Phaeton falls among rearing horses and winged figures as a burst of light crosses Rubens's painting Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 14, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

A chariot loses its course

Rubens's The Fall of Phaeton catches disaster while it is still unfolding. Phaeton falls headfirst from the Sun's chariot. Horses rear, turn and break away; figures with butterfly-like wings recoil around him. A strong stream of light enters from the upper right, while small flames appear far below. The chariot's intended path through the heavens no longer seems to hold. The eye can follow individual bodies, but it cannot make the group settle into a stable procession.

This oil painting on canvas is in the National Gallery of Art in Washington[1], accession 1990.1.1, and measures 98.4 × 131.2 centimetres. The NGA dates its beginning to about 1604–05 and says it was probably reworked about 1606–08. A later technical study by NGA conservator E. Melanie Gifford argues for a further, final phase around 1610–12, after Rubens returned from Italy to Antwerp. The two dates should be read together: they record a work that changed, and the Gallery's current public label has not yet adopted every detail of the later proposed sequence. The composition visible today may not be identical with the one Rubens first painted.

A small reproduction helps locate the main figures and the shaft of light, while the conservation study provides magnified and technical images for details that are otherwise difficult to see. The painting's subject is a mythic loss of control; its surface is also evidence of Rubens repeatedly reconsidering how to represent that loss.

At a Glance

  • ArtistPeter Paul Rubens [1]
  • DateBegun c. 1604–05; later revisions debated [1][2]
  • MediumOil on canvas [1]
  • Dimensions98.4 × 131.2 cm [1]
  • CollectionNational Gallery of Art, Washington, 1990.1.1 [1]

Where this work sits in Rubens's career

Rubens's career
16001610162016301640

Contents

  1. What happened to Phaeton?
  2. How is the collapse organised?
  3. An earlier painting under the present one
  4. A final revision after Rubens's return
  5. How did it reach Washington?

What happened to Phaeton?

In Book II of Ovid's Metamorphoses, Phaeton wants proof that he is the Sun god's son and asks to drive his father's chariot for a day. His father warns that even he finds the route difficult, but his promise cannot be withdrawn. Phaeton cannot control the horses. The chariot strays from its course, and the Earth alternately suffers cold and destructive heat. Jupiter finally throws a thunderbolt to stop the catastrophe, sending Phaeton down to his death. The University of Virginia's text of Ovid[4] gives the narrative that Rubens compresses into one moment.

Rubens does not paint the conversation with the Sun god or a later scene of mourning. He shows the turning point after the journey has failed. The NGA's account[1] identifies the winged women as the Horae, figures associated with the hours or seasons and the regular order of the universe. Their alarm enlarges the event beyond one young driver's death: the rhythms of sky and Earth have been disturbed. The arching bands of the heavens and the flames below make that cosmic scale visible.

Jupiter is outside the picture. The light that enters from the right conveys the force of his intervention, but there is no painted standing god to find among the horses. This matters for reading the action. Rubens turns an unseen decision into a physical change of direction. The chariot breaks apart, the figures scatter, and Phaeton's body descends through them. The viewer sees the consequence of a thunderbolt rather than its wielder.

The tale attracted moral readings in Rubens's time. The NGA cites Karel van Mander's 1604 interpretation: the chariot can warn against failing to keep a moderate course, and against the harm that an inexperienced ruler may cause a whole community. The Gallery says such ideas may lie behind Rubens's painting. They are useful historical context, not evidence of a personal political statement from Rubens or a known commission for this canvas. Its immediate subject remains the collapse that the body, horses, light and burning landscape make visible.

How is the collapse organised?

At first glance the figures appear to tumble without a pattern. Rubens nevertheless gives the eye routes through the disorder. The light cuts diagonally across the upper right. A curving celestial band sweeps around the left. The horses' heads and legs rise toward the bright edge, while Phaeton's falling body pulls attention down. The winged Horae are caught between those contrary directions. The result is an image of failed steering made by a carefully steered composition.

The painting's small scale relative to Rubens's later altarpieces makes its density surprising. Many heads, limbs, wings and lengths of harness occupy a canvas just over a metre wide. The chariot's red and gold, the grey and white horses, and the dark blue sky let the viewer separate parts of the wreckage. Light does more than reveal the participants: it seems to press them away from the course they should have followed.

