Stages of Cruelty Ford Madox Brown Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 30, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Stages of Cruelty by Ford Madox Brown: Introduction

A child raises a flowering stem above a dog. Behind her, a young man clasps a woman’s hand and searches her face, while she directs her attention elsewhere. In Stages of Cruelty , Ford Madox Brown places physical mistreatment beside an unhappy encounter between lovers. Their arrangement invites us to compare the two relationships before deciding how closely they resemble one another.

The oil painting in Manchester Art Gallery was begun in 1856 and completed in 1890. [1]

Its dense garden setting and carefully described clothes make the scene feel immediately present, yet the canvas brings together work separated by more than three decades.

Brown’s diary records the labour of painting the leaves outdoors; the surviving child study and the later repainting of her head reveal another kind of time embedded in the picture. [1] [2]

At a Glance

  • Artist Ford Madox Brown. [1]
  • Title Stages of Cruelty . [1]
  • Date 1856–1890, with a long interruption in its making. [1]
  • Medium Oil paint on canvas. [2]
  • Size 73.3 × 59.9 cm, unframed. [3]
  • Collection Manchester Art Gallery, accession 1911.104. [3]
  • Setting A garden, with lovers beside a wall and a child and dog below.
  • Related objects A child study in Birmingham and separate watercolour versions at Tate and the Ashmolean. [2] [4]

This work across Ford Madox Brown’s career

1840–1893; ranges can include separate phases of work
184018501860187018801893

Manfred on the Jungfrau

1841; retouched 1861

Pretty Baa-Lambs

1851–1859

Work

1852–1865

King René’s Honeymoon

Tate watercolour, 1864

Contents

  1. Two encounters on the garden steps
  2. From stolen pleasures to cruelty
  3. Flowers that complicate the story
  4. Painting leaves in a changing garden
  5. A child study and a painting resumed

Two encounters on the garden steps

Brown builds the picture upwards from the dog at the lower left. The child sits close beside it, her red dress spreading across the steps. Above her, the young woman’s blue skirt occupies much of the canvas. Higher still, her pale jacket and uncovered face stand against the dark mass of leaves. The man appears from behind the brick wall, with little more than his head, hands and shoulders visible. This difference in bodily presence gives the woman compositional authority: she fills the space in which he can only reach towards her.

The two encounters are linked through hands and arms. The man holds the woman’s wrist or forearm as well as her hand. She rests her other hand beneath a piece of needlework. Below, the child holds the dog’s lead in one hand and lifts the flowering stem with the other. Affection, restraint, dependence and threatened violence are concentrated in small areas of contact.

The child’s action is caught before the downward stroke. Her raised elbow and the trailing flower heads make the threat legible without showing an impact. The dog’s large head, low position and lifted paw offer a response in a different physical language. Its size gives it the potential for strength, but its posture makes it look vulnerable. The lead runs across the girl’s lap, joining the pair even while the stem keeps them apart.

Above, the man’s face tilts towards the woman, while hers turns away from him. His expression asks for an answer that she withholds. Her needlework supplies an alternative occupation for the hand he does not hold. The narrow ledge under his arms and the wall in front of his body make his approach awkward; the woman, by contrast, appears securely seated. Brown creates the imbalance through position as much as expression.

Looking between these groups is essential. Seen alone, the child and dog form a scene of threatened physical hurt. Seen alone, the lovers could represent a quarrel, a refusal or an unwanted appeal. Placed together beneath this title, they become an argument about the capacity to cause another creature pain. That argument depends upon an analogy. Refusing a lover and striking an animal are different actions, even when the arrangement encourages the spectator to associate them.

From stolen pleasures to cruelty

The earliest documented idea had a lighter emphasis. In his June 1856 diary, reproduced in Ford Madox Hueffer’s biography, Brown described a young woman sitting on a garden wall at her work, with a young man’s head visible beyond it. He proposed the title Stolen Pleasures are Sweet . The entry followed a dealer’s discouraging response to another subject; Brown was considering what to paint next. [1]

That early description centres on the lovers and their partly concealed meeting. The eventual title redirects attention towards the child and the relationship between the two groups. Pleasure becomes a question about whose pleasure is being represented, and what it costs someone else. The secluded garden can still look inviting, but the invitation becomes uncomfortable once we notice the raised stem and the man’s imploring face.

The title also invites comparison with William Hogarth ’s The Four Stages of Cruelty . In Hogarth’s sequence, the youthful Tom Nero’s abuse of animals precedes violence against a human victim. The Morgan Library & Museum’s account stresses this passage from one form of brutality to another. [5] Brown’s picture places a child’s treatment of an animal beside an adult relationship within a single garden. The comparison helps explain the force of the word “stages”, without requiring us to invent a complete life story for either figure.

