Young Woman with Peonies — Montpellier Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on November 2, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Young Woman with Peonies (Montpellier version): Introduction

A woman raises a flower towards a vase while holding another stem against her white blouse. Her eyes follow the arrangement rather than meeting ours. Around her hands, pale pink petals, deep red blooms and small white flower heads spread across the table. Frédéric Bazille gives the act of arranging flowers the scale and concentration of a portrait. The person doing the work is as consequential as the flowers being displayed.

Painted in 1870, this Young Woman with Peonies belongs to the Musée Fabre in Montpellier, inventory 18.1.3. It is the canvas with the large decorated vase, distinct from the basket composition now in Washington. Both paintings bring a Black woman into the foreground of Bazille’s art; their different gestures create different relationships between the sitter, her flowers and the spectator. [1] [2]

At a Glance

  • Date1870 [1]
  • MediumOil on canvas [1]
  • Dimensions60.5 × 75.4 cm [1]
  • CollectionMusée Fabre, Montpellier, 18.1.3 [1]

This work across Frédéric Bazille’s career

Contents

  1. Identifying the Montpellier painting
  2. Following the hands and the gaze
  3. A vase, a tabletop and several kinds of brightness
  4. Two oils and a work on paper
  5. Flowers were already part of Bazille’s ambitions
  6. Manet, the model and the roles within paintings
  7. A family gift and changing museum contexts

Identifying the Montpellier painting

The Montpellier picture is an oil on canvas measuring 60.5 × 75.4 cm. Its horizontal proportions make room for two substantial presences: the vase and its flowers on the left, the woman on the right. The signature and date sit at the lower left. In Michel Schulman’s catalogue raisonné it is MSb-60; the Washington painting has the separate number MSb-61. These identifiers matter because reproductions and older accounts can make the two compositions sound interchangeable. [1] [2]

The year is secure, although assigning an exact moment within it is less straightforward. The National Gallery of Art’s 2017 exhibition checklist dates both peony canvases to spring 1870. Their shared subject and similar scale invite comparison, but do not establish which Bazille painted first. The question remains open in the scholarship discussed by Schulman. It is more useful to approach them as two sustained treatments of a subject than to make one a preliminary step towards the other. [3] [4]

The Musée Fabre now calls the work Jeune femme aux pivoines, while recording its former racialised title, Négresse aux pivoines. The older wording remains part of the painting’s history, but the present title directs attention towards a young woman engaged in an activity. Neither title supplies her personal name. The visible individual and the unnamed person who posed for Bazille deserve to be considered together, without filling the documentary silence with an invented biography. [1] [2]

Following the hands and the gaze

Begin with the woman’s raised hand at the upper left. Its fingers grip a slender stem close to the dark background, beneath a small red flower. That hand is surrounded by taller stems, leaves and flower heads, but its warm colour and broad shape keep it legible. Across the painting, her other hand gathers a yellow-flowered branch near her chest. Between the two hands, her face turns towards the vase. The activity describes an open circuit: a stem, an attentive face, another stem waiting to be placed.

This is a particularly effective way of making a half-length figure active. We see neither the full body nor a large working space, yet the separated hands suggest reach, selection and adjustment. Her arms stretch across the arrangement instead of sitting decoratively beside it. One reaches towards the upper flowers; the other holds material in reserve. The picture catches a gesture whose outcome has not quite arrived. We can imagine the arrangement changing without needing to invent a story about who ordered it or where it will go.

Her gaze holds the structure together. It is directed across the surface, towards the flowers, and leads our eyes back into the painting. The forehead, cheek, nose and mouth remain clearly modelled even where the face approaches the dark ground. Her expression is attentive, but it does not disclose a private mood. Concentration is a useful description of the depicted action; melancholy, shyness or contentment would go beyond what the pose can establish.

The white blouse opens a broad light area around the face and hands. Small warm buttons descend along its front, while gathered edges and shadowed folds prevent the garment becoming a flat white screen. The sleeve at the lower right turns around the forearm and meets the cropped edge of the composition. Higher up, the striped headscarf introduces narrow lines and alternating colours against the relatively broad areas of skin and cloth. Its knot is visible behind the head, another small indication that the figure occupies space rather than simply forming a silhouette.

