The Mass of the Angels (attributed to Dürer) Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 22, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

The Mass of the Angels (attributed to Dürer): Introduction

A church fills with creatures that its worshippers seem scarcely to notice. Angels gather around a great tablet, a priest stands before the altar, and small, improbable figures circulate between the monks. A house and a basket loom absurdly large among their bearers. In The Mass of the Angels , the difficulty of keeping one's thoughts on prayer becomes something that can be seen: the private thoughts of a congregation have crowded into the same room.

The drawing, dated about 1500 and currently attributed to Albrecht Dürer, belongs to the Musée des Beaux-Arts in Rennes. Brown pen and ink, watercolour and white gouache cover beige paper measuring 30.5 × 21.7 centimetres. [1]

Attribution note: The Rennes museum currently attributes this drawing to Dürer. The article explains competing views of its authorship. [1]

At a Glance

  • Date About 1500 [1]
  • Attribution Attributed to Albrecht Dürer [1]
  • Collection Musée des Beaux-Arts, Rennes [1]
  • TypeDrawing [1]

This work across Albrecht Dürer’s career

Contents

  1. A church full of competing images
  2. What happens during prayer
  3. The unfinished words on the tablet
  4. Whose drawing is it?
  5. Frequently Asked Questions

A church full of competing images

The first way through the composition is upwards. At the bottom, angels present a broad rectangular panel almost parallel to the picture surface. Above it, the church floor opens into a space occupied by the strange little visitors. Farther back, a standing figure faces the altar; steps lead towards a more settled arrangement of candlesticks and sacred furnishings. The Virgin and Child occupy the upper centre. This sequence gives the eye a destination, even when the activity on either side repeatedly pulls it away. [12]

The architecture helps hold the crowded sheet together. Two substantial columns divide the room, while arches rise over them and meet the curving vault. Behind the altar, an arched recess frames the central sacred image. At the right, a curtain hangs diagonally across an opening. The drawing makes the church intelligible through these large, simple shapes before filling it with smaller incidents. Its enclosing walls and overhead curves prevent the multitude from becoming a loose collection of figures on a blank page.

That framework is especially noticeable around the altar. Long horizontal edges establish the altar cloth and its platform; the tall candlesticks answer the verticals of the columns. An upright angel beside the altar extends its wings into the architecture. Below, a smaller winged figure inclines forward. The differences between standing, bowing and flying bodies make the sacred end of the room animated without giving it the restless, dispersing movement of the middle distance.

Along the sides, the monks are much more closely packed. Their hooded garments produce repeated slopes and hollows, interrupted by individual heads, hands and open books. On the right, a face near the lower edge of the group turns towards the space in front of it. Higher up, heads overlap in a dense sequence beside the column. The reader can follow the congregation as a group, then stop to examine its separate members, much as one might read individual faces in a crowded street.

The small intruders change that rhythm. A basket sits high on the back of a thin, striding creature near the centre. Nearby, a little building with a pitched roof stands among figures much too small for it. Elsewhere, vessels, birds and twisting bodies interrupt the intervals between the worshippers. Ordinary things have acquired the disproportion of a compelling thought: a household object can occupy as much attention as a person. Their scale and unstable movements make the church feel invaded by fragments of other lives.

At the bottom, the angels have a different physical presence. Their broad wings, flowing sleeves and bent knees frame the tablet on three sides. Feathers spread out towards the corners; hands grip or approach its upper edge. Several heads turn across the group, so that even this apparently formal presentation contains a web of glances. The tablet is unusually open and pale beside the dense drawing above it. It offers a pause, but the marks on its surface create another small puzzle.