The painting’s moral rhetoric deserves attention of its own. It makes female indifference to male affection available as an example of cruelty, beside a child’s unmistakable threat to an animal. A viewer can recognise how that comparison works without treating it as a universal judgement about women or accepting that the man has a right to the response he seeks. The painting gives us his appeal and her refusal; it does not tell us what has happened between them before this moment.

Nor does the scene establish that the woman takes pleasure in the dog’s distress. Her diverted gaze helps connect the groups, but the relationship between attention, approval and indifference remains something we have to judge. The title steers our response strongly; the faces and gestures leave room to examine its claim.

Flowers that complicate the story

The garden is more than a screen behind the figures. Leaves crowd the woman’s shoulders and almost engulf the young man. The brick wall cuts across that growth, while a pale railing rises at the right. Brown brings these surfaces close together, leaving little open distance into which the eye can escape. Human discomfort takes place amid luxuriant growth.

Manchester Art Gallery interprets the flowers through Victorian flower language: love-lies-bleeding suggests hopelessness; lilac, first love; and convolvulus, bonds or extinguished hopes. Its description identifies the red flowers at the woman’s breast only tentatively as geraniums, whose associations included deceit, preference and comfort. These are the gallery’s proposed meanings, with alternatives built into the reading. [3]

The flowers also do things within the picture. Those on the woman’s jacket sit near the needlework and her carefully finished clothing. Those held by the child become an instrument of threatened hurt. At the right, climbing flowers wind around the railing, following its upward movement. Before consulting any flower dictionary, we can see how Brown makes vegetation participate in the arrangement of bodies and objects.

Love-lies-bleeding is particularly pointed because its name introduces injury into something ornamental. Its hanging red flower heads echo the colour of the child’s dress, binding the threatening object to the apparently decorative figure who carries it. The stem is slender and ordinary. The disturbing element is the use to which it is being put.

A fixed code would make this scene easier to solve than it is to look at. The possible meanings of the geranium alone range from consolation to deception. Keeping that uncertainty visible allows the flowers to sharpen the emotional atmosphere without pretending that each plant supplies a single sentence in a hidden script.

Watch: Ford Madox Brown

Choose a film exploring the people, stories and visual details in two of Brown’s best-known paintings.

Painting leaves in a changing garden

Brown’s diary makes the garden’s apparent stillness especially striking. He began the new picture on 21 June 1856, recording that he had painted eight bricks and some leaves. Two days later he fitted up a tent to shield his work from excessive outdoor light. Without that shade, he explained, colours judged outside could look flat when the canvas was brought indoors. This is an account of controlling the conditions of observation as well as observing nature closely. [1]

The lilac demanded repeated attention. In July he placed a lay figure among the leaves so that he could paint their contact with a body. Rain threatened to damage it, so he substituted a child’s chair and old cushions topped with the lay figure’s head. He also pinned fresh leaves into place where others had deteriorated and adjusted branches displaced by the figure. [1]

These practical arrangements illuminate the finished effect. The plants look insistently particular, but their arrangement was also managed. Brown maintained the relationship between foliage and figure as weather and growth altered the material before him. The small substitute body on the wall preserved a place for a person while he attended to the leaves around it.

He was equally willing to construct the human action. A July entry records designing the lovers’ poses before a mirror with himself and his daughter Lucy, who was seated on the piano. In November he recorded painting from the sculptor Thomas Woolner’s brother for Stages of Cruelty . These entries describe separate stages of making, rather than identifying every feature in the finished lovers as a single person’s portrait. [1]

The diary therefore offers a useful balance to the picture’s minute finish. Looking closely did not exclude acting, substitution or rearrangement. The wall could be real, the leaves painted from life and the pose tested indoors, all within the making of one invented encounter. Brown’s drawings preserve another part of this process: the particular observation that could later be absorbed into a larger design.

Hueffer called this Brown’s most Pre-Raphaelite work, praising the extreme detail of its handling while finding the result constrained. That is the grandson’s critical judgement in his 1896 biography, rather than the painter describing his own intention. His response captures a tension still visible here: extraordinary attention to individual things is held within a tight, almost airless composition. [1]

A child study and a painting resumed

The child study represents Brown’s daughter Catherine, or Cathy. Laura MacCulloch catalogues the Birmingham drawing as black chalk on pale grey paper, dated 1857, accession 1922P18. She also identifies the canvas as material from Brown’s discarded Chaucer triptych wings. [2]

MacCulloch identifies Cathy’s daughter Juliet as the later model for the painted girl. [2]

A figure that appears to occupy one instant thus contains work from two generations. That family relationship explains the painting’s making, without making its fictional behaviour evidence about either sitter’s character.