The arrangement allows our attention to alternate between doing and looking. The flowers are conspicuous enough to draw the eye immediately, but the hands explain their presence. Conversely, the woman is not presented apart from her task: the flower stems give her pose its shape. This reciprocity is the painting’s central achievement. A still life becomes an encounter with someone who handles, chooses and arranges its contents.

A vase, a tabletop and several kinds of brightness

The vase occupies much of the lower left. Its rounded dark body is covered with pale gold-coloured floral ornament. Against this patterned surface, the actual flowers have irregular edges, soft petals and varying degrees of openness. Bazille thus places one representation of flowers inside another: painted flowers rise above a vessel decorated with floral forms. The vessel’s controlled ornament makes the looseness of the living arrangement more noticeable.

The largest pale peonies spread outward above the vase. Their broken pink and white surfaces contrast with the red bloom beside them, which reads as a more compact mass. Higher stems interrupt the background with sharper leaves and smaller accents. At table level the flowers gather into a lower, denser band. White rounded clusters sit beside red petals and broad green leaves. There is no need to identify every plant to recognise how differently these forms behave: some droop, some spread, and others remain tightly gathered.

The tabletop gives this abundance a firm base. Its near edge runs along the bottom of the canvas, close enough to make the flowers feel within reach. The woman and the vessel rise from a continuous foreground rather than occupying separate compartments. Yet the arrangement is not equally dense everywhere. Small dark intervals between stems preserve their individual shapes, while the blouse supplies a much larger opening. The brightest patches have enough surrounding darkness to remain distinct.

That darkness has several functions. Behind the head it makes the scarf’s stripes conspicuous; around the flowers it separates petal from petal; within the vase it carries the ornament. A single dark setting can therefore accommodate several kinds of brightness. The blouse has relatively continuous folds, the gold-coloured pattern has crisp turns, and the peonies have scattered light touches. The pleasure of the painting comes partly from these differences in surface, rather than from flower colour alone.

Schulman emphasises the close packing of figure and flowers and relates the floral handling to the still lifes of Courbet and Fantin-Latour. Those comparisons place the canvas within a wider interest in substantial, closely observed flowers. They need not make it a demonstration of another painter’s manner. Here, the floral display acquires a particular rhythm from the woman’s movements, and the vase’s weight counters the lifted hand above it. [2]

Watch: Bazille and early Impressionism

Explore a Paris studio with Smarthistory, then discover the beginnings of Impressionism with the National Gallery of Art.

Two oils and a work on paper

In the Washington Young Woman with Peonies, the sitter faces outward and raises pale flowers towards the viewer. A broad basket and its contents occupy the foreground. The Montpellier vase instead establishes a more upright mass on one side, while her turned face directs attention towards the work in progress. The same broad combination of woman and flowers produces two different experiences: an outward presentation in Washington and an activity observed from nearby in Montpellier. [4]

The distinction is especially clear if we follow the raised hand in each picture. In Washington, its flowers can seem to be offered for our inspection. We become the possible recipient of a gesture, even though the painting does not specify a transaction. In Montpellier, the hand belongs to the arrangement’s internal construction. We watch a stem being held in relation to the other stems. The viewer is present as an observer without becoming the immediate object of the woman’s attention.

These differences make a simple opposition between an active and a passive sitter unhelpful. Both figures act; what changes is the direction and purpose suggested by the action. Nor does the frontal gaze provide a personal history that the averted gaze withholds. The two paintings give the model pictorial presence through different means. Their relationship becomes richer when neither is treated as the corrected or completed form of the other.

