drawing's close focus removes much of the original architectural setting, inviting the viewer to compare the women's poses directly. It records artistic attention, not a commission for a known finished Rubens painting.

The specific purpose of this sheet remains open in the sources cited here. Boijmans does not identify a later canvas for which it served as a preparatory design, and no documented patron is named. It is safer to call it a study after Primaticcio's designs than to assign it to an invented painting project. The drawing is valuable in its own right because it shows how Rubens looked, selected and recombined earlier forms.

Primaticcio was an Italian artist working in France. The Met's account of his career[3] says that, with Rosso, he oversaw decoration at Fontainebleau and became central to the style now called the School of Fontainebleau. The phrase “after Primaticcio” in the Rotterdam title therefore points to a wider artistic exchange across Italy, France and the Low Countries. It does not require us to imagine Rubens meeting Primaticcio: the two artists' careers did not overlap.

The sheet lets us watch that exchange at a human scale. A palace's large decorative figures become bodies on paper, each one small enough to compare at a glance. Chalk and wash replace stucco, and the printed right-hand model joins the sculptural pair. The drawing turns inherited ornament into an active exercise in line, volume and movement.

Collection identity and access

The museum lists the drawing in its Drawings & Prints department under V 6 recto (PK). Its credit line is a loan from the Stichting Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, associated with the former Koenigs collection, and the record gives 1940 as the acquisition or loan date. Franz Koenigs appears in its collector field. Those fields should be read carefully: a loan credit is not the same thing as saying the museum owns the sheet outright.

The online record currently marks the object as in storage. Display status can change, so visitors should consult the live Boijmans page[1] before planning to see the original. For identification, the stable details are the title, Rubens attribution, medium, dimensions and object number. They distinguish the sheet from Primaticcio's own works and from later images of Fontainebleau motifs.

The inherited name “Three Caryatids” remains in the URL, while the heading follows the museum's current title. That small editorial change serves a larger purpose: it tells the reader who made the surviving sheet and how its sources relate. Rubens drew the women; Primaticcio supplied earlier designs; Davent's print mediated one of them. Keeping those roles separate makes the work more interesting than a vague label of three figures.