MacCulloch associates the eventual completion with the patron Henry Boddington. [2]

Hueffer’s later chronological account specifies that Brown returned to the unfinished picture in August and September 1890. The early year in the painting’s date marks its beginning, rather than a finished Victorian scene left untouched thereafter. [1]

There are also separate treatments on paper. Tate’s collection data lists a small watercolour, Stages of Cruelty , around 1856, accession N04625. Its support measures 143 × 121 mm. [4]

MacCulloch lists another version at the Ashmolean, worked in watercolour and bodycolour with pen and black ink. [2]

Neither should be confused with the Manchester oil or with the single-figure chalk study.

These distinctions change how we read the finished canvas. Its actors inhabit a shared garden moment, while its surface joins outdoor work, model sessions, an early child study and a late return. The strongly organised scene conceals a discontinuous history. Brown’s patient attention to leaves and clothing survives alongside a story whose implications depend on the comparison we make between its figures.

Artworks directory

Explore paintings, drawings, cartoons, illustrations and decorative designs documented in museum collections and specialist research. Distinct versions are listed separately; repeated print impressions are grouped. The coverage includes studies and works without a dedicated article and remains open to further research.

327 records

NameDateMedium
Work (Manchester)1852–1865Oil on canvas
The Last of England (Birmingham)1852–1855Oil on panel
Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet1852–1856Oil on canvas
Pretty Baa-Lambs1851–1859Oil on panel
Take Your Son, Sir?1851–1892Oil on canvas
Lear and Cordelia1849–1854Oil on canvas
Cordelia’s Portion1867–1875Oil on canvas
Walton-on-the-Naze1859–1860Oil on canvas
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III (Tate)1856–1868Oil on canvas
Carrying Corn1854–1855Oil on mahogany
The Hayfield (The Hay Harvest)1855–1856Oil on mahogany
Stages of Cruelty1856–1890Oil on canvas
The Irish Girl1860Oil on canvas laid on board
Romeo and Juliet (Delaware)1869–1870Oil on canvas
The Seeds and Fruit of English Poetry1845–1853Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait1877Oil on canvas
The Bromley ChildrenProbably 1844Oil on canvas
The Bromley Family1844Oil on canvas
Byron’s Dream (Manchester)1874; worked on into 1875Oil on canvas
Cartoon for The Baptism of Edwin1879–1891Pastel, coloured chalks and grey gouache
The Coat of Many Colours1864–1866Oil on canvas
The Convalescent (Birmingham)Dated October 1872Pastel
Crabtree Watching the Transit of Venus (reduced painting)1881–1888Tempera on panel
Cromwell on His Farm (Lady Lever)Completed 1874Oil on canvas
Cromwell Protector of the Vaudois1877Oil on canvas
Dalton Collecting Marsh-Fire Gas (Town Hall mural)1886–1887Mural on canvas
The Establishment of the Flemish Weavers (reduced painting)1881; completed 1888Tempera on panel
The Finding of Don Juan by Haidée (NGV)1869–1870; later retouchedWatercolour and gouache over pencil
Henry and Millicent Fawcett1872Oil on canvas
Jacob and Joseph’s Coat (Ponce)c.1868–1871Oil on canvas
James Leathart1863–1864; altered 1869Oil on canvas
King René’s Honeymoon (Tate watercolour)1864Graphite, watercolour, gouache and gum arabic on card
King René’s Honeymoon Cabinet (collaborative work)1861; exhibited 1862Oak, inlaid woods, painted panels and metal mounts; Brown designed Architecture
Manfred on the Jungfrau1841; retouched 1861Oil on canvas
Millie Smith1846Oil on paper laid on panel
William Michael Rossetti by Lamplight1856–1857Oil on panel
The Traveller (Manchester oil)1868–1884Oil on panel
Waiting: An English Fireside of 1854–551851–1855Oil on panel
An English Autumn Afternoon1852–1853; finished c.1854Oil on canvas
Alfred the Great: Sketch of Alfred drawing in the Sand1843–1845pencil
Historical Notes and Sketches of Alfred the Great1843–1850brown ink writing over pencil
Angels watching the Crown of Thorns: Study of clasped Hands1846black chalk
Architecture: Study of Gothic Arches and 14th Century Vaultingc. 1847brown pen and ink over pencil on grey paper
The Ascension: Study of Angels and Hands1844brown pen and ink over pencil
The Ascension: Study of a Group of Angels1844brown pen and ink over pencil
The Ascension: Study of a Group of six flying Angels1844brown pen and ink over pencil
The Ascension: Two nude Angels holding onto each other1844brown brush and ink over pencil
The Ascension: Study for a kneeling Apostle1844black chalk touched with white on brown-toned paper
Head of a Childc. 1844black chalk touched with white on brown toned paper
The Ascension: Drapery Study of a praying Apostle1844black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Seated Figure in ecclesiastical Robes, gripping a Staff with left Hand raised in a Blessing1844black chalk
The Ascension: Study for an Apostle1844black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Body of seated Figure in ecclesiastical Robes holding a Staff and a Book1844black chalk
The Ascension: Study of an Apostle1844black chalk on toned paper
Full-length Sketch of a standing, naked Child1844black chalk on toned paper
The Ascension: Study for Christ1844brown pen and ink over pencil
Caricature: Composite Drawing: A Stunner1861–1863pencil
A Victorian Woman in her Underwear1861–1863pencil
Caricature: Composite Drawing: Bewigged Head1861–1863pencil
Bowed Head of a bearded Man1861–1863pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Early compositional Study1845pencil with brown pen and ink
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study for Milton and two Designs for Tombstonesc.1845–c.1846pencil with brown frame outline