A third related work belongs to the Fitzwilliam Museum in Cambridge. Its Black Woman with Peonies, inventory PD.1-2004, combines watercolour and gouache with black chalk and graphite on card, and is dated about 1870. It is a separate work on paper, not a small oil replica of either canvas. Schulman discusses it as a possible preparatory study for Montpellier while also stressing its independent finish. That relationship remains a proposal rather than a securely dated sequence of study followed by painting. [5] [6]

The existence of three treatments is valuable evidence of Bazille’s interest in the subject. It shows him considering it across different materials as well as different poses. It does not tell us how many sittings took place, what the model said, or whether all three works arose from one uninterrupted campaign. The surviving images offer variations; they leave the practical timetable largely unresolved. [4] [6]

Young Woman with Peonies
Young Woman with Peonies

Flowers were already part of Bazille’s ambitions

The peony paintings grew from a sustained interest in flower painting. In its 2016 retrospective, the Musée Fabre placed Bazille’s floral work within the renewed enthusiasm for the genre among painters including Courbet, Fantin-Latour, Monet and Manet. Flowers offered opportunities to test colour, arrangement and material description. Bazille’s Study of Flowers, also called Potted Flowers, signed 1866 and accepted at the Salon of 1868, belongs to this earlier engagement. Its paper-wrapped bouquet also prompted the museum’s comparison with Manet’s Olympia. [7]

His correspondence supplies a more specific connection between flowers and figures. Writing to his mother in April 1867, Bazille described a painting in progress of two life-size women arranging flowers, which he hoped to finish when peonies were available. The letter records a project, rather than identifying the Montpellier canvas of three years later. It nevertheless establishes that the conjunction of women, arranging gestures and seasonal flowers had occupied him well before the two surviving peony oils. [8]

Technical research adds another piece of that earlier history. Bruno Mottin’s laboratory study reports a woman behind flowers beneath Bazille’s Still Life with Heron. Mottin also records Paul Perrin’s proposed links between that hidden composition and related figure and flower studies. This concerns a reused canvas elsewhere in Bazille’s work; it does not reveal an underpainting beneath the Montpellier peonies. It does show that a woman seen in relation to flowers was a subject he had explored and reconsidered. [9]

Seen against these earlier attempts, the Montpellier painting unites two kinds of attention Bazille had already cultivated. The flowers demand separate decisions about shape and colour, while the figure introduces coordinated movement. Neither element serves merely to fill the space left by the other. The red bloom beside the vase and the hand above it are linked by their positions and contrasting surfaces; the white flowers below the figure answer the blouse without repeating its structure. The composition makes its subject through those relationships.

Manet, the model and the roles within paintings

The connection with Manet is substantial. The Musée Fabre’s 2016 curators associated Bazille’s peony canvases with the Black woman holding flowers in Olympia, painted in 1863 and exhibited at the Salon in 1865. They also pointed to Manet’s interest in peonies as a still-life subject. Bazille brings these two elements together, allowing a figure associated with the margins of a larger scene to become the principal human presence of a flower painting. [7] [10]

The comparison becomes more precise when we ask where the woman’s attention goes. In Olympia, the flowers participate in an exchange involving other people. In Montpellier, no second figure directs the action. The woman’s hands and gaze organise the entire encounter. This change does not erase the racial and social conventions surrounding such imagery, but it alters the visual hierarchy. She has the space, activity and scale through which we understand the subject.

Bazille’s La Toilette offers a different arrangement. Its Black figure bends beside a reclining nude within an elaborate ensemble of bodies and textiles. Scholars have proposed that the model also posed for the peony paintings. The identification is plausible and frequently repeated, but her personal name is not established. Nor should the attendant’s role within La Toilette be mistaken for a record of the model’s actual occupation or circumstances. A real person posed for these scenes; the painter assigned different actions and relationships within them. [2] [7]

The Musée d’Orsay’s 2019 exhibition Black Models: From Géricault to Matisse, co-curated by Cécile Debray, Stéphane Guégan, Denise Murrell and Isolde Pludermacher, made the artist–model relationship central to its account of modern art. Its framing asked viewers to recognise Black models as participants in artistic life and to reconsider the conventions through which their images had been understood. This provides a productive context for Bazille’s paintings without supplying a missing identification. The name Laure, associated with Manet’s model, cannot simply be transferred to Bazille’s sitter. [10]

The distinction also changes how we read older criticism. Schulman’s discussion preserves a history of responses that move between floral exuberance, comparisons with Manet and judgements of the woman’s appearance. Some of that language racialises or sexualises the sitter. We can understand its place in the painting’s reception while attending more closely to what the picture gives her to do: hold stems, assess an arrangement and occupy a substantial part of the canvas. [2]