Rubens artworks directory

128 artworks

NameDateMedium
A Seated Lion / Study of a Seated LionCirca 1612–1613Drawing
Adam and Eve1598–1600Painting
Albert Rubens in Profile to the LeftCirca 1619Drawing
Allegory of Emperor Charles V as Ruler of the WorldCirca 1604Painting
An Autumn Landscape with a View of Het Steen in the Early MorningProbably 1636Painting
Atalanta and Meleager Hunting the Calydonian Boar1635–1640Painting
Bildnis einer Frau / Portrait of a Woman (traditionally identified as Isabella Brant)Painting
Christ on the Cross / Christus aan het kruis (oil modello)1628Painting
Cows, Study for a PaintingDrawing
Daniel in the Lions' DenCirca 1614–1616Painting
Das Opfer Abrahams / The Sacrifice of Abraham (drawing after Titian)Drawing
Der Triumph des Siegers / The Triumph of VictoryCirca 1614Painting
Diana and CallistoCirca 1635Painting
Don Diego Messía (Mexía) Felipe de Guzmán, Marquis of LeganésDrawing
Epitaph of Nicolaas Rockox and His Wife Adriana Perez (traditionally The Incredulity of Thomas)1613–1615Painting
Equestrian Portrait of Giovan Carlo Doria / Ritratto di Giovan Carlo Doria a cavallo1607–1608Painting
Equestrian Portrait of the Duke of Lerma1603Painting
Ex-voto: Virgin and Child with portraits of the donors Alexandre Goubau and Anna AnthonyPainting
Ganymede / Ganymed1611–1612Painting
Georges Villiers, Herzog von Buckingham / George Villiers, Duke of BuckinghamDrawing
Gesatteltes Pferd / Saddled HorseCirca 1615–1618Drawing
Head of a Woman with Downcast Eyes (study for the Madonna of the Ildefonso Altarpiece)Drawing
I quattro filosofi / The Four PhilosophersCirca 1611–1612Painting
Ignudo Turning to the Right (after Michelangelo)Circa 1606Drawing
Juno and ArgusCirca 1610Painting
La Marche de Silène / The Procession of SilenusDrawing
Lamentation over the Dead Christ / Compianto su Cristo morto1601–1602Painting
Landscape with Philemon and BaucisPainting
Landscape with St George and the Dragon1630–1635Painting
Landscape with the Ruins of the Palatine Hill in Rome / Paysage avec les ruines du mont Palatin à RomeCirca 1614–1618Painting
Leda and the Swan (Stephen Mazoh collection version)Before 1600Painting
Les Pèlerins d'Emmaüs / The Supper at Emmaus (Saint-Eustache version)Circa 1608–1611Painting
Madonna della Vallicella Adored by Angels / Madonna con Bambino e angeli1606–1608Painting
Madonna in a Garland of Flowers / Madonna im BlumenkranzCirca 1616–1618Painting
Madonna Surrounded by Saints / Madonna met heiligenCirca 1630Painting
Marchesa Brigida Spinola Doria1606Painting
Marchesa Maria Serra Pallavicino (?)1606Painting
Marie de Medici, Queen of FranceCirca 1622Painting
Mercury and Argus / Merkur und ArgusCirca 1635–1638Painting
Neptune Calming the Tempest (Quos Ego); modello for the Cardinal Infante's voyage1635Painting
Nikolaus RubensDrawing
Ochse / OxCirca 1618Drawing
Old Woman and Boy with CandlesCirca 1616–1617Painting
Pan and SyrinxCirca 1617Painting
Perseus and AndromedaPainting
Perseus frees Andromeda1620–1622Painting
Philippe Rubens, the Artist's Brother1610Painting
Portrait du duc de Lerma / Study for the Equestrian Portrait of the Duke of LermaCirca 1603Drawing
Portrait of a Bearded Man / Bildnis eines Mannes mit VollbartCirca 1604–1605Drawing
Portrait of a Man, Possibly an Architect or Geographer1597Painting
Portrait of Aletheia Talbot, Countess of Arundel1620Painting
Portrait of Anne of Austria, Queen of FranceCirca 1622Painting
Portrait of George Gerbier, son of Balthasar Gerbier (identification qualified)1629–1630Drawing
Portrait of Isabella Brant (portrait drawing)Circa 1620–1621Drawing
Portrait of Louis XIII, King of FranceCirca 1622Painting
Portrait of Marie de Médicis as a Triumphant QueenPainting
Portrait of Nicolas Trigault in Chinese Costume1617Drawing
Portrait of the Emperor Charles V (after Titian)Circa 1603–1605Painting
Prometheus BoundPainting
Romulus and Remus / Romolo e Remo1612Painting
Rubens and Isabella Brant in the Honeysuckle BowerCirca 1609–1610Painting
Saint George and the Dragon1606–1608Painting
Saint Gregory with Saints, venerating the Madonna of Vallicella1606–1607Painting
Saint James the Greater / Santiago el Mayor1610–1612Painting
Saint Jerome in His Study / Der heilige HieronymusCirca 1609–1610Painting
Saint Sebastian / Der heilige Sebastian1618Painting
Saints Amandus and Walburga, exterior wing of The Elevation of the Cross1609–1610Painting
Saints Catherine of Alexandria and Eligius, exterior wing of The Elevation of the Cross1609–1610Painting
Salome Presented with the Head of Saint John the BaptistCirca 1609Painting
Samson and DelilahCirca 1609–1611Painting
Satyr and Girl with a Basket of FruitCirca 1615Painting
Scipio and Hannibal before the Battle of ZamaDrawing
Self-portrait1623Painting
Self-Portrait in a Circle of Friends from MantuaCirca 1602–1605Painting
Study of the Laocoön and His Sons (after the ancient Vatican sculpture)1601–1602Drawing
Summer: Peasants Going to MarketPainting
Susanna FourmentCirca 1620Drawing
The Adoration of the Magi / L'Adoration des magesCirca 1617–1618Painting
The AnnunciationCirca 1610Painting
The Arrival of the Queen at Lyon (Meeting of King and Queen, 9 December 1600)Painting
The Assumption of the Virgin Mary1625–1626Painting
The Baptism of Christ1604–1605Painting
The Battle of Anghiari (drawing after Leonardo's lost composition)Drawing
The Battle of the Amazons / Die AmazonenschlachtCirca 1618Painting
The Capture of Jülich, 1 September 1610Painting
The Child with the Bird / Das Kind mit dem VogelPainting
The Circumcision of Christ / La Circoncisione di Gesù1605Painting
The Consequences of War1638Painting
The Defeat of Sennacherib / Die Niederlage SanheribsCirca 1617Painting
The Descent from the Cross, triptych1611–1614Painting
The Discovery of the Child Erichthonius / Die Auffindung des ErichthoniusknabenCirca 1616Painting
The Disembarkation of the Queen at Marseille, 3 November 1600Painting
The Elevation / Raising of the Cross, triptych1609–1610Painting
The Entombment / Graflegging1615–1617Drawing
The Fall of PhaetonCirca 1604–05Painting
The Feast of HerodCirca 1635–1638Painting
The Feast of Venus1636–1637Painting
The Garden of Love / El jardín del amor1630–1635Painting
The Gonzaga Family in Adoration of the Holy Trinity / La famiglia Gonzaga in adorazione della Santissima TrinitàPainting
The Head of MedusaPainting
The Hippopotamus and Crocodile HuntCirca 1616Painting
The Holy Family with Saint AnneCirca 1630Painting
The Holy Family with Saint Elizabeth and Saint John the Baptist1614–1615Painting
The Immaculate Conception1628–1629Painting
The Judgement of Paris (Prado early Italian-period version)1606–1608Painting
The Kermesse / La Kermesse (also Village Festival)Circa 1635–1638Painting
The Lamentation of Christ / Die Beweinung Christi1610–1611Painting
The Last Supper / Institution of the Eucharist1631–1632Painting
The Lion Hunt / Löwenjagd1621Painting
The Massacre of the InnocentsPainting
The Massacre of the Innocents (early Toronto version)Circa 1610Painting
The Rainbow LandscapeCirca 1636Painting
The Rape of the Daughters of Leucippus / Raub der Töchter des LeukipposCirca 1618Painting
The Resurrection of Christ, Jan Moretus epitaph triptych1611–1612Painting
The Return from the Fields / Ritorno dai campiCirca 1632–1634Painting
The Three Graces1630–1635Painting
The Triumph of the Eucharist over IdolatryCirca 1625Painting
Three Groups of Apostles in a Last Supper (recto); Three Sketches for Medea and Her Children (verso)About 1601–1602Drawing
Three Women Holding Garlands (after Francesco Primaticcio)Circa 1622–1627Drawing
Two Young Women, the One on the Left Holding a Dog / Zwei junge Frauen, die linke hält einen HundCirca 1616–1618Drawing
Venus and Adonis (Hermitage swan-chariot version)1610–1611Painting
Venus and Adonis (Metropolitan Museum late version)Painting
Venus Frigida1614Painting
Venus in Front of the Mirror / The Toilet of VenusCirca 1614–1615Painting
Venus Lamenting over the Dead AdonisCirca 1612Drawing
Venus, Amor, Bacchus und Ceres / Venus, Cupid, Bacchus and CeresCirca 1612–1613Painting
Wolf and Fox HuntCirca 1616Painting
Young Woman Looking Down (Study for the Head of Saint Apollonia)Circa 1628Drawing