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Tracing of the Figure of Miltonc.1845–c.1849brown pen and ink with pencil on tracing paper
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Tracing of a Gothic Archc.1845–c.1849brown pen and ink with pencil on tracing paper
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Early compositional Study1845pencil with brown pen and ink
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies of two Boys1845pencil, laid down
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies of four Figures1845pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Eight early Studies of Figures and Hands1845pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies for the Figures of Byron, Shakespeare and Burns1845black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for Burns1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a right Leg and left Foot for Milton1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a left Leg for Shakespeare1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Drapery for Milton1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for Shakespeare1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a Man in a medieval Hood1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study for the Cardinal1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study in Profile for Courtier1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Female Nude Study of a Muse holding onto a Rail1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Female Nude: Study of a Muse1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Study for seated Lady1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Study of a Woman with right Arm raised1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Studies of Back of a seated Woman's Head1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Studies of a seated Woman in lost Profile Pose and from the Back1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Study of a Woman1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Sketch of a Woman supporting another Figure1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of the Heads and Shoulders of two Women1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for Edward III with Outline of a Child1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Foreshortened Study for Head of a Jester1847pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Head of Alexander Pope1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Hand Studies1847black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Head of Milton copied from Sculpture1848black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies for the Squire and the Courtier talking to Gower1848pencil
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for the Black Prince1848black chalk with touches of white
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Three Studies of Hands1848Black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Four Studies of Hands1848black chalk touched with white
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a clasped right Hand for one of the Poets1848black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a left Hand for Burns1848black chalk heightened with touches of white
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Drapery for Burns1848black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study1848black chalk
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for the Black Prince1851black and white chalks on brown-toned paper
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study for Squire's Legs1851black chalk heightened with white
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Head Studies of an old Woman1851black chalk
Costume Study: Five Sketches of Armour and Costume1844brown pen and ink over pencil
Costume Study: Archbishop's Dress1845brown pen and ink on tracing paper
Costume Studies: French and Italian thirteenth and fourteenth-century Costumes (seven Drawings)1845brown pen and ink on tracing paper
Costume Study: Seigneur de Rimini1845brown pen and ink on tracing paper
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: The Death of Eglon1863–1865engraved woodblock; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: The Death of Eglon1881wood engraving; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Elijah and the Widow's Son1863–1865engraved woodblock; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Elijah and the Widow's Son1881wood engraving; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Joseph’s Coat (Compositional Sketch and four Studies for Jacob's Granddaughter)1863–1865pencil on paper
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Joseph's Coat1863–1865engraved woodblock; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers
Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Joseph’s Coat1881wood engraving; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers
Decorative Sketches: Venus Reclining on a Shell in the Midst of the Sea1848–1849brown pen and ink over pencil
Decorative Design: Ornamental Pattern1850watercolour and bodycolour over pen and ink, and pencil on two sheets of paper
Down Stream: Main Illustration (Last Year's First of May)1871wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
Down Stream: Tailpiece to the Poem (This Year's First of June)1871wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
The Establishment of Flemish Weavers in Manchester A.D. 1363: Four Studies of Parts of a Horse1879–1882black, white and red chalk on rough brown paper
Female: Two Studies of young Woman in eighteenth-century Costume1849pencil
Infant's Repast: Study of Mother and Child1848black and white chalk