What happens during prayer

Hartmut Scholz describes the subject as the recording of pious and sinful thoughts during choral prayer, giving the scene a moral and satirical purpose. [12]

Such imagery belongs to a long tradition of stories about failures of attention in church. In her study of the recording demon, Margaret Jennings distinguishes two recurring narratives. One concerns a devil who writes down churchgoers' idle words; another concerns a devil who collects omitted or carelessly shortened syllables of prayer in a sack. These stories make neglect tangible: something apparently fleeting becomes evidence that can be carried away and used against the worshipper. Jennings also finds that many Continental pictures of writing devils leave the creatures unnamed. That history helps explain the drawing's moral imagination without requiring every grotesque in Rennes to be assigned the name Tutivillus. [13]

The effect here is more unsettling than a simple procession of monsters. The monks remain in their places, recognisable as a community at worship, while the fantastical figures take possession of the spaces between them. Their disturbance does not need to demolish the church or overturn the altar. It operates within an outwardly ordered service. The disproportionate house and the burdensome basket catch our attention precisely because they are so specific. The viewer experiences something of the wandering attention that the image exposes, repeatedly leaving the altar to inspect another fascinating interruption.

The Rule of Saint Benedict supplies a useful point of comparison. Chapter 19 tells monks to remember that they sing before God and the angels, and ends by requiring agreement between mind and voice. Chapter 20 places the value of prayer in humility and purity of heart, rather than the quantity of speech. The drawing's visible angels and distracted congregation make that demand especially vivid. This comparison illuminates the tension in the image; it does not establish that the artist was illustrating those chapters directly. A monk's presence in church, his book and his part in the communal service cannot by themselves show where his mind has gone. [14]

The unfinished words on the tablet

The foreground panel draws that problem of attention towards the reader. Its ornamental flourishes include loops, crossings and repeated letter-like forms, some resembling monogram trials. They are quite different from the compact line of writing along the top. The legible instruction reads, in Scholz's transcription, “Do schreibt hrein was Ir wollt”: “Write in here whatever you want.” The contrast is striking. Angels solemnly display a place for an inscription, but the artist leaves its eventual wording to someone else. [12]

Laboratory analysis reported in the Rennes catalogue record found that the inscription's ink matched the drawing's ink; the record identifies the words as the draughtsman's own. [1]

Scholz argues that the instruction demonstrates intended execution by another hand. He relates the sheet closely to the Saint Benedict stained glass designs associated with Nuremberg's Egidien monastery, while cautioning that Friedrich Winkler's proposal of a stained glass destination for this composition remains unproved. A richly developed design could still reserve decisions for the next person who used it. [12]

The colour reproduction also rewards looking beyond the dark outlines. Restrained blue and green passages interrupt the prevailing warm brown, with colour appearing in scattered details rather than dividing the sheet into broad painted zones. Much of the architecture remains close to the paper's tone. Closely spaced pen strokes describe shadow, curved feathers and the folds of clothing; relatively bare intervals allow the floor and altar cloth to breathe. These changes of density keep the many different surfaces legible within a very small space.

Whose drawing is it?

The current attribution remains qualified. The Rennes record notes support for Dürer from Winkler in 1936 and Arlette Calvet in 1966, and for Hans von Kulmbach from Lisa Oehler in 1968 and Fritz Koreny in 2000. Stephanie Porras and, in 2011, Jaya Remond supported Dürer; Remond distinguished the sheet from a separate Kulmbach copy, shown on the art market in 2004, as the work of another hand. [1]

The sheet came from Christophe-Paul de Robien's collection. It entered state ownership through revolutionary seizure in 1791 and was deposited in Rennes in 1794. Its present inventory number is 794.1.2533; older literature uses C 110, 1. [1]

Uncertainty about authorship need not flatten the experience of looking. The sheet's particular invention lies in the way it keeps a solemn church service visible through an unruly traffic of competing images. Its crowded centre asks us to notice what the monks should resist; its angels hold up a space in which words still need to be chosen. Following those details brings us back to the same demanding subject: how outward participation in prayer can coexist with a mind occupied elsewhere.

Frequently Asked Questions

When was it made?