La Toilette
La Toilette

A family gift and changing museum contexts

Marc Bazille, the artist’s brother, gave the Montpellier canvas to the Musée Fabre in 1918. Its public life therefore belongs to the family’s long preservation and promotion of Bazille’s work. Michel Hilaire identifies the artist’s mother’s gifts of View of the Village and Still Life with Heron in 1898 as an important beginning of that recovery, followed by further family gifts and the work of historians and curators. The peonies entered a growing museum account of an artist whose career had ended in 1870. [1] [11]

The painting’s exhibition history shows how differently it could be framed. The Musée Fabre records its inclusion in the 1931 Colonial Exhibition in Paris, as well as the later Working Among Flowers exhibitions of 2014–15 and the Bazille retrospective of 2016–17. These settings place it within colonial display, flower painting and the study of a single artist respectively. The canvas remains the same; the surrounding questions change. [1]

The two canvases also travelled separately within the Black Models exhibition project. The 2019 Orsay dossier illustrates the Washington peony oil, alongside La Toilette and the Fitzwilliam work on paper. The Musée Fabre records that the Montpellier oil appeared at the Pointe-à-Pitre stage of the wider tour. The exhibition’s intellectual context is relevant to both oils, although their individual journeys differed. [10] [1]

Returning to Montpellier’s painting after these comparisons, the quiet precision of the gesture becomes more striking. Her turned head, reaching hand and waiting stem give the arrangement its human measure. Bazille leaves us with an activity held in balance: flowers gathered and still being gathered, a substantial vase and an attentive person whose task is still in progress.

Bazille catalogue directory

The 284 records comprise 85 painting records,40 separate works-on-paper records and 159 album or study records. They describe the catalogue’s organisation rather than 284 independent objects or unanimously accepted attributions. Recto, verso, albums and multiple studies remain distinct. Dates are qualified where needed; the Drawing filter includes the etching, gouache and mixed works on paper. Manuscript mentions and unproved projects are listed separately below.

Works known through documents

These mentions remain separate from the 284 catalogue records. Some may concern surviving studies or underlying compositions; they cannot simply be added together as missing physical paintings.

  • A copy after Rubens mentioned in March 1863 is unlocated.
  • A portrait of an unidentified woman was reported completed before July 1866.
  • A portrait of Monet and a composition of two life-size women arranging flowers were reported in progress in April 1867. Their mention does not establish two otherwise unknown surviving canvases.
  • Gertrude et le père Lapin was at least begun in the summer of 1870.

Further reported works and uncertain attributions

  • A Bouquet of Lilacs was reportedly stolen and returned in 1864; a portrait of the friend Theulier and Yellow Narcissi reported by Maître in 1868 are also documentary mentions.
  • Unidentified pictures associated with Guillemet and Mme Rolina are reported through later correspondence cited by the catalogue.
  • Children Dressed as Bride and Groom was associated with Vallotton’s collection and also attributed to Renoir. Its identification and authorship should remain open.

Projects whose completion is unproved

  • A portrait of Pauline was planned in July 1865.
  • A portrait of Marc was proposed in April 1866; a related drawing survives.
  • A Jardinière project appears in album inscriptions and related figure material. Written plans are not evidence of a completed painting.