Infant's Repast: Study of Mother and Child with separate Arm and Leg Studies of the Child1848black chalk with grey wash
King Lear: Sketch of Lear questioning Cordelia1844brown pen and ink over pencil
Alfred the Great: Compositional Sketches1843–1845pencil
King Lear: Sketches of Lear imagining his unfaithful Daughters’ Trial and Lear in the Storm1844brown pen and ink over pencil
Alfred the Great: Compositional Studies and Sketches and Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Cherubs1843–1849pencil
King Lear: Kent accuses Oswald1844brown pen and ink with pencil underneath
King Lear: Lear recounts his Wrongs to ReganUndatedBrown pen and ink over pencil
King Lear: Cordelia at Lear's Bedside (Lear's Awakening)1844brown pen and ink over pencil
Cordelia Parting from Her Sisters (The Germ)1850; reprinted 1901Etching; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
King René's Honeymoon: Study for Architecture1861brush and brown ink, with watercolour, over pencil on brown paper
The Last of England: Cartoon1852pencil, image edged with brown ink
The Last of England: Portrait of Emma HillDecember 1852chalks with scratching out on two sheets of paper
Lear and Cordelia and The Infant’s Repast: Four Studies of Hands1849black chalk
Lyra Germanica - the Christian Life: Abraham and Isaac1868wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
Lyra Germanica - the Christian Life: Finished Design for The Entombment1867black pen and ink
Lyra Germanica - the Christian Life: The Entombment1868wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
Male: Sketch of Man reclining on Steps with Hands bound together1844brown pen and ink over pencil
Male: Academic nude Study, half-length with Moustache and Arms folded1846–1849black chalk
Male: Academic Study of Nude holding a Staff1847pencil
Male: Academic Study of Nude posed as a Sculptor1847chalk with grey wash
Male: Academic Study, three-quarter length Nude, with a Moustache and clenched Fists1847black chalk
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Seven Sketches1846pencil
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Four Studies for Angel holding Child1847pencil
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Angel holding Child1847black chalk
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Arm and Hands for Angel holding Bowl of Water1847black chalk
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Drapery Study for Angel holding Bowl of Water1847black chalk
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Head for Angel holding Bowl of Water1847black chalk with rubbing and grey wash
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Child seated on Knees of the Virgin and two separate Studies of the Child's Legs1847pencil on brown-toned paper
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Frieze Designc. 1847pencil and black pen and ink
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Three Studies of Arms and Legs of Child1847pencil
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Three Studies of Child's Legs on Virgin's Knees1847pencil
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Studies of Right Foot and Left Hand of Child1847pencil on light brown paper
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Drapery Study for Virgin1847black chalk
Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study for Head of Virgin1847black chalk with wash
Parisina’s Sleep: Study for Prince Azo and Parisina1842black chalk with pencil side drawing
Parisina's Sleep: Study for Head of Prince Azo1842black chalk with grey wash
Parisina's Sleep: Study for the Head of Parisina1842black and white chalk with grey wash
Poets of the Nineteenth Century: The Prisoner of Chillon: Compositional Sketch1856pencil
Profile of a Man's left Eye and Nosec.1856pencil
Poets of the Nineteenth Century: The Prisoner of Chillon: Study of a Corpse1856pencil
Designs for Decorationc.1856pencil
Poets of the Nineteenth Century: The Prisoner of Chillon1857wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
Portrait: Head Study of Daniel Casey (three-quarter view)1848black chalk
Portrait: Head Study of Daniel Casey (full-face)1848black chalk
Portrait: Miss Iza Duffus Hardy1872pastel and coloured chalks on brown paper
Portrait: Emma Hill (later Mrs Madox Brown)1848black chalk
Portrait: Emma Hill (later Mrs Madox Brown)1852pencil
Portrait: Mrs Madox Brown (neé Emma Hill)9 May 1854pencil
The Repose in Egypt: Compositional Sketch1847pencil
Study of a Statue of the Discobolus1845Black chalk
William Shakespeare: Study1849–1850pencil
William Shakespeare: Invitation Card1850wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver
The Spirit of Justice: Study for Baron and his Advisor, with Sketches of Erudition and Wisdom1844–1845brown pen and ink over pencil
The Spirit of Justice: Drapery Study for Erudition1844–1845black chalk
Drapery Study and Sketch of Two LegsUndatedBlack chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Study for Wisdom1844–1845black chalk with grey wash
The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of the Baron1844–1845black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Study for the Head of central Bishop1844–1845black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Study for the Head of a Bishop1844–1845black chalk with grey wash
The Spirit of Justice: Study for the uplifted left Arm of Justice1844–1845black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of Counsellor in a Coronet1844–1845black chalk with touches of blue chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of Counsellor1844–1845black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Drapery Study for the Central Bishop1844–1845Black chalk
Part of a Drapery Study1844–1845black chalk