About 1500 [1]

Who is the work currently attributed to?

Attributed to Albrecht Dürer [1]

Which collection is the work associated with?

Musée des Beaux-Arts, Rennes [1]

Artworks directory

These 187 records include individual works, reverse sides, detail views, paired panels and reconstructed arrangements. Three additional catalogue images repeat works already listed. Related views are not counted as separate originals; qualified attributions and published dating are retained.

187 records

NameDateMedium
A Greyhoundc. 1500–1501Drawing
A Hare Bearing the Date 1528 (Hans Hoffmann)c. 1580–1585Drawing
A Lion, 14941494Drawing
A Nuremberg Woman and a Venetian Womanc. 1495Drawing
Adam and Eve: Dürer’s Engraving of 15041504Engraving
Adoration of the Wise Men (1524 drawing)1524Drawing
Albrecht Dürer’s Self-Portrait of 15001500Painting
Allegory of Avarice1507Painting
Alliance Coat of Arms1490Painting
An Eastern Ruler Seated on His Thronec. 1495Drawing
Angel Appearing to Joachimc. 1504Woodcut
Apollo and Dianac. 1503–1505Engraving
Apostles Philip and James, paired paintings1516Painting
Bacchanal with Silenus (after Mantegna)1494Drawing
Bat (formerly attributed to Dürer)c. 1600Drawing
Bearded Saint in a Forest: Grünewald’s Proposed Mosesc. 1516Drawing
Bird in Three ViewsDate uncertainDrawing
Bird with Outstretched Wings (Draft for a Book Sign: Crane)Inscribed 1513Drawing
Blue-Flowering Iris1508Drawing
Charlemagne: The Costume Study1510Drawing
Christ and the Disciples at Emmausc. 1510Woodcut
Christ Bearing the Cross (Small Passion)1509Woodcut
Christ before Pilate (Small Passion)c. 1508–1509Woodcut
Christ Being Nailed to the Cross (Small Passion)c. 1509Woodcut
Christ Carrying the Cross (Engraved Passion)1512Engraving
Christ Crowned with Thorns (Engraved Passion)1512Engraving
Christ on the Mount of Olives (Large Passion)c. 1496–1497Woodcut
Christ Shown to the People (Small Passion)c. 1509Woodcut
Christ Taken Captive (Large Passion)1510Woodcut
Christ Taking Leave of His Mother (Life of the Virgin)c. 1504–1505Woodcut
Christ’s Entry into Jerusalem (Small Passion)c. 1508–1509Woodcut
City of Trento from the North1495; date debatedDrawing
Crab (formerly attributed to Dürer)c. 1494–1495; attribution withdrawnDrawing
Dead Blue Rollerc. 1500Drawing
Design for a Goblet1495–1500Drawing
Dosso di Trento (Trintperg)1495 or 1496Drawing
Dresden Altarpiece, with qualified wing attributionc. 1496Painting
Dürer’s Adam and Eve, 15071507Painting
Dürer’s Adoration of the Magi, 15041504Painting
Dürer’s All Saints: the Landauer Altarpiece1511Painting
Dürer’s Christ Among the Doctors1506Painting
Dürer’s Feast of the Rosary1506Painting
Dürer’s Four Apostles1526Painting
Dürer’s Heller Altarpiece1507–1509Painting
Dürer’s Nemesis (The Great Fortune)c. 1501–1502Engraving
Dürer’s Prodigal Sonc. 1496Engraving
Dürer’s Rhinoceros1515Woodcut
Dürer’s Salvator Mundic. 1505Painting
Dürer’s Sea Monsterc. 1498Engraving
Emperor Maximilian I, Nuremberg canvas1519Painting
Emperors Charlemagne and Sigismundc. 1511–1513Painting
Expulsion from Paradise (Small Passion)1510Woodcut
Flagellation (Small Passion)c. 1509Woodcut
