Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois by Ford Madox Brown: Introduction
A ruler, a poet and a writer crowd around a table. Cromwell turns towards Milton, Milton raises a hand, and Andrew Marvell waits with his pen. In Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois , Ford Madox Brown makes the preparation of a diplomatic letter into an encounter between force, language and thought. The Manchester Art Gallery painting dates from 1877. [1]
Its subject is Cromwell’s intervention for persecuted Protestants in the Alpine valleys of Piedmont. Brown’s letters reveal how he constructed the scene: he selected a dispatch to the French king and imagined its passage from Cromwell’s instructions through Milton’s Latin to Marvell’s pen. The result is a Victorian reconstruction of political action, rather than a record of a witnessed meeting. [2]
At a Glance
- Artist Ford Madox Brown.
- Title Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois .
- Date 1877.
- Medium Oil on canvas.
- Collection Manchester Art Gallery. [1]
- Figures Oliver Cromwell at the right, John Milton at the left, Andrew Marvell writing between them. [2]
- Related version A slightly smaller oil in Nottingham, dated 1877–78 by Laura MacCulloch. [3]
This work across Ford Madox Brown’s career
Manfred on the Jungfrau
1841; retouched 1861Pretty Baa-Lambs
1851–1859The Last of England
1852–1855Work
1852–1865King René’s Honeymoon
Tate watercolour, 1864Manchester Murals
1878–1893Contents
- The Persecution Behind the Letter
- How a Request for Milton Became a Group Scene
- Three Figures, Three Kinds of Action
- The Room and Its Smaller Clues
- Carlyle and Brown’s Victorian Cromwell
- Manchester and Nottingham: Two Separate Paintings
The Persecution Behind the Letter
The Vaudois, also called Waldensians, were a Protestant community in the valleys of Piedmont, now in northern Italy. The massacres of 1655 prompted Cromwell to seek relief for the survivors through fundraising and international diplomacy. Milton helped articulate that response in letters of state. The historian Charles Firth describes both the appeal to other Protestant powers and pressure on France to intervene with Savoy. [4]
Brown chose a later moment in this continuing crisis. Writing to his patron Charles Rowley on 24 February 1877, he identified a dispatch to the King of France from May 1658, shortly before Cromwell’s death. Hueffer’s account specifies 26 May. The distinction matters: the painting’s background is the slaughter of 1655, but the document Brown selected concerns renewed danger after the settlement that followed it. [2]
The surviving letter to Louis XIV, in the English translation published with Carlyle’s edition, looks back on the massacre and complains that the subsequent peace has been violated. It describes expulsions, restrictions on religious practice and further violence, then appeals to the French king’s ability to protect the threatened people. Its argument joins compassion, Christian obligation and the responsibilities of an allied ruler. [5]
That helps explain why Brown could make a letter the centre of a history painting. Words here are intended to produce action beyond the room. The map on the table supplies a visible connection with the distant territory; the men’s different tasks show how a response might be formulated. The people whose suffering motivates the exchange remain outside the picture.
How a Request for Milton Became a Group Scene
The subject developed from a patron’s request. In a letter to Frederic Shields dated 13 February, reproduced by Hueffer in his account of 1877, Brown reported that Rowley wanted “a Milton with a Cromwell doing something together.” Brown initially felt the commission displaced subjects of his own, but said he had devised a scene in his head ten minutes later. [2]
Research then changed that first conception. On 24 February he told Rowley that he had established Milton’s blindness at the relevant date and found the May 1658 dispatch translated near the end of Carlyle’s Letters and Speeches . He proposed to show Cromwell dictating or giving instructions to Milton, who would dictate the Latin to Marvell. His concluding reservation was practical and revealing: “I have still to think a great deal about it before I begin.” [2]
These letters distinguish an initial idea from a worked-out design. They also show that Marvell’s presence was integral to Brown’s solution. Adding a third person gave the exchange an observable destination: spoken instructions would become a written document. Milton’s blindness could be acknowledged through the action itself.
