Franz Marc’s Birds, three birds among coloured forms

by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 17, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Looking at Birds

Three birds flicker through Franz Marc’s Birds. One pale creature stands at the left, its thin beak and round eye drawn with a few dark marks. A second appears high among blue and green shapes. A third emerges lower down, its light body caught in crossing bands of colour. Wings, leaves and rays are hard to separate. Marc painted the work in 1914, near the end of his short career. The painting lets an identifiable subject hover at the edge of abstraction: the birds are present, yet the surrounding movement almost carries them away. [1]

The Lenbachhaus in Munich records Vögel as oil on canvas, 109 × 100 cm. It is a nearly square picture rather than a horizontal landscape. An early sale catalogue described three bird forms within prismatic, spectrum-like colour; the current museum essay also identifies three. Counting them is a useful first task for a viewer, but the picture becomes more rewarding when the birds’ shapes are followed into the larger fan of blue, green, red, violet and white. [1] [2]

Watch: Franz Marc

Explore Marc’s blue horses, the Blue Rider circle and the move towards abstraction in English-language videos.

Finding the three birds

The bird at left has the clearest face. Its pale neck rises beside a blue vertical passage, and a small eye and pointed beak make it immediately legible. The body below becomes less certain as white and pink areas join the surrounding forms. It seems to stand or watch while the picture moves around it. That relatively quiet presence gives the eye a place to begin before the rest of the painting opens up. [1]

Higher and nearer the middle, a dark head and narrow beak emerge among green and blue blades. This bird is harder to trace as a complete body. The lower bird is made from pale angular passages crossed by warm yellow and red; its head and beak are suggested with minimal dark strokes. Marc has reduced the signs needed to recognize each creature. A curved line or pointed mark may be enough for an eye or beak, while the body participates in the same colour geometry as everything around it. [1]

The larger composition moves diagonally. Green forms sweep upward across the centre; blue and violet regions press from the sides. Pale wedge shapes and red-orange accents break the field into a fan. The Lenbachhaus relates this spreading structure to a wingbeat. That analogy is a way to feel the painting’s movement, even where there is no single wing to outline. The birds’ flutter and the canvas’s shifting planes become almost one event. [1]

Yet the painting is not all motion. The pale left bird pauses in profile; the central forms meet at points that briefly hold still; the colour fan is balanced within the nearly square format. The museum essay describes a simultaneous sense of flutter and quiet. That tension lets the image avoid becoming a mere diagram of speed. We can watch for the instant before movement, the instant within it, or the stillness that remains when the eye settles on one bird. [1]

Colour, shape and late work

Marc had long joined animals to their surroundings through colour. In The Large Blue Horses, the curves of three bodies echo hills. In Deer in a Monastery Garden, an animal stands within fractured moonlit vegetation. Birds goes further: the creatures are indicated with only a few graphic signs and almost vanish into the field of colour. The change is one of degree and purpose, not a sudden rejection of living subjects. [3] [4] [1]

The Lenbachhaus essay connects the broken planes and bright colours with Marc’s engagement with Italian Futurism and Robert Delaunay’s painting. It cites art historian Armin Zweite on the way angled pieces allow both flight and watchful pause. Those comparisons help locate the formal language of 1914, but the image itself remains the test. The green fan across the middle, the sharply crossing pale shapes and the briefly visible birds show Marc adapting modern techniques to a particular sensation of animal life. [1]

The museum also quotes a letter Marc wrote to Maria in 1915 from military service. Looking back on his art, he described finding even animals and nature less pure than he had once hoped, and feeling driven towards more schematic, abstract forms. This later reflection can illuminate the direction visible in Birds, but it was written after the 1914 painting and in the altered circumstances of war. It should not be treated as a diary entry recording exactly what he intended at the easel when he painted these three birds. [1]

The birds are especially useful for thinking about abstraction because they have not disappeared entirely. Fighting Forms, also dated 1914, asks us to follow a contest of red and blue-black masses without a secure depicted animal. In Birds, a beak and eye remain enough to identify a creature. The artist could shift how much of the natural subject he retained rather than move along a single, irreversible ladder from depiction to pure form. [5] [1]

Confiscation and the Lucerne sale

The painting later passed through a coercive history. A Lenbachhaus exhibition label states that it was in Dresden’s Galerie Neue Meister until the Nazi authorities confiscated it on 12 August 1937. The original Galerie Fischer catalogue lists Vögel as lot 90 in the Lucerne auction of modern works removed from German museums on 30 June 1939, identifying Dresden as the source. This original catalogue settles the auction year: a later Lenbachhaus label inadvertently prints 1938. The painting did not enter that market as an ordinary voluntary sale by the Dresden museum. [6] [2]

A Düsseldorf provenance report names the American collector Ray W. Berdeau as buyer at that sale and gives the price in dollars. The painting later reached the Lenbachhaus, with public acquisition support reflected in its current credit line. Its earlier route ran from Dresden through Nazi confiscation and the 1939 Lucerne sale; the Munich museum is its present home. [7] [1] [6]

That material history belongs beside the visual experience, not over it. The painting still asks us to look patiently. Find the pale bird at left, then the darker upper figure and the light form below. Follow the crossing colours that make wings and setting meet. Marc held recognisable creatures within a restless surface, so that an eye can both locate them and lose them again. Birds gives that movement a vivid, delicate shape. [1]

Artwork Directory

This source-checked selection contains 192 identified works and print designs from the current Franz Marc research set. It is a curated selection, not a complete catalogue raisonné. Some works link to their article here; others link to a collection record. Unresolved identifications are omitted.