Four Naked Women1497Engraving
Girl from Cologne and Agnes Dürer1521Drawing
Glim Lamentationc. 1500Painting
Great Piece of Turf1503Drawing
Hands Holding a Book1506Drawing
Head of a Roebuckc. 1502–1503Drawing
Head of an Apostle Looking Downward1508Drawing
Head of an Apostle Looking Upward1508Drawing
Head of the Dead Christ1503Drawing
Heavenly Body in the Night Skyc. 1496Painting
Hercules at the Crossroadsc. 1498Engraving
Heron (Garza)1515Drawing
Hymn in Adoration of the Lambc. 1496–1497Woodcut
Innsbruck Seen from the Northc. 1495; dating debatedDrawing
Innsbruck: The Hofburg and Wappenturm (Detail)c. 1495; detailDrawing
Iris Troianac. 1503; attributedDrawing
Jabach Altarpiece, paired outer wingsc. 1503–05Painting
Knight on HorsebackDate not securely establishedDrawing
Knight, Death and the Devil1513Engraving
Lamentation from the Large Passionc. 1498–1499Woodcut
Laughing Peasant Woman1505Drawing
Little Owl Attributed to Dürer1502 or 1508 (?)Drawing
Lobster1495Drawing
Lot and His Daughters, reverse of the Haller Madonnac. 1496–99Painting
Lute-playing Angel1497Drawing
Madonna and Child with the Pear, 15261526Painting
Madonna of the Carnation1516Painting
Madonna of the Pear, 15121512Painting
Madonna with the Swaddled Infant1520Engraving
Man of Sorrowsc. 1492–1493Painting
Map of the Northern Sky1515Woodcut
Map of the Southern Sky1515Woodcut
Martagon LilyMiddle to late sixteenth centuryDrawing
Martyrdom of the Ten Thousand1508Painting
Melencolia I1514Engraving
Monkey: an Escorial Animal StudyDate uncertainDrawing
Nativity1504Engraving
Nutcracker: the Louvre Bird StudyExecution date not establishedDrawing
ParrotExecution date not establishedDrawing
Paumgartner Altarpiecec. 1500Painting
Penance of Saint John Chrysostomc. 1497Engraving
Piper and Drummer from the Jabach Altarpiecec. 1503–1504Painting
Portrait of a Clergyman (Johann Dorsch?)1516Painting
Portrait of a Girl with a Red Beret1507Painting
Portrait of a Man Aged Ninety-Three1521Drawing
Portrait of a Man with Beret and Scroll1521Painting
Portrait of a Man, Kisters collectionPublished as 1497; current dating unverifiedPainting
Portrait of a Young Man, 15081508Drawing
Portrait of a Young Venetian Woman1505Painting
Portrait of a Young Woman with Her Hair Down1497Painting
Portrait of Barbara Dürer1490Painting
Portrait of Bernhard von Reesen1521Painting
Portrait of Burkhard von Speyer1506Painting
Portrait of Dürer’s Father at SeventyPossibly later sixteenth centuryPainting
Portrait of Elsbeth Tucher1499Painting
Portrait of Emperor Maximilian I1519Painting
Portrait of Hans Tucher1499Painting
Portrait of Hieronymus Holzschuher1526Painting
Portrait of Jakob Fugger the Wealthyc. 1520Painting
Portrait of Jakob Muffel1526Painting
Portrait of Johannes Kleberger1526Painting
Portrait of Lucas Cranach the Elderc. 1524Drawing
Portrait of Michael Wolgemut1516Painting
Portrait of Oswolt Krel1499Painting
Portrait of the Artist’s Father 14901490Painting
Portrait of the Artist’s Mother 15141514Drawing
Praying Hands1508Drawing
Primula (Tuft of Cowslips)Dating disputed; later 1526 inscriptionDrawing
Rhinoceros (Pen and Ink)1515Drawing