Hueffer places the painting’s execution between February and October 1877, alongside Brown’s self-portrait . The February letters make clear how much conceptual work lay behind that span. [2]
Brown had explained this distinction much earlier in his essay on designing a historical picture. He advised painters to research the people and their surroundings, then imagine the story and work out the actions of the figures before proceeding through studies. That 1850 account offers a useful context for the construction of his compositions , without proving that every prescribed step survives for this canvas. [6]
Three Figures, Three Kinds of Action
Cromwell occupies the foreground at the right. Armour, a red sash and long boots give his body a dense, angular presence. He sits across the corner of the table, turning sharply towards Milton. One hand holds a small piece of paper; the other reaches down over the map. The body seems too expansive for its position, yet the turn of the head directs its energy back into the room.
Hueffer interprets Cromwell’s expression as indignation and describes the map as the territory ravaged by the Duke of Savoy. His account contrasts the Protector’s forceful manner with Milton’s controlled bearing. The contrast gives the exchange much of its dramatic character. [2]
Look at the difference between Cromwell’s two hands. The scrap of paper is held close to his chest, while the hand above the map gives the discussion a geographical point of reference. A written prompt, a territory and an urgent address to another person are compressed into one pose. Armour remains conspicuous, but the immediate instrument of action is the letter being prepared.
Milton answers this physical weight with a different rhythm. Seated at the left, he has crossed legs and a comparatively narrow silhouette. His dark clothing falls into long folds, relieved by white at the collar and cuffs. One finger is raised near his face; his other hand stretches into the interval between himself and Cromwell. The hands seem to measure or qualify the exchange.
Hueffer reads Milton’s extended gesture as a check on Cromwell’s flow of words while the poet formulates the Latin. Brown’s own February letter supplies the underlying sequence. Together, letter and painting make Milton’s work an active transformation of the message. [2]
Marvell is easy to overlook because he has been placed behind the table and partly hidden by Cromwell. His face emerges against the dark fireplace. The light sleeve and writing hand bring him forward again, drawing attention to the pen poised above the document. He looks up towards the speakers while remaining ready to write.
His partial concealment gives the scene depth and makes the viewer search for the third participant. It also creates a pause. The pen has not simply finished its task: it waits on words still being formed. Brown lets the viewer see a process in progress, with each person dependent on another.
The most useful way to follow the composition is therefore to move between the hands. Cromwell supplies instructions; Milton shapes their verbal form; Marvell records them. This division is Brown’s stated conception, realised through unequal but connected poses. [2]
Watch: Ford Madox Brown
Choose a film exploring the people, stories and visual details in two of Brown’s best-known paintings.
Pre-Raphaelites: Ford Madox Brown – Work
Curator Tim Barringer explores the figures and stories within Work.
Watch on YouTubeThe Room and Its Smaller Clues
The room is tightly filled. A carved table projects towards the viewer, and its decorated support occupies much of the lower centre. Behind the men, a pale fireplace, patterned upholstery and heavy curtains divide the interior into distinct areas. The table links these areas while the figures turn across them.
Colour helps distinguish the three bodies without isolating them. The warm red around Cromwell’s armour is echoed behind him and around Marvell; Milton’s pale face and hands stand out against his darker clothes. Small illuminated areas keep the conversation legible within an otherwise crowded setting.
Hueffer places the encounter in Milton’s house in Petty France and describes red afternoon light falling across the room. He identifies the instrument behind Milton as his organ and suggests that its carved surround resembles a laurel crown around the poet’s head. He also identifies the flowers at Milton’s feet as dropped roses, the paper near Cromwell’s boots as a proclamation of a solemn fast, and the dark band on Cromwell’s arm as mourning for the Vaudois dead. [2]
These details give the room two overlapping characters. The organ and flowers belong to Milton’s personal surroundings; the map, proclamation and mourning band connect the conversation with public events. The apparent crown is particularly subtle: Hueffer’s reading depends on the alignment of an ordinary furnishing with the sitter’s head. The carved object takes on an additional meaning through its position within the composition. [2]
Carlyle and Brown’s Victorian Cromwell
Carlyle’s relevance is unusually well documented here. Brown explicitly named his translation of the dispatch while planning the painting. The connection reaches into Brown’s choice of the historical moment itself. [2]
MacCulloch places Brown’s two Cromwell subjects within the nineteenth-century reassessment of the ruler, in which Carlyle played a central part. Her account makes the picture part of Victorian historical culture as well as a representation of the seventeenth century. [3]
The title’s protective role and the choice of a persecuted Protestant community give this Cromwell a sympathetic purpose. Even his awkward, forceful pose contributes to a picture of urgency. Yet this selective episode cannot serve as a comprehensive judgment of his rule. Brown concentrates attention on a particular act of intervention and on the people who formulate it; the viewer should recognise the scope of that choice.