The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of Widow1844–1845black chalk
Stages of Cruelty: Study for the Child (Catherine Madox Brown)1857black chalk on pale grey paper
Stained Glass Design: Cartoon for Zachariah, The High Priest1872black chalk
Stained Glass Design: Cartoon for The Young Milton1874black chalk
Stained Glass Design: Cartoon for St Simon1874black chalk
Sterne's 'Sentimental Journey': Study for Yorick and La Fleur talking to Maria’s Mother1842brown pen and ink over pencil
The Body of Harold brought before William the Conqueror: Eight Sketches of Figure Groupsc.1844pencil
Sterne's 'Sentimental Journey' : Yorick (Laurence Sterne) and Maria Walking1842pen and ink, watercolour and bodycolour over pencil
Study of Tree Trunk with Rootsc.1847black chalk, heightened with white chalk on buff paper
Two Studies of Tree Trunksc.1846black chalk
Unknown Subject: Compositional Sketch1843–1850pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study for Chaucer1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Chaucer1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study of Gower1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Gower1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study for John of Gaunt and Chaucer's right Hand1847pencil and black chalk
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of John of Gaunt and Chaucer's Left Hand1847pencil and black chalk
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Wycliffe1847black chalk
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study for Wycliffe1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Drapery Study for Wycliffe1847black chalk
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Drapery Study for Chaucer1848black chalk
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of Legs for John of Gaunt and two Studies of Feet for Wycliffe1848black chalk
Wycliffe Reading his Translation of the Bible: Studies of Hands for John of Gaunt and Gower1847black chalk
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Head of Wycliffe1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Constance and Child1847pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Unfinished Study for Head of Constance1847–48pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Portrait of Elizabeth Bamford modelling for Constance1848pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Head of Constance1848chalk over pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Head of Chaucer1848pencil
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of Monk representing the Catholic Faith1848black chalk with brown pen and ink, squared up
Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of young Woman representing the Protestant Faith1848black chalk
Cathy Madox Brown at the Age of Three (Tate N01356)1853Graphite on paper
King René‘s Honeymoon (Tate N02409)date not knownInk on paper
Sheepshearing (Tate N02410)c.1887Ink and graphite on paper
Studies for ‘Work’ (Tate N02411)1855Graphite and ink on paper
Design for Badge for Gillum’s Homes (Tate N02412)date not knownInk and graphite on paper
Arkwright’s Mill (Tate N02413)1878Graphite on paper
Study for ‘John Kay’ (Tate N02414)1889Graphite on paper
Study for ‘Southend’ (Tate N02415)date not knownGraphite on paper
‘Where are you going, my pretty maid?’ (Tate N02416)date not knownGraphite on paper
Section of the Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02417)1890Ink on paper
A Barge on the Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02418)1890Graphite on paper
Study of the Tow-Path on the Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02419)1890Graphite on paper
Our Lady of Good Children (Tate N02684)1847–61Pastel, watercolour and gold paint on paper
Arkwright’s Mill (Tate N02791)1881Graphite on paper
The Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02792)1890Ink on paper
The Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02793)date not knownChalk and graphite on paper
The Last of England (Tate N03064)1864–6Watercolour on paper
Mauvais Sujet (Tate N03228)1863Watercolour on paper
Study of a Man Painting (Tate N03472)1839Graphite on paper
The Brent at Hendon (Tate N03528)1854–5Oil paint on board on mahogany
Study for the Dean in the ‘Execution of Mary Queen of Scots’ (Tate N04280)c.1840Oil paint on paper
Sketch for ‘Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet’ (Tate N04281)1852Graphite on paper
Sketch for ‘Cromwell on his Farm’ (Tate N04282)c.1853Graphite on paper
The Coat of Many Colours (Tate N04584)1867Watercolour and gouache on paper
Stages of Cruelty (Tate N04625)c.1856Watercolour on paper
Head of a Girl (Tate N04803)date not knownOil paint on paper
Portrait of Dykes Barry as a Child (Tate N04866)1853Oil paint on mahogany
Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet (Tate N05301)1857–8Watercolour on paper
Platt Lane (Tate N05383)1884Oil paint on canvas
Study of F.G. Stephens for ‘Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet’. Verso: A Head Crowned with Laurels (Tate T00571)1852Graphite on paper. Verso: graphite on paper
Sketch for ‘Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet’ (Tate T01035)c.1851Ink and graphite on paper
Chaucer at the Court of Edward III (Sydney)1845–1851Oil on canvas
Wycliffe Reading His Translation of the Bible to John of Gaunt (Bradford)1848Oil on canvas
Work (Birmingham replica)1859–1863Oil on canvas
The Spirit of Justice (Book of Art reproduction)Published 1846Wood engraving after Brown’s cartoon; engraver unknown
The Execution of Mary Queen of Scots1840–1842Oil on canvas
The Prisoner of Chillon (Manchester oil)1843Oil on canvas
The Parting of Cordelia from Her Sisters (oil)1853Oil on canvas
Cordelia’s Portion (Lady Lever)1866–1872Watercolour, gouache and pastel