Saint Anthony1519Engraving
Saint Eustacec. 1501Engraving
Saint George on Horseback1508Engraving
Saint Jerome in His Study, 1514,1514Engraving
Saint Jerome in the WildernessMid-1490sPainting
Saint Jerome, 1521: Dürer’s Lisbon Painting1521Painting
Saint John’s Churchc. 1494Drawing
Self-Portrait 14981498Painting
Self-Portrait at Thirteen1484Drawing
Self-Portrait Holding a Thistle 14931493Painting
Seven Sorrows of the Virgin, reconstructed arrangementc. 1495–98Painting
Sketch of a Table Fountain1495–1500Drawing
Small Horse1505Engraving
St John Eating the Book1497–1498Woodcut
Stag Beetle1505Drawing
Standing Apostle (Study of a Man in Drapery)1508Drawing
Studies of Dürer’s Left Hand1493/1494Drawing
Study of a Man with a Drillc. 1495–1497Drawing
Study of Christ’s Upper Body1508Drawing
Study of Drapery for Christ in the Heller Altarpiece1508Drawing
Study of the Feet of an Apostlec. 1508Drawing
The Conversion of Paul (formerly attributed to Dürer)After 1500Engraving
The Crucifixion (1508 engraving)1508Engraving
The Crucifixion (Large Passion woodcut)c. 1498Woodcut
The Fall (Small Passion)c. 1509–1510Woodcut
The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse1498Woodcut
The Haller Madonnac. 1496–1499Painting
The Holzschuher Lamentationc. 1499–1500 or 1506–1507Painting
The Innsbruck Castle Courtyard with Cloudsc. 1495Drawing
The Innsbruck Castle Courtyard without Cloudsc. 1495Drawing
The Landauer Altarpiece Frame1511Sculpture
The Large Horse1505Engraving
The Last Judgement from the Small Passionc. 1510Woodcut
The Last Supper from the Large Passion1510Woodcut
The Lionc. 1495–1500 (?)Drawing
The Madonna with the IrisPossibly 1503–1508Painting
The Martyrdom of Saint Johnc. 1496–1498Woodcut
The Mass of the Angels (attributed to Dürer)c. 1500Drawing
The Meeting of Joachim and Anne at the Golden Gate1504Woodcut
The Mocking of Christ from the Small Passionc. 1508Woodcut
The Opening of the Seventh Seal and the Eagle Crying Woec. 1496–1498Woodcut
The Small Piece of Turf (Tuft of Grass: Minor)c. 1495–1500 (?)Drawing
The Storkc. 1500–1505Drawing
The Suicide of Lucretia1518Painting
The Virgin and Child with an Angel Playing the ViolProbably 1519Drawing
The Virgin and Child with Saint AnneProbably 1519Painting
The Virgin Nursing the Child1512Drawing
The Wire-Drawing Mill1489–1494Drawing
The Wire-Drawing Mill: Mill Buildings (Detail)1489–1494; detailDrawing
The Wire-Drawing Mill: River and Hallerwiese (Detail)1489–1494; detailDrawing
Three Studies of a Helmetc. 1498–1500Drawing
Title Page for Life of the Virginc. 1511Woodcut
Title Page of Small Passionc. 1511Woodcut
Title Page of the Large Passionc. 1511Woodcut
Tucher and Rieter coats of arms, reverse of Hans Tucher1499Painting
Two Seated Lions1521Drawing
Two Squirrels by Hans HoffmannExecution date not establishedDrawing
Valley near Kalchreuthc. 1495–1500Drawing
View of KalchreuthDate discussed in articleDrawing
View of NurembergMid-1490s or c. 1519; disputedDrawing
View of the Arco Valley in the Tyrolc. 1495Drawing
Walrus1521Drawing
Wing of a Blue Rollerc. 1500Drawing
Young Bullc. 1496Drawing
Young Hare1502Drawing