The Gallery's visual description[1] counts eleven women in the visible picture. Some are clothed, others nude, and only some show the patterned wings that help identify the Horae. They are not arranged in a neat ring around Phaeton. One group presses against the curved band at the left, while others are caught beside or below the horses. The scattered positions make the collapse legible in stages: order breaks at the edge of the sky, the horses pull free, and figures who should mark regular time lose their bearings. The bright clothing also gives the eye small points of orientation amid the overlapping bodies. Counting the figures is useful, but it does not turn them into eleven named individuals with separate stories. Their collective reaction is what the NGA identifies. The count also refers to the present surface. Gifford's X-radiograph reveals a suppressed twelfth figure at lower right, so a technical account of what Rubens once painted and a description of what a visitor now sees need different numbers.

Some apparent oddities are traces of design decisions. The NGA notes[1] reins and harness straps Rubens painted over but which remain perceptible. These pentimenti, or changes made by the artist, show that the confusion did not emerge from one uninterrupted burst of painting. Gifford's study demonstrates that the present image contains several campaigns of work. A viewer can respond to its turbulence without seeing every concealed line, but the hidden evidence changes what the turbulence means as an artistic achievement.

An earlier painting under the present one

Gifford's 2019 technical study[2] reconstructs three stages rather than one. Rubens began the picture in Italy on a fine-weave canvas with a yellow-tan preparation. He sketched the figures in brown paint directly on that ground. Some of the ground and sketch lines remain part of the finished appearance, particularly in light details such as hair and wings. This was a way to make a complicated group move quickly on the surface without finishing every contour to the same degree.

The first stage, begun around 1604–05, was darker and more literal in its violence than the picture now appears. Technical imaging reveals a dark, pre-dawn sky, a narrower stroke of lightning and flames among the falling figures. Gifford identifies fire around a Hora and evidence that Phaeton's cloak itself once appeared to burn. A cloud of smoke and reflected red light intensified the impact. The figure group was already largely present, but it occupied a frightening setting in which Jupiter's weapon and the conflagration were harder to miss.

That reconstruction rests on several types of evidence, not on imagining an unseen lost painting from the myth. Infrared images expose dark paint below later layers, X-radiographs distinguish revisions, and close study of pigments separates red cloak from red fire. The article's reconstructions are scholarly visualisations of the evidence, not photographs of a complete earlier state. They help explain how a picture could become brighter and more abstract without Rubens replacing its whole cast of figures.

In the second stage, which Gifford places while Rubens was still in Italy, he reduced the flames and softened the explicit lightning into a broad burst of yellowish radiance. Grey and white clouds covered portions of the fire. He altered the lower right, suppressing one falling Hora and introducing the distant burning Earth. The emphasis moved from bodies caught in a literal inferno toward a diagonal force of light passing through them. Gifford argues that the painting was still unresolved at this point and was set aside. She offers the sequence as a reasoned interpretation of the layered paint, rather than a dated studio diary.

A final revision after Rubens's return

Gifford's most consequential proposal is that Rubens completed a third stage in Antwerp, around 1610–12. He narrowed and focused the wash of light, brushed blue sky around some figures and covered more of the earlier reins. He also painted a brilliant white horse over parts of the existing design. Gifford counts five horses in the resulting composition, although Ovid's chariot has four; the NGA's shorter public visual description counts four visible horses. Her technical finding concerns a painted addition that is hard to separate at a glance in the crowded group. The added animal crowns the central group and gives the horses' rearing movement a sharper visual peak. Rubens also brightened the neighbouring grey horse so the two would read together.

The case for a later campaign is material as well as stylistic. In a tiny existing loss at the white horse's shoulder, a paint sample shows the layers in order: early smoke, then golden light, then blue sky and the white horse. The earlier layers appear to have cured before the last were applied. Gifford also finds differences in the supplies of some pigments across stages. Rubens used indigo in part of the first sky and ultramarine in the later blue passages. No single pigment proves where a painter was working, but the combination of a time gap, material differences and comparisons with Antwerp works supports her proposed return to the canvas after 1608.