284 records

NameDateMedium
Mystic Marriage of St. Catherine1863Oil on canvas
Trees, Study1863Oil on canvas
Farm of Saint-Sauveur1863Oil on canvas
In the Garden of the Parc Monceau, Paris1864Oil on canvas
Naked Woman from Behind1864Oil on canvas
Reclining Nude1864Oil on canvas
Courtyard of the Auberge du Cheval blanc at Chailly near Barbizon1864Oil on canvas
Covered Soup Bowls1864Oil on canvas
Two Herrings1864Oil on canvas
The Pink Dress1864Oil on canvas
The Dog Rita Asleep1864 (catalogue); c. 1864 (2017 checklist)Oil on canvas
The Scoter1864Oil on canvas
Naked Reclining Woman1864Oil on canvas
Landscape at Chailly1865Oil on canvas
Rocks at Chailly, Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Undergrowth at Chailly, Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Still Life with Grapes and Nuts1865Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait with a Palette — Chicago1865Oil on canvas
Landscape of Saint-Sauveur1865Oil on canvas
Beach at Sainte-Adresse1865Oil on canvas
The Improvised Field Hospital1865Oil on canvas
Village Street, Chailly1865Oil on canvas
Small Valley in the Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Woman Ironing1866Oil on canvas
The Artist's Studio on the rue de Furstenberg1865–66 (museum)Oil on canvas
Still Life with Fish1866Oil on canvas
Little Italian Street Singer1866Oil on canvas
Potted Flowers1866Oil on canvas
The Little Gardener1866–1867Oil on canvas
Young Woman Playing the Piano1866–1867Oil on canvas
End of a Summer Day1866–1867Oil on canvas
A Studio on the rue Visconti1867Oil on canvas
Thérèse Reading in the Park at Méric1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Verlaine1867Oil on canvas
The Terrace at Méric1867Oil on canvas
Still Life with Heron1867Oil on canvas
The Family Gathering1867–68 (museum)Oil on canvas
Oleanders1867Oil on canvas
Woman on the Terrace at Méric1867Oil on canvas
The Ramparts at Aigues-Mortes from South1867Oil on canvas
The Western Ramparts at Aigues-Mortes1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Edmond Maître — head study1867Oil on canvas
Porte de la Reine at Aigues-Mortes1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Sisley1867Oil on wood
Portrait of Renoir — Cleveland1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Renoir — Musée d’Orsay1867Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait with a Detachable Collar — Minneapolis1865–67 (museum); 1867–68 (catalogue)Oil on canvas
Vase of Flowers on a Console1868 (museum); 1867–68 (catalogue)Oil on canvas
Portrait of a Woman1868Oil on canvas
Young Woman in the Vineyards1868Oil on card
Harvester with a Basket1868Oil on card
Harvester with a Yellow Hat1868Oil on card
Harvester with a Headdress1868Oil on panel
On the Banks of the Lez1868Oil on canvas
After the Bath (attribution questioned)1868?Oil on canvas
Young Woman with Lowered Eyes1868Oil on canvas
Fisherman with a Net1868Oil on canvas
View of the Village1868Oil on canvas
Portrait of Bazille (attributed to Monet by Musée Fabre; disputed catalogue attribution)1864 (museum); 1868 (catalogue)Oil on panel
Studies for a Grape Harvest (two panels)1868Oil on canvas (two panels)
The Fortune Teller1868–69 (catalogue); c. 1869–70 (2017 checklist)Oil on canvas
Harvester with a Cap1869Oil on card
Portrait of Edmond Maître — 18691869Oil on canvas
Woman in a Moorish Costume1869Oil on canvas
Young Woman in the Garden1869Oil on canvas
Portrait of Alphonse Tissié in a Cavalryman's Uniform1869Oil on canvas
Portrait of a dragoon1869Oil on canvas
Portrait of Zacharie Astruc1869Oil on canvas
Bunch of Grapes in a Bucket1869Oil on card
Portrait of Edouard BlauProbably 1869; inscribed 1866Oil on canvas
Young Male Nude Lying on the Grass1870Oil on canvas
Summer Scene1869–1870Oil on canvas
The Studio on the rue La Condamine1869–1870Oil on canvas
La Toilette1870Oil on canvas
Young Woman with Peonies — Montpellier1870Oil on canvas
Young Woman with Peonies — Washington1870Oil on canvas
Monotonous Chant1870Oil on canvas
Flowers — private collection1870Oil on canvas
Flowers — Musée Fabre1870Oil on canvas
Young Fisherman1870Oil on canvas
Study for Ruth and Boaz1870Oil on wood
Ruth and Boaz1870Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait in Shirt Sleeves1870Oil on canvas
Landscape on the Banks of the Lez1870Oil on canvas
Study after an Alpine Landscape1860Graphite on watercolour-tinted paper
Profile Head1862Charcoal on laid paper
Studies after Delacroix1863Ink and graphite, with gouache and watercolour, on paper
Academic Head1863Charcoal on paper
Study of a Woman's Head in Profile on a Chair1863Charcoal on paper
Academic Head of a Woman1863Charcoal on paper
Academy of Woman1863Black pencil and charcoal, stumped, on watermarked laid paper
Academy of Man1863Black pencil and charcoal, stumped, on watermarked laid paper
Naked Man1863Charcoal on paper