Discussion

Look again at the images and ideas explored in The Mass of the Angels (attributed to Dürer). These editorial prompts invite your observations.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Close Looking

Which detail or idea in The Mass of the Angels (attributed to Dürer) most changed your reading, and why?

Editorial prompt · Comparison

How does the discussion of “A church full of competing images” affect your understanding?

Editorial prompt · Context

What comparison would you bring to the discussion of “Whose drawing is it?”?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about The Mass of the Angels (attributed to Dürer) below.

References

  1. Olivia Savatier , La Messe des anges , Joconde notice 02110002354, French Ministry of Culture, updated 11 May 2026. French. View source .
  2. ALBERTINA, Selbstbildnis als Dreizehnjähriger, inv. 4839 (German). View source.
  3. Metropolitan Museum, Four Horsemen from The Apocalypse, 19.73.209 (English). View source.
  4. Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Selbstbildnis im Pelzrock, inv. 537 (German). View source.
  5. ALBERTINA, Feldhase, inv. 3073 (German). View source.
  6. ALBERTINA, Das große Rasenstück, inv. 3075 (German). View source.
  7. Metropolitan Museum, Adam and Eve, 19.73.1 (English). View source.
  8. ALBERTINA, Betende Hände, inv. 3113 (German). View source.
  9. Metropolitan Museum, Knight, Death, and the Devil, 43.106.2 (English). View source.
  10. Metropolitan Museum, Melencolia I, 43.106.1 (English). View source.
  11. Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, inventory 545: current collection record (German; descriptive citation). View source.
  12. Hartmut Scholz , “Zur Überlieferung des Benediktzyklus in den Kreuzgangsfenstern des Nürnberger Egidienklosters”, Dürer-Forschungen , 2 (2009), pp. 193–226, especially pp. 216–217, fig. 25 on p. 218, and notes 63–65 on p. 225. German, with English abstract. View source .
  13. Margaret Jennings , Tutivillus: The Literary Career of the Recording Demon , Studies in Philology , 74, no. 5 (December 1977), especially pp. 10–13 and 33. English. View source .
  14. Saint Benedict , The Rule of St. Benedict , English translation, preface by W. K. Lowther Clarke (London: S.P.C.K., 1931), chapters 19–20. English translation of Latin. View source .
  15. Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Barbara Dürer (German and English). View source.
  16. Web Gallery of Art, Tucher–Rieter reverse (English). View source.
  17. National Gallery of Art, Portrait of a Clergyman (English). View source.
  18. Dürer Art, Portrait of a Man (English). View source.
  19. Hessen Kassel Heritage, Elsbeth Tucher (German). View source.
  20. Web Gallery of Art, Hans Tucher (English). View source.
  21. Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Emperor Maximilian I (German and English). View source.
  22. National Gallery of Art, Lot and His Daughters, reverse (English). View source.
  23. Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Glim Lamentation (German). View source.
  24. Museo Nacional del Prado, Portrait of a Man (Spanish). View source.
  25. Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Madonna of the Carnation (German). View source.
  26. Städel Museum, Job on the Dungheap (German). View source.
  27. Wallraf-Richartz-Museum, Piper and Drummer (German). View source.
  28. Italian Ministry of Culture / Uffizi, Head of Saint James (Italian). View source.
  29. Klassik Stiftung Weimar, Dresden Altarpiece (German). View source.
  30. Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Girl with a Red Beret (German and English). View source.
  31. Dresden State Art Museums / Roland Enke, Bernhard von Reesen (German). View source.
  32. Royal Collection Trust, Burkhard von Speyer (English). View source.
  33. Dresden State Art Museums, Seven Sorrows of the Virgin (English). View source.
  34. Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Mater Dolorosa (German). View source.
  35. Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Lucretia (German). View source.
  36. Städel Museum, Young Woman with Her Hair Down (English). View source.
  37. ALBERTINA, Portrait of a Young Man (German). View source.