A brief comparison with Cromwell on His Farm makes the change clear. The earlier composition surrounds the future ruler with rural work and other people. Here the space contracts around three figures and a shared intellectual task. MacCulloch treats both as sympathetic constructions of Cromwell, while distinguishing their different human settings. [3]
Ford Madox Brown, Cromwell on His Farm, completed 1874. Lady Lever Art Gallery. An earlier phase of Cromwell’s life in a different composition.
Manchester and Nottingham: Two Separate Paintings
Manchester Art Gallery’s oil is dated 1877. There is also a slightly smaller version in Nottingham, which MacCulloch dates to 1877–78. The two dates describe separate paintings of the same subject. [1] [3]
Hueffer records that Brown began a duplicate in December 1877, after completing the first painting in October. This account helps explain the overlapping dates, although it does not by itself provide a complete ownership history for both canvases. They preserve a related composition while remaining distinct physical works within Brown’s paintings . [2]
Artworks directory
Explore paintings, drawings, cartoons, illustrations and decorative designs documented in museum collections and specialist research. Distinct versions are listed separately; repeated print impressions are grouped. The coverage includes studies and works without a dedicated article and remains open to further research.
| Name | Date | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| Work (Manchester) | 1852–1865 | Oil on canvas |
| The Last of England (Birmingham) | 1852–1855 | Oil on panel |
| Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet | 1852–1856 | Oil on canvas |
| Pretty Baa-Lambs | 1851–1859 | Oil on panel |
| Take Your Son, Sir | ?1851–1892 | Oil on canvas |
| Lear and Cordelia | 1849–1854 | Oil on canvas |
| Cordelia’s Portion | 1867–1875 | Oil on canvas |
| Walton-on-the-Naze | 1859–1860 | Oil on canvas |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III (Tate) | 1856–1868 | Oil on canvas |
| Carrying Corn | 1854–1855 | Oil on mahogany |
| The Hayfield (The Hay Harvest) | 1855–1856 | Oil on mahogany |
| Stages of Cruelty | 1856–1890 | Oil on canvas |
| The Irish Girl | 1860 | Oil on canvas laid on board |
| Romeo and Juliet (Delaware) | 1869–1870 | Oil on canvas |
| The Seeds and Fruit of English Poetry | 1845–1853 | Oil on canvas |
| Self-Portrait | 1877 | Oil on canvas |
| The Bromley Children | Probably 1844 | Oil on canvas |
| The Bromley Family | 1844 | Oil on canvas |
| Byron’s Dream (Manchester) | 1874; worked on into 1875 | Oil on canvas |
| Cartoon for The Baptism of Edwin | 1879–1891 | Pastel, coloured chalks and grey gouache |
| The Coat of Many Colours | 1864–1866 | Oil on canvas |
| The Convalescent (Birmingham) | Dated October 1872 | Pastel |
| Crabtree Watching the Transit of Venus (reduced painting) | 1881–1888 | Tempera on panel |
| Cromwell on His Farm (Lady Lever) | Completed 1874 | Oil on canvas |
| Cromwell Protector of the Vaudois | 1877 | Oil on canvas |
| Dalton Collecting Marsh-Fire Gas (Town Hall mural) | 1886–1887 | Mural on canvas |
| The Establishment of the Flemish Weavers (reduced painting) | 1881; completed 1888 | Tempera on panel |
| The Finding of Don Juan by Haidée (NGV) | 1869–1870; later retouched | Watercolour and gouache over pencil |
| Henry and Millicent Fawcett | 1872 | Oil on canvas |
| Jacob and Joseph’s Coat (Ponce) | c.1868–1871 | Oil on canvas |
| James Leathart | 1863–1864; altered 1869 | Oil on canvas |
| King René’s Honeymoon (Tate watercolour) | 1864 | Graphite, watercolour, gouache and gum arabic on card |
| King René’s Honeymoon Cabinet (collaborative work) | 1861; exhibited 1862 | Oak, inlaid woods, painted panels and metal mounts; Brown designed Architecture |
| Manfred on the Jungfrau | 1841; retouched 1861 | Oil on canvas |
| Millie Smith | 1846 | Oil on paper laid on panel |
| William Michael Rossetti by Lamplight | 1856–1857 | Oil on panel |
| The Traveller (Manchester oil) | 1868–1884 | Oil on panel |
| Waiting: An English Fireside of 1854–55 | 1851–1855 | Oil on panel |
| An English Autumn Afternoon | 1852–1853; finished c.1854 | Oil on canvas |
| Alfred the Great: Sketch of Alfred drawing in the Sand | 1843–1845 | pencil |
| Historical Notes and Sketches of Alfred the Great | 1843–1850 | brown ink writing over pencil |
| Angels watching the Crown of Thorns: Study of clasped Hands | 1846 | black chalk |
| Architecture: Study of Gothic Arches and 14th Century Vaulting | c. 1847 | brown pen and ink over pencil on grey paper |
| The Ascension: Study of Angels and Hands | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| The Ascension: Study of a Group of Angels | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| The Ascension: Study of a Group of six flying Angels | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| The Ascension: Two nude Angels holding onto each other | 1844 | brown brush and ink over pencil |