The Pont au Change in Paris1864Watercolour on paper
Study for the Pink Dress or Portrait of Thérèse des Hours1864Black pencil on paper
Naked Woman Standing1864Pencil on paper
Study of a Reclining Nude1864Charcoal on paper
Bathers1864Charcoal on paper
Portrait of a Man1864Charcoal on paper
Study for The Pink Dress1864Black pencil, squared, on paper
Study for Landscape of Saint-Sauveur1864Graphite on paper
Study for Landscape of Saint-Sauveur1865Pencil on paper
Man Taming a Bull1866Pen and black pencil on paper
Man Half Lying on a Sofa1866Charcoal on paper
Study for The Family Gathering1867Pencil on paper
Study for The Family Gathering1867Graphite, charcoal and black pencil on paper
The Embroiderer1867Pencil on pink paper
Study of Children1867Pencil on paper
Women in a Garden1867Pencil drawing
View of the Village1868Etching on paper
Portrait of a Bearded Man (catalogued as Self-Portrait)Undated (museum); 1869 (catalogue)Charcoal and brown ink
Man Smoking Pipe1869Watercolour on paper
Manet Drawing1868–70(?) (museum)Charcoal and white chalk on paper
Study for the Summer Scene1869Charcoal, pen and ink on paper
Family Portrait1869Pastel and charcoal on paper
Study for Ruth1870Pencil and charcoal on paper
Woman Arranging a Hat1870Pencil drawing
Study for Boaz Asleep1870Pastel and red chalk
Boaz Asleep1870Charcoal and pencil on paper
Study for Boaz Asleep1870Black and beige pastel with red chalk on laid paper
Ruth Lying down1870Charcoal and pastel on paper
Head, Arm and Chest of Ruth1870Charcoal on paper
Chest of Ruth1870Black chalk and charcoal on paper
Black Woman with Peonies — gouachec. 1870Gouache, watercolour, pencil and black chalk on card
Various Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Rocky Sea SideUndatedCharcoal on paper
Studies of a Dancing WomanUndatedDrawing with white chalk
Study of a LegUndatedPencil drawing
Dancers in CamargueUndatedPencil drawing
Academy of WomanUndatedCharcoal
Caricature of Venus of Milo and Various Other CaricaturesUndatedCharcoal
CaricatureUndatedPencil drawing
Study of LandscapeUndatedCharcoal
Caricatures and Seated MonkUndatedCharcoal
Caricatures and Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Women Carrying a PitcherUndatedPencil drawing
The Hanged ManUndatedCharcoal
Castle in the PlainUndatedCharcoal
Naked Woman from BehindUndatedCharcoal
CaricaturesUndatedCharcoal and pencil
Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Landscape with a CastleUndatedCharcoal
Study of LandscapeUndatedCharcoal
Horse Rider seen from BehindUndatedCharcoal
MazeppaUndatedPencil and charcoal
Study of Rider and Others SubjectsUndatedPencil, pen and brown ink
Study of an Unidentified ManUndatedPencil drawing
Study for an Unknown Historic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study a Man ReadingUndatedPencil drawing
Study of Men ReadingUndatedPencil drawing
Study of Landscape ?UndatedCharcoal
Study of a Head of a ManUndatedPencil drawing
Erotic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study of DogUndatedCharcoal
Studies of Unidentified Subjects and Erotic SceneUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Study for a Theater SceneUndatedCharcoal
Study of a Reclining Naked WomanUndatedCharcoal
Two Studies of LandscapeUndatedPencil drawing
CaricatureUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Portrait of an Unidentified Young ManUndatedCharcoal
Study of an Unidentified SubjectUndatedBrown ink drawing
Unidentified Man with a HatUndatedPencil and charcoal
Study of an Unidentified WomenUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Theater Character ?UndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Theater Character ?UndatedPen drawing
The Pavillon de la Reine in ParisUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Horse RiderUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Entwined Couple. Caricature ?UndatedPencil drawing
Woman Sitting on a SofaUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Studies of AnimalsUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Horse Rider in CamargueUndatedCharcoal
Study of Hunting DogsUndatedPencil drawing
Study of Soldiers. CaricaturesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Hunting Dogs ?UndatedPencil drawing
Hunting Scene. Hunter Playing the HornUndatedPencil drawing
CaricatureUndatedPencil drawing
Study of an IbexUndatedPencil drawing
Theater Scene. CaricaturesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Animals. Horses ?UndatedPencil drawing
CaricaturesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Various Subjects and AnimalsUndatedPencil drawing
Unidentified SubjectUndatedPencil drawing
Rider Taming a Horse [in Camargue ?]UndatedPencil drawing
Caricature of a SoldierUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Woman and MouseUndatedPencil drawing