192 artworks

NameDateMedium
Abstract Composition1913 - 14Drawing
Alpine Herdsman in the Hut1902Painting
Altar Sheep from Lana (postcard to Gabriele Münter)11. April 1913Drawing
Animal Legend1912Print
Animals in Landscape1914Painting
Bathing Girls1968Painting
Belt Clasp (Lioness Pierced by an Arrow)1909/10Sculpture
Bewitched Mill1913Painting
Birds1914Painting
Birth of the Horses1913Print
Blue Fox1911Painting
Blue Horse1911Painting
Blue Horse II1911Painting
Blue Horse with Rainbow1913Drawing
Bluish Mythical Creature (Messages to Prince Jussuff)1913Drawing
Boy with Sled in a Winter Landscapeum 1902Painting
Broken Forms1914Painting
Bull1911Painting
Caliban1914Drawing
Cat Behind a Tree1910–11Painting
Cat behind a Tree1910-1911Drawing
Cat on a Yellow Pillow1912Painting
Cats1909–10Painting
Chimera1914Sculpture
Colored Flowers1913–14Drawing
Conciliation1912Print
Cottages on the Dachau Marsh1902Painting
Cows Yellow, Red & Green1911Painting
Crouching Deer1911Painting
Cup (alabaster)—Sculpture
Dead Deer1913Drawing
Dead Sparrow1905Painting
Deer at Dusk1909Painting
Deer in a Monastery Garden1912Painting
Deer in the Forest1913Painting
Deer in the Forest II1914Painting
Deer in the Forest II (Lenbachhaus, 1912)1912Painting
Deer in the Reeds1909Painting
Deer in the Snow1911Painting
Design for a Keyhole Escutcheon: Two Mythical Animals1913Drawing
Dog1912Painting
Dog Lying in the Snow1911Painting
Donkey Frieze1911–12Painting
Dream1912Painting
Dream Rock1913Drawing
Dreaming Horse1913Drawing
Elephant1907Drawing
Elephant (1913 MoMA pencil drawing)1913Drawing
Elephant, Horse and Cow1913–14Painting
Fabulous Beast II (Horse)1913Drawing
Fairy Animals I1913Drawing
Fate of the Animals1913Painting
Female Nude Study1909Painting
Female Torso1910Sculpture
Fighting Forms1914Painting
Fire Ox, Green Horse and Ibex1913Drawing
Forest with Squirrel1913Painting
Four Foxes1913Drawing
Fox1913Painting
Fox and Gazelle (Messages to Prince Jussuff)1913Drawing
From King Jussuff's Nights1913Drawing
From Prince Jussuff's Hunting Grounds1913Drawing
From the Ancient Royal City of Thebes1913Drawing
Gazelles1913–14Drawing
Genesis II (NGA impression)1914Print
Girl with Cat II1912Painting
Grazing Horses1910Painting
Grazing Horses I1910Painting
Hay Wagon1905Painting
Haystacks in the Snow1911Painting
Horse (1913 Art Institute drawing)1913Drawing
Horse and Dog1913Drawing
Horse in a Landscape1910Painting
Horses (museum title partly redacted)1913Drawing
Horses by the Sea1907Painting
In the Rain1912Painting
Indersdorf1904Painting
Inside a Forest with a Bird1912Painting
Jumping Dog Schlick1908Painting
Keyhole Fitting (Panther Leaping at a Horse)1910Sculpture
Keyhole Fitting Shaped Like a Sword Guard (Adam and Eve)1910Sculpture
King Abigail's Toy Horse1913Drawing
King Jussuff's Three Panthers1913Drawing
Lamb1913–14Painting
Landscape with Red Animal (postcard to Alfred Kubin)18. März 1913Drawing
Larch Sapling1908Painting
Large Blue Horses1911Painting
Large Lenggries Horses1908Painting
Large Red Horses1911Painting
Leaping Horse1912Painting
Leaping Horse (1912 drawing)1912Drawing
Little Blue Horse1912Painting
Little Yellow Horses1912Painting
Long Yellow Horse1913Painting
Mandrill1913Painting
Mandrill (1913 sketchbook study)1913Drawing
Monkey1912Painting
Monkey and Humanum 1912Painting
Monkey Frieze1911Painting
Mortar and Pestle1910Sculpture
Mother Mare of the Blue Horses1913Drawing
Mountain Goats1914Painting
Mountains1911–12Painting
New Year's Card1913Drawing
New Year's Greeting (postcard to Gabriele Münter)30. Dezember 1912Drawing
Nude Lying in the Flowers1910Painting
Nude with Cat1910Painting
Orpheus Among the Animals (Design for a Tapestry)Um 1907/09Painting
Park Landscape1908Drawing
Picture with Cattle1913Painting
Playing Dogs1912Drawing
Portrait of a Woman Painter with Palette (Maria Marc Painting in the Snow)1906Painting
Portrait of Henri Rousseau (reverse-glass painting)1911Painting
Portrait of the Artist's Father1902Painting
Portrait of the Artists Mother1902Painting