| The Ascension: Study for a kneeling Apostle | 1844 | black chalk touched with white on brown-toned paper |
| Head of a Child | c. 1844 | black chalk touched with white on brown toned paper |
| The Ascension: Drapery Study of a praying Apostle | 1844 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Seated Figure in ecclesiastical Robes, gripping a Staff with left Hand raised in a Blessing | 1844 | black chalk |
| The Ascension: Study for an Apostle | 1844 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Body of seated Figure in ecclesiastical Robes holding a Staff and a Book | 1844 | black chalk |
| The Ascension: Study of an Apostle | 1844 | black chalk on toned paper |
| Full-length Sketch of a standing, naked Child | 1844 | black chalk on toned paper |
| The Ascension: Study for Christ | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Caricature: Composite Drawing: A Stunner | 1861–1863 | pencil |
| A Victorian Woman in her Underwear | 1861–1863 | pencil |
| Caricature: Composite Drawing: Bewigged Head | 1861–1863 | pencil |
| Bowed Head of a bearded Man | 1861–1863 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Early compositional Study | 1845 | pencil with brown pen and ink |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study for Milton and two Designs for Tombstones | c.1845–c.1846 | pencil with brown frame outline |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Tracing of the Figure of Milton | c.1845–c.1849 | brown pen and ink with pencil on tracing paper |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Tracing of a Gothic Arch | c.1845–c.1849 | brown pen and ink with pencil on tracing paper |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Early compositional Study | 1845 | pencil with brown pen and ink |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies of two Boys | 1845 | pencil, laid down |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies of four Figures | 1845 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Eight early Studies of Figures and Hands | 1845 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies for the Figures of Byron, Shakespeare and Burns | 1845 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for Burns | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a right Leg and left Foot for Milton | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a left Leg for Shakespeare | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Drapery for Milton | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for Shakespeare | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a Man in a medieval Hood | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study for the Cardinal | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study in Profile for Courtier | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Female Nude Study of a Muse holding onto a Rail | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Female Nude: Study of a Muse | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Study for seated Lady | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Study of a Woman with right Arm raised | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Studies of Back of a seated Woman's Head | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Studies of a seated Woman in lost Profile Pose and from the Back | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Study of a Woman | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Sketch of a Woman supporting another Figure | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of the Heads and Shoulders of two Women | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for Edward III with Outline of a Child | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Foreshortened Study for Head of a Jester | 1847 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Head of Alexander Pope | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Hand Studies | 1847 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Head of Milton copied from Sculpture | 1848 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Nude Studies for the Squire and the Courtier talking to Gower | 1848 | pencil |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for the Black Prince | 1848 | black chalk with touches of white |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Three Studies of Hands | 1848 | Black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Four Studies of Hands | 1848 | black chalk touched with white |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a clasped right Hand for one of the Poets | 1848 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of a left Hand for Burns | 1848 | black chalk heightened with touches of white |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Drapery for Burns | 1848 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study | 1848 | black chalk |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Drapery Study for the Black Prince | 1851 | black and white chalks on brown-toned paper |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study for Squire's Legs | 1851 | black chalk heightened with white |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Two Head Studies of an old Woman | 1851 | black chalk |