This is why the NGA's brief label and the detailed study should not be collapsed into one date. The object page gives the long-standing public range of a painting begun about 1604–05 and probably reworked about 1606–08. Gifford's later research argues that the final white horse and related changes belong closer to 1610–12. The first stages and final appearance can therefore be separated in discussion without pretending that the precise month of any repainting is known.

Gifford compares the final horses with Rubens's Conversion of Saint Paul[5] and Death of Hippolytus. The related pair of rearing animals appears as Rubens works through several crowded subjects around 1610–12. Her point is not that the Phaeton painting is a copy of those works, or that they are copies of it. She argues that Rubens revisited related compositional problems across paintings, moving between projects and testing new arrangements. That process makes the Washington canvas a record of artistic thinking over time.

How did it reach Washington?

The NGA's provenance notes[1] identify a Phaeton on canvas by Rubens in the 1657 inventory of Susanna Willemsens in Antwerp and mark the connection to the Washington painting as probable. A possible 1775 sale is less secure. Later ownership is clearer: the work was in the Caledon family before 1857 and passed through successive earls. At a London sale in 1939 it appeared under the name of Abraham van Diepenbeeck, a historical attribution that differs from the NGA's present catalogue credit to Rubens. The Gallery purchased the painting in 1990 through its Patrons' Permanent Fund.

These changes of attribution and ownership matter because the painting's meaning did not stay fixed once it left Rubens's studio. A nineteenth-century observer also described it as a copy after Rubens, according to the NGA bibliography. The current attribution draws on the Gallery's direct object study, including the revisions Gifford traces through the paint. The earlier sale labels remain part of its collecting history, while the painting is now catalogued as Rubens.