The Ascension1844–1845Oil on canvas
Manfred in the Chamois Hunter’s Hut (oil sketch)1840Oil on canvas
Dr Primrose and His Daughters (The Vicar of Wakefield)1840–1841Oil on canvas
The Body of Harold Brought before William the Conqueror1844–1861Oil on canvas
The Seeds and Fruits of English Poetry (Bedford cartoon)1845Black chalk on paper
Wycliffe Reading His Translation of the Bible (oil sketch)1847–1848Oil on board
Cromwell Discussing the Protection of the Vaudois (Nottingham)1877–1878Oil on canvas
Two Drawings of Men in Hoodsc.1845Pencil on paper
The Seeds and Fruits of English Poetry: Study of the Right Sidec.1845Brown pen and ink with pencil
Chaucer: A Man in a Hood with a Liripipe and Two Drapery Studies1848Oil on canvas
The Prisoner of Chillon Entreating His Jailors (Yale watercolour)1858Watercolour heightened with bodycolour
Elijah and the Widow’s Son (Birmingham oil)1864Oil on panel
He That Soweth (Lyra Germanica)Published 1868Wood engraving by the Dalziel Brothers after Brown
The Entombment (NGV)1871–1878Watercolour, gouache, gold paint and gum arabic over pencil
The Sower (Morris firm tile)c.1864–1873Tile; design by Brown, workshop execution
Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage (Byron illustration)Published 1870Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown
The Two Foscari (Byron illustration)Published 1870Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown
The Corsair (Byron illustration)Published 1870Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown
Sardanapalus (Byron illustration)Published 1870Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown
Don Juan (Byron illustration)Published 1870Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown
Byron’s Dream (roundel title-page design)Published 1870Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown
The Finding of Don Juan by Haidée (Birmingham oil)1870–1873Oil on canvas
The Dream of Sardanapalus (Delaware)1871–1872Watercolour on paper
The Traveller (Once a Week)Published 1869Wood engraving by Joseph Swain after Brown
The Infant’s Repast1848Oil on board
Oliver Madox Brown Aged Four (Dwale Bluth frontispiece)Published 1876Etching
Oliver Madox Brown as a Young Man (Dwale Bluth frontispiece)Published 1876Etching
A Beggar and Other Fantasies: Title-page IllustrationPublished 1889Photo-engraving after Brown
Dramas in Miniature: Title-page IllustrationPublished 1891Photo-engraving after Brown
The Brown Owl: FrontispiecePublished 1892Photo-engraving after Brown
The Brown Owl: Central IllustrationPublished 1892Photo-engraving after Brown
The Feather: FrontispiecePublished 1892Photo-engraving after Brown
The Ascension: Study for Christ1844Pen and ink
King Lear: Lear Questions Cordelia (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: France Claims the Dispossessed Cordelia (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Cordelia Parts from Her Sisters (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Goneril and Regan Together (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Goneril Tells Oswald How to Treat Lear (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Oswald’s Insolence to Lear (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear Rebukes Oswald (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Kent Trips Oswald (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Goneril’s Complaint to Lear (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear Curses Goneril’s Infidelity (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Kent Challenges Oswald (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Kent in the Stocks (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear Recounts His Wrongs to Regan (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear Parts from Regan and Goneril (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear and the Fool in the Storm (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear Mad on the Beach at Dover (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Alternative Study: Lear Curses Goneril (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
King Lear: Lear Imagines His Daughters’ Trial (Whitworth)1844Pencil
King Lear: Alternative Study: Lear in the Storm (Whitworth)1844Pencil, pen and brown ink
The Last of England (Fitzwilliam)1860Oil on canvas
The Convalescent (Metropolitan Museum)Dated 1872Pastel
Self-Portrait (Walker drawing)1850; retouched 1853Black chalk
Byron’s Dream (Whitworth)1889Watercolour over graphite
Cordelia Parting from Her Sisters (Cleveland sketch)1854Pen and oil on paper mounted on panel
David and Goliath: Cartoon for Stained Glass Window at Jesus College, Cambridge1872Charcoal and graphite on Japanese paper
The Virgin Swooning (recto)1844Black chalk on laid paper
Two Drapery Studies (verso)c.1844Black chalk
Architecture: King René’s Honeymoon (stained glass)1862Stained glass; designed by Brown, made by Morris, Marshall, Faulkner & Co.
The Romans Building a Fort at Mancenion (Town Hall mural)1880Spirit fresco
The Baptism of Edwin (Town Hall mural)1879–1880Spirit fresco
The Expulsion of the Danes (Town Hall mural)1880–1881Spirit fresco
The Establishment of the Flemish Weavers (Town Hall mural)1881–1882Spirit fresco
Crabtree Watching the Transit of Venus (Town Hall mural)1882–1883Spirit fresco
The Proclamation Regarding Weights and Measures (Town Hall mural)1883–1884Spirit fresco
Wycliffe on Trial (Town Hall mural)1885–1886Spirit fresco
Chetham’s Life’s Dream (Town Hall mural)1885–1886Mural on canvas
Bradshaw’s Defence of Manchester (Town Hall mural)1892–1893Mural on canvas
John Kay, Inventor of the Fly Shuttle (Town Hall mural)1888–1890Mural on canvas
The Opening of the Bridgewater Canal (Town Hall mural)1891–1892Mural on canvas