Historic SceneUndatedCharcoal
Architecture StudiesUndatedPencil drawing
Mythologic SceneUndatedCharcoal
OpheliaUndatedPencil drawing
Mythologic SceneUndatedCharcoal
Studies of Various SubjectsUndatedPencil and pen drawing
Studies of PeasantsUndatedPencil drawing
Historic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Historic or Literary SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Unidentified Historic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Unidentified StudyUndatedPencil drawing
Man in an ArmchairUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Portraits of Unidentified MenUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Horse Rider and ArtistUndatedCharcoal and pencil
Study of Unidentified CharactersUndatedCharcoal
Dead Horse in a PlainUndatedCharcoal
Study of Various Subjects and FurnitureUndatedPencil drawing
Caricatures and Various Notes about OpéraUndatedPencil drawing
Galloping HorseUndatedCharcoal
Study for La ToiletteUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Naked WomanUndatedPencil drawing
Domestic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
PhysiognomiesUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Female ProfilesUndatedPencil drawing
Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Terrace at MéricUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues-MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues-MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedCharcoal
Children PortraitsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Children's HeadsUndatedPencil drawing
Study of MinervaUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Family GatheringUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Young FishermanUndatedCharcoal
Self-PortraitsUndatedBlack pencil drawing
Study of Horses for the Porte de la Reine at Aigues-MortesUndatedInk drawing
Study of Horses for the Porte de la Reine at Aigues-MortesUndatedInk drawing
Study of Horses for the Porte de la Reine at Aigues-MortesUndatedInk drawing
Study for an Outdoor ConcertUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of LegsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of HatsUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of MenUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Little GardenerUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues MortesUndatedCharcoal
Studies of Sail BoatsUndatedPencil drawing
Portrait of Marc BazilleUndatedCharcoal, black pencil and graphite
Studies of Children's HeadsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Aigues-MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Women's HeadsUndatedPencil drawing
Portrait of Camille des Hours and an Unidentified ManUndatedCharcoal
Study of Flying BirdsUndatedCharcoal or graphite
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study of HandsUndatedPen drawing
Self-PortraitUndatedBlack pencil drawing
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil drawing
Study of BranchesUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Seated ChildUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Couple and Unidentified WomenUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Unidentified WomenUndatedPencil drawing
Study of BuildingsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil and charcoal
Studies of BoatersUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Man Writing at his TableUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Woman Cutting FlowersUndatedPencil drawing
Study of HandUndatedPencil drawing
Women in a GardenUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Women in ProfileUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Ruth and BoazUndatedCharcoal
Study for The Family GatheringUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the View of the VillageUndatedPencil drawing
Study of the View of the VillageUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the Fisherman with a NetUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the View of the VillageUndatedCharcoal
Study for The Little GardenerUndatedCharcoal
Portrait of a Man with a Top HatUndatedPencil drawing
Portrait of a Man with a Top HatUndatedPencil drawing
InscriptionsUndatedPencil inscriptions
Study of TreeUndatedPencil drawing
Caricature of Nina la BelleUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Saint SebastianUndatedPencil drawing
Young Woman SewingUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of HandsUndatedPencil drawing
Woman in a GardenUndatedPencil drawing
Elegant WomanUndatedPencil drawing
Various InscriptionsUndatedInscriptions (medium unspecified in index)
Study of a Man with a HatUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a ChildUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Man with a HatUndatedPencil drawing