Rubens artworks directory

128 artworks

NameDateMedium
A Seated Lion / Study of a Seated LionCirca 1612–1613Drawing
Adam and Eve1598–1600Painting
Albert Rubens in Profile to the LeftCirca 1619Drawing
Allegory of Emperor Charles V as Ruler of the WorldCirca 1604Painting
An Autumn Landscape with a View of Het Steen in the Early MorningProbably 1636Painting
Atalanta and Meleager Hunting the Calydonian Boar1635–1640Painting
Bildnis einer Frau / Portrait of a Woman (traditionally identified as Isabella Brant)Painting
Christ on the Cross / Christus aan het kruis (oil modello)1628Painting
Cows, Study for a PaintingDrawing
Daniel in the Lions' DenCirca 1614–1616Painting
Das Opfer Abrahams / The Sacrifice of Abraham (drawing after Titian)Drawing
Der Triumph des Siegers / The Triumph of VictoryCirca 1614Painting
Diana and CallistoCirca 1635Painting
Don Diego Messía (Mexía) Felipe de Guzmán, Marquis of LeganésDrawing
Epitaph of Nicolaas Rockox and His Wife Adriana Perez (traditionally The Incredulity of Thomas)1613–1615Painting
Equestrian Portrait of Giovan Carlo Doria / Ritratto di Giovan Carlo Doria a cavallo1607–1608Painting
Equestrian Portrait of the Duke of Lerma1603Painting
Ex-voto: Virgin and Child with portraits of the donors Alexandre Goubau and Anna AnthonyPainting
Ganymede / Ganymed1611–1612Painting
Georges Villiers, Herzog von Buckingham / George Villiers, Duke of BuckinghamDrawing
Gesatteltes Pferd / Saddled HorseCirca 1615–1618Drawing
Head of a Woman with Downcast Eyes (study for the Madonna of the Ildefonso Altarpiece)Drawing
I quattro filosofi / The Four PhilosophersCirca 1611–1612Painting
Ignudo Turning to the Right (after Michelangelo)Circa 1606Drawing
Juno and ArgusCirca 1610Painting
La Marche de Silène / The Procession of SilenusDrawing
Lamentation over the Dead Christ / Compianto su Cristo morto1601–1602Painting
Landscape with Philemon and BaucisPainting
Landscape with St George and the Dragon1630–1635Painting
Landscape with the Ruins of the Palatine Hill in Rome / Paysage avec les ruines du mont Palatin à RomeCirca 1614–1618Painting
Leda and the Swan (Stephen Mazoh collection version)Before 1600Painting
Les Pèlerins d'Emmaüs / The Supper at Emmaus (Saint-Eustache version)Circa 1608–1611Painting
Madonna della Vallicella Adored by Angels / Madonna con Bambino e angeli1606–1608Painting
Madonna in a Garland of Flowers / Madonna im BlumenkranzCirca 1616–1618Painting
Madonna Surrounded by Saints / Madonna met heiligenCirca 1630Painting
Marchesa Brigida Spinola Doria1606Painting
Marchesa Maria Serra Pallavicino (?)1606Painting
Marie de Medici, Queen of FranceCirca 1622Painting
Mercury and Argus / Merkur und ArgusCirca 1635–1638Painting
Neptune Calming the Tempest (Quos Ego); modello for the Cardinal Infante's voyage1635Painting
Nikolaus RubensDrawing
Ochse / OxCirca 1618Drawing
Old Woman and Boy with CandlesCirca 1616–1617Painting
Pan and SyrinxCirca 1617Painting
Perseus and AndromedaPainting
Perseus frees Andromeda1620–1622Painting
Philippe Rubens, the Artist's Brother1610Painting
Portrait du duc de Lerma / Study for the Equestrian Portrait of the Duke of LermaCirca 1603Drawing
Portrait of a Bearded Man / Bildnis eines Mannes mit VollbartCirca 1604–1605Drawing
Portrait of a Man, Possibly an Architect or Geographer1597Painting
Portrait of Aletheia Talbot, Countess of Arundel1620Painting
Portrait of Anne of Austria, Queen of FranceCirca 1622Painting
Portrait of George Gerbier, son of Balthasar Gerbier (identification qualified)1629–1630Drawing
Portrait of Isabella Brant (portrait drawing)Circa 1620–1621Drawing
Portrait of Louis XIII, King of FranceCirca 1622Painting
Portrait of Marie de Médicis as a Triumphant QueenPainting
Portrait of Nicolas Trigault in Chinese Costume1617Drawing
Portrait of the Emperor Charles V (after Titian)Circa 1603–1605Painting
Prometheus BoundPainting
Romulus and Remus / Romolo e Remo1612Painting
Rubens and Isabella Brant in the Honeysuckle BowerCirca 1609–1610Painting
Saint George and the Dragon1606–1608Painting
Saint Gregory with Saints, venerating the Madonna of Vallicella1606–1607Painting
Saint James the Greater / Santiago el Mayor1610–1612Painting
Saint Jerome in His Study / Der heilige HieronymusCirca 1609–1610Painting
Saint Sebastian / Der heilige Sebastian1618Painting
Saints Amandus and Walburga, exterior wing of The Elevation of the Cross1609–1610Painting
Saints Catherine of Alexandria and Eligius, exterior wing of The Elevation of the Cross1609–1610Painting
Salome Presented with the Head of Saint John the BaptistCirca 1609Painting
Samson and DelilahCirca 1609–1611Painting
Satyr and Girl with a Basket of FruitCirca 1615Painting
Scipio and Hannibal before the Battle of ZamaDrawing
Self-portrait1623Painting
Self-Portrait in a Circle of Friends from MantuaCirca 1602–1605Painting
Study of the Laocoön and His Sons (after the ancient Vatican sculpture)1601–1602Drawing
Summer: Peasants Going to MarketPainting
Susanna FourmentCirca 1620Drawing
The Adoration of the Magi / L'Adoration des magesCirca 1617–1618Painting
The AnnunciationCirca 1610Painting
The Arrival of the Queen at Lyon (Meeting of King and Queen, 9 December 1600)Painting
The Assumption of the Virgin Mary1625–1626Painting
The Baptism of Christ1604–1605Painting
The Battle of Anghiari (drawing after Leonardo's lost composition)Drawing
The Battle of the Amazons / Die AmazonenschlachtCirca 1618Painting
The Capture of Jülich, 1 September 1610Painting
The Child with the Bird / Das Kind mit dem VogelPainting
The Circumcision of Christ / La Circoncisione di Gesù1605Painting
The Consequences of War1638Painting
The Defeat of Sennacherib / Die Niederlage SanheribsCirca 1617Painting
The Descent from the Cross, triptych1611–1614Painting
The Discovery of the Child Erichthonius / Die Auffindung des ErichthoniusknabenCirca 1616Painting
The Disembarkation of the Queen at Marseille, 3 November 1600Painting
The Elevation / Raising of the Cross, triptych1609–1610Painting
The Entombment / Graflegging1615–1617Drawing
The Fall of PhaetonCirca 1604–05Painting
The Feast of HerodCirca 1635–1638Painting
The Feast of Venus1636–1637Painting
The Garden of Love / El jardín del amor1630–1635Painting
The Gonzaga Family in Adoration of the Holy Trinity / La famiglia Gonzaga in adorazione della Santissima TrinitàPainting
The Head of MedusaPainting
The Hippopotamus and Crocodile HuntCirca 1616Painting
The Holy Family with Saint AnneCirca 1630Painting
The Holy Family with Saint Elizabeth and Saint John the Baptist1614–1615Painting
The Immaculate Conception1628–1629Painting
The Judgement of Paris (Prado early Italian-period version)1606–1608Painting
The Kermesse / La Kermesse (also Village Festival)Circa 1635–1638Painting
The Lamentation of Christ / Die Beweinung Christi1610–1611Painting
The Last Supper / Institution of the Eucharist1631–1632Painting
The Lion Hunt / Löwenjagd1621Painting
The Massacre of the InnocentsPainting
The Massacre of the Innocents (early Toronto version)Circa 1610Painting
The Rainbow LandscapeCirca 1636Painting
The Rape of the Daughters of Leucippus / Raub der Töchter des LeukipposCirca 1618Painting
The Resurrection of Christ, Jan Moretus epitaph triptych1611–1612Painting
The Return from the Fields / Ritorno dai campiCirca 1632–1634Painting
The Three Graces1630–1635Painting
The Triumph of the Eucharist over IdolatryCirca 1625Painting
Three Groups of Apostles in a Last Supper (recto); Three Sketches for Medea and Her Children (verso)About 1601–1602Drawing
Three Women Holding Garlands (after Francesco Primaticcio)Circa 1622–1627Drawing
Two Young Women, the One on the Left Holding a Dog / Zwei junge Frauen, die linke hält einen HundCirca 1616–1618Drawing
Venus and Adonis (Hermitage swan-chariot version)1610–1611Painting
Venus and Adonis (Metropolitan Museum late version)Painting
Venus Frigida1614Painting
Venus in Front of the Mirror / The Toilet of VenusCirca 1614–1615Painting
Venus Lamenting over the Dead AdonisCirca 1612Drawing
Venus, Amor, Bacchus und Ceres / Venus, Cupid, Bacchus and CeresCirca 1612–1613Painting
Wolf and Fox HuntCirca 1616Painting
Young Woman Looking Down (Study for the Head of Saint Apollonia)Circa 1628Drawing