Prince Juss's Four Companion Dogs1914Drawing
Prince Jussuf's Lemon Horse and Fire Ox1913Drawing
Prince Jussuff's Warhorse7. April 1913 (Poststempel)Drawing
Reclining Deer (pencil study)1911/12Drawing
Red and Blue Horse1912Drawing
Red and Blue Horse (1913 postcard)5. April 1913Drawing
Red Bull1912Drawing
Red Deer1913Painting
Red Deer Grazing1910Painting
Red Deers1912Painting
Red Horse and Yellow Cow (postcard to Alfred Kubin)21. Mai 1913Drawing
Red Woman1912Painting
Resting Horses1911–12Print
Rising Mist1903Painting
Scene from Jussuff's Peaceful Days1. Mai 1913 (Poststempel)Drawing
Seated Mythical Animal1912/13Drawing
Seated Saint (1913 postcard)8. Juni 1913Drawing
Self Portrait1904Painting
Sheaf of Grain1907Painting
Sheep1912Painting
Shepherd Boy1902Painting
Shepherds1912Painting
Siberian Sheepdogs1909/1910Painting
Sleeping Animals1913Painting
Small Composition I1913Painting
Small Composition II1913/14Painting
Small Composition III1913–14Painting
Small Horse Picture1909Painting
Small Horse Study1905Painting
Small Reed Stack near Brunnenbach1908Drawing
St. Julian the Hospitaler1913Drawing
Stables1913Painting
Staffelalm (II) with Sheep1902Painting
Standing Horse with Trees1910Drawing
Tale of Creation (Cleveland impression)1914Print
The Blue Rider and His Horse1912Drawing
The First Animals1913Drawing
The Holy Little Calf1913Drawing
The Little Violet Elephant1913Drawing
The Panther1908Sculpture
The Riding School1913Print
The Trees Showed Their Rings, the Animals Their Veins (work on paper)1913Drawing
The Unfortunate Land of Tyrol (paper study)1913Drawing
The Watering Place at Ruby Mountain1913Drawing
The World Cow1913Painting
Three Cats1913Painting
Three Horses1912Drawing
Tiger1912Painting
Tower of Blue Horses1913Painting
Tower of Blue Horses postcard1912Drawing
Two Animals (postcard to Kandinsky)15. Februar 1913Drawing
Two Bathing Girls1909Painting
Two Blue Horses—Drawing
Two Blue Horses1913Drawing
Two Blue Horses before a Red Rock1913Drawing
Two Cats (colour lithograph)1909/10Print
Two Cats Blue and Yellow1912Painting
Two Cows in a Mountain Landscape1913Drawing
Two Horses (1913)1913Drawing
Two Horses (bronze sculpture)1908/09Sculpture
Two Horses, Red and Blue (1912)1912Drawing
Two Sheep (postcard to Kandinsky)1. Mai 1913Drawing
Two Women on the Hillside1906Painting
Tyrol1914Painting
Unfortunate Land of Tyrol1913Painting
Untitled (Sheep with Bent Head)—Sculpture
Untitled (Standing Sheep)—Sculpture
Vermilion Greeting (postcard to Kandinsky)19. April 1913Drawing
Water Pool1906Painting
Waterfall1912Painting
Weasels Playing1911Painting
White Pigs1912Painting
Wild Boars in the Water1910–11Drawing
Wild Pigs Boar and Sow1913Painting
Wolves Balkan War1913Painting
Yellow Cow1911Painting
Young Oak Tree1909Painting

Discussion

Three birds emerge from an increasingly broken field of colour.

Reader Insights

Observation

Which bird can you find first, and which is hardest to separate from the background?

Comparison

How does this late work differ from Marc’s more legible animal groups?

Interpretation

How does the painting’s later collecting history shape your encounter with it?

Join the Conversation

Which detail changed the way you saw this work? Share a close observation or a comparison with another Marc picture.


References

  1. Lenbachhaus, Vögel, G 17489 and Friedel/Hoberg essay. View source.
  2. Galerie Fischer, Lucerne sale catalogue, 30 June 1939, lot 90. View source.
  3. Walker Art Center, The Large Blue Horses. View source.
  4. Lenbachhaus, Deer in a Monastery Garden. View source.
  5. Bavarian State Painting Collections, Fighting Forms. View source.
  6. Lenbachhaus, expanded object label, 2024. View source.
  7. Düsseldorf, provenance research report on Marc’s Foxes, comparison with Birds. View source.
  8. Related artwork image, Yellow Cow: Photograph by Dr. Alexey Yakovlev; resized without crop or colour change, CC BY-SA 2.0.
  9. Franz Marc’s Birds, three birds among coloured forms. Legacy site reproduction of the artwork discussed on this page.