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Stages of Cruelty ?

The oil painting is in Manchester Art Gallery’s collection, accession 1911.104. It measures 73.3 × 59.9 cm without its frame. [3]

Why does the painting have two dates?

Brown began it in 1856 and returned to it much later. Hueffer’s chronological account records its completion in August and September 1890. The date span reflects interrupted making, rather than continuous work throughout those years. [1]

What is the child holding?

She raises a stem of love-lies-bleeding above the dog. The gallery interprets the plant through the Victorian language of flowers; its physical role as a threatened switch is also central to the scene. [3]

Is Tate’s Stages of Cruelty the same painting?

No. Tate has a small watercolour on paper, dated around 1856, accession N04625. Manchester’s work is the larger oil on canvas developed between 1856 and 1890. [4] [1]

Discussion

Look again at the images and ideas explored in Stages of Cruelty by Ford Madox Brown. These editorial prompts invite your observations.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Does the comparison convince you?

The child’s threatened blow and the woman’s refusal of her lover occupy the same picture. Consider how much of their apparent similarity comes from the gestures, and how much from the title. Does the composition encourage sympathy for the man in the same way that it encourages sympathy for the dog?

Editorial prompt · Follow the hands

Move from the man’s grip to the woman’s needlework, then down to the child’s lead and raised stem. Each hand establishes a different relationship with another body or object. Which contact seems affectionate, possessive, indifferent or threatening, and where does the distinction remain uncertain?

Editorial prompt · Look at the leaves before the flowers

The flower names offer clues, but the mass of foliage also shapes the experience of the scene. Imagine the figures against an open sky instead. How would that change the closeness of the encounter, the lovers’ privacy and the impression of being unable to look away?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Stages of Cruelty by Ford Madox Brown below.

References

  1. Ford Madox Hueffer , Ford Madox Brown: A Record of His Life and Work (1896), pp.107, 129–132, 140 and 385. Brown’s 1856 diary is reproduced within Hueffer’s biography; the critical assessment on p.107 is Hueffer’s own. View source .
  2. Laura MacCulloch , Ford Madox Brown: Works on Paper and Archive Material at Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery , PhD thesis, University of Birmingham (2009), vol.1, pp.282–283, catalogue 143 and related works. View source .
  3. Manchester Art Gallery , Stages of Cruelty , collection record: summary, date, medium, support, dimensions and accession 1911.104; flower-language interpretation. View source .
  4. Tate , official historical collection dataset, Stages of Cruelty , N04625: watercolour on paper, c.1856, support 143 × 121 mm. View source .
  5. The Morgan Library & Museum , First Stage of Cruelty , online exhibition entry and Jennifer Tonkovich’s audio transcript, explaining Tom Nero’s abuse of animals and its relation to his later violence. View source .
  6. Ford Madox Hueffer, Ford Madox Brown: A Record of His Life and Work, 1896; selected career, object and mural passages. View source.
  7. Laura MacCulloch, Ford Madox Brown: Works on Paper and Archive Material at Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery, 2009, volumeI; catalogue entries. View source.
  8. Tim Barringer, Ford Madox Brown, Work, MAVCOR, 2014. View source.
  9. Tate, official historical collection dataset; Ford Madox Brown accession records. View source.
  10. National Portrait Gallery, Henry Fawcett and Millicent Garrett Fawcett, NPG1603; portrait and frame record. View source.
  11. Laura MacCulloch, Ford Madox Brown: Works on Paper and Archive Material at Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery, 2009, volumeII; illustration lists, pp1–24. View source.
  12. Fitzwilliam Museum, The Last of England, M.Add.3. View source.
  13. Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Convalescent, 10.46. View source.
  14. Carol Blackett-Ord / National Portrait Gallery, Ford Madox Brown: all known portraits. View source.
  15. The Whitworth / Art UK, Byron’s Dream, 1889 watercolour. View source.
  16. Cleveland Museum of Art, Cordelia Parting from Her Sisters, 2013.261. View source.
  17. Cleveland Museum of Art, David and Goliath: Cartoon for Stained Glass Window at Jesus College, Cambridge, 1872, 2013.247. View source.
  18. National Gallery of Art, The Virgin Swooning, recto, 1987.73.1.a. View source.
  19. National Gallery of Art, Two Drapery Studies, verso, object70237. View source.
  20. Victoria and Albert Museum, Architecture: King René’s Honeymoon, CIRC.516-1953. View source.
  21. Manchester City Council, The Ford Madox Brown Murals; cycle and individual scenes. View source.
  22. Splash image, Ford Madox Brown, Stages of Cruelty, 1856–1890. Oil on canvas. Manchester Art Gallery, 1911.104.