Frequently Asked Questions

It is in the National Gallery of Art, Washington, accession 1990.1.1.

No. His thunderbolt acts from outside the frame; Rubens represents its force through light and the collapse of Phaeton's chariot.

The NGA labels it begun about 1604–05 and probably reworked about 1606–08. A 2019 conservation study proposes a further final revision in Antwerp around 1610–12.

The NGA identifies them as the Horae, figures of time or the seasons. Their disorder shows that Phaeton's failed journey has disrupted a larger cosmic order.

Discussion

Look closely at the falling figures, horses and force of light.

Share an observation about the painting or a reliable source that adds to its history.

Reader Insights

Close Looking

How does the light change the direction of the chariot group?

Context

Where can you see the traces of Rubens's revisions?

Open Question

How does Gifford's proposed final stage change your reading of the canvas?

Join the Conversation

Add your reading below, keeping observations specific and evidence clear.

References

  1. National Gallery of Art, The Fall of Phaeton , object record, visual account, provenance and bibliography. View source
  2. E. Melanie Gifford, “Rubens's Invention and Evolution: Material Evidence in The Fall of Phaeton ,” Journal of Historians of Netherlandish Art 11.2 (2019). View source
  3. Gifford, “Exploration and Resources,” technical images and study guide. View source
  4. Ovid, Metamorphoses , Book II, University of Virginia Electronic Text Center. View source
  5. Conversion of Saint Paul. View source