Frequently Asked Questions

Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen identifies Peter Paul Rubens as draughtsman. “After Francesco Primaticcio” names the earlier designs he studied, not the maker of the Rotterdam sheet.

The museum relates the two women at left probably to Primaticcio's caryatid stuccoes at Fontainebleau. It identifies a Léon Davent print after Primaticcio as the model for the woman at right.

That was an older theory. Boijmans reports no traces of an underdrawing and no longer presents the sheet as a Primaticcio drawing reworked by Rubens.

The museum dates it circa 1622–27 and lists red chalk, brown wash and white heightening. It measures 269 × 253 millimetres.

The museum's online record currently marks it in storage. Check the current object page for any change in access or display.

Discussion

Compare the poses and decorative garlands across the three women.

Share an observation about the sheet or a reliable source that adds to its history.

Reader Insights

Close Looking

How does the right-hand figure differ from the pair at left?

Context

Where do wash and white heightening make the bodies feel sculptural?

Open Question

What does the revised attribution tell us about Rubens's way of studying earlier art?

Join the Conversation

Add your reading below, keeping observations specific and evidence clear.

References

  1. Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Three Women Holding Garlands (after Francesco Primaticcio) , V 6 recto (PK). View source
  2. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Fontainebleau , history of palace decoration and printmaking. View source
  3. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Primaticcio's separate Two Nymphs Carrying a Third. View source