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this painting called today?

The Montpellier canvas is presented here as Young Woman with Peonies, the English equivalent of the Musée Fabre’s Jeune femme aux pivoines. It has also circulated under an older title. [1]

Where is the Montpellier version?

It belongs to the Musée Fabre, inventory 18.1.3. Painted in 1870, it measures 60.5 × 75.4 cm. [1]

Does it show the same arrangement as the Washington canvas?

No. In this version, the woman concentrates on placing a flower within an arrangement. The Washington painting changes her pose and relationship to the viewer. [1] [4]

Discussion

The woman’s attention turns towards the flowers. Follow the relationship between her hands, the stems and the vase.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · An attentive gesture

Follow the movement from the woman’s eyes to her hands and the flower. How is the action held together?

Editorial prompt · Flowers against darkness

How does the dark background affect the colour and physical presence of the blooms?

Editorial prompt · The second canvas

Compare this absorbed action with the Washington figure’s address to the viewer. Which feels more immediate?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Young Woman with Peonies (Montpellier version) below.

References

  1. Musée Fabre, Jeune femme aux pivoines, inventory 18.1.3, collection record, dimensions, acquisition and exhibition history. Source (in French). View source.
  2. Michel Schulman, Young Woman with Peonies, MSb-60, digital catalogue raisonné, object record and critical essay. Source (English translation of French scholarly catalogue). View source.
  3. National Gallery of Art, Frédéric Bazille and the Birth of Impressionism, exhibition checklist, 2017, peony paintings, catalogue nos. 61–62. Source. View source.
  4. Michel Schulman, Young Woman with Peonies, MSb-61, digital catalogue raisonné, object record and critical essay. Source (English translation of French scholarly catalogue). View source.
  5. Fitzwilliam Museum, Black Woman with Peonies, PD.1-2004, collection record. Source. View source.
  6. Michel Schulman, Black Woman with Peonies, MSb-76, digital catalogue raisonné, object record and critical essay. Source (English translation of French scholarly catalogue). View source.
  7. Musée Fabre, Frédéric Bazille: la jeunesse de l’impressionnisme, exhibition press dossier, 2016, PDF pp. 15 and 21. Source (in French). View source.
  8. Frédéric Bazille, letter to his mother, April 1867, Musée Fabre, inventory 94.7.1, transcription, PDF p. 4. Source (in French). View source.
  9. Bruno Mottin, “L’œuvre de Frédéric Bazille (1841-1870) examiné au laboratoire,” Technè 46 (2018), pp. 30–38, especially paragraph 17. Source (in French). View source.
  10. Musée d’Orsay, Le modèle noir de Géricault à Matisse / Black Models: From Géricault to Matisse, exhibition press dossier, 2019, PDF pp. 5–7, 26, 50–52, 70 and 80. Source (in French and English). View source.
  11. Michel Hilaire, “Bazille ou la vie brève,” Académie des Sciences et Lettres de Montpellier, communications presented in 2016, printed pp. 166–172, especially p. 166. Source (in French). View source.
  12. Joconde/POP, La Robe rose, RF2450. View source. (in French).
  13. Musée d’Orsay, L’Ambulance improvisée, RF 1967 5. View source. (in French).
  14. Musée d’Orsay, Réunion de famille,RF2749. View source. (in French).
  15. Musée d’Orsay, Pierre Auguste Renoir,DL1970 3. View source.
  16. Musée Fabre, Vue de village, 898.5.1. View source. (in French).
  17. National Gallery of Art, Young Woman with Peonies,1983.1.6. View source.
  18. Michel Schulman, painting index and documentary introduction (English titles; French metadata). View source.
  19. Michel Schulman, works-on-paper index (English titles; French metadata). View source.
  20. Michel Schulman, albums and studies index (English titles; French metadata). View source.