| Costume Study: Five Sketches of Armour and Costume | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Costume Study: Archbishop's Dress | 1845 | brown pen and ink on tracing paper |
| Costume Studies: French and Italian thirteenth and fourteenth-century Costumes (seven Drawings) | 1845 | brown pen and ink on tracing paper |
| Costume Study: Seigneur de Rimini | 1845 | brown pen and ink on tracing paper |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: The Death of Eglon | 1863–1865 | engraved woodblock; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: The Death of Eglon | 1881 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Elijah and the Widow's Son | 1863–1865 | engraved woodblock; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Elijah and the Widow's Son | 1881 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Joseph’s Coat (Compositional Sketch and four Studies for Jacob's Granddaughter) | 1863–1865 | pencil on paper |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Joseph's Coat | 1863–1865 | engraved woodblock; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers |
| Dalziels' Bible Gallery: Joseph’s Coat | 1881 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, engraved by the Dalziel Brothers |
| Decorative Sketches: Venus Reclining on a Shell in the Midst of the Sea | 1848–1849 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Decorative Design: Ornamental Pattern | 1850 | watercolour and bodycolour over pen and ink, and pencil on two sheets of paper |
| Down Stream: Main Illustration (Last Year's First of May) | 1871 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| Down Stream: Tailpiece to the Poem (This Year's First of June) | 1871 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| The Establishment of Flemish Weavers in Manchester A.D. 1363: Four Studies of Parts of a Horse | 1879–1882 | black, white and red chalk on rough brown paper |
| Female: Two Studies of young Woman in eighteenth-century Costume | 1849 | pencil |
| Infant's Repast: Study of Mother and Child | 1848 | black and white chalk |
| Infant's Repast: Study of Mother and Child with separate Arm and Leg Studies of the Child | 1848 | black chalk with grey wash |
| King Lear: Sketch of Lear questioning Cordelia | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Alfred the Great: Compositional Sketches | 1843–1845 | pencil |
| King Lear: Sketches of Lear imagining his unfaithful Daughters’ Trial and Lear in the Storm | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Alfred the Great: Compositional Studies and Sketches and Chaucer at the Court of Edward III: Study of Cherubs | 1843–1849 | pencil |
| King Lear: Kent accuses Oswald | 1844 | brown pen and ink with pencil underneath |
| King Lear: Lear recounts his Wrongs to Regan | Undated | Brown pen and ink over pencil |
| King Lear: Cordelia at Lear's Bedside (Lear's Awakening) | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Cordelia Parting from Her Sisters (The Germ) | 1850; reprinted 1901 | Etching; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| King René's Honeymoon: Study for Architecture | 1861 | brush and brown ink, with watercolour, over pencil on brown paper |
| The Last of England: Cartoon | 1852 | pencil, image edged with brown ink |
| The Last of England: Portrait of Emma Hill | December 1852 | chalks with scratching out on two sheets of paper |
| Lear and Cordelia and The Infant’s Repast: Four Studies of Hands | 1849 | black chalk |
| Lyra Germanica - the Christian Life: Abraham and Isaac | 1868 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| Lyra Germanica - the Christian Life: Finished Design for The Entombment | 1867 | black pen and ink |
| Lyra Germanica - the Christian Life: The Entombment | 1868 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| Male: Sketch of Man reclining on Steps with Hands bound together | 1844 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| Male: Academic nude Study, half-length with Moustache and Arms folded | 1846–1849 | black chalk |
| Male: Academic Study of Nude holding a Staff | 1847 | pencil |
| Male: Academic Study of Nude posed as a Sculptor | 1847 | chalk with grey wash |
| Male: Academic Study, three-quarter length Nude, with a Moustache and clenched Fists | 1847 | black chalk |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Seven Sketches | 1846 | pencil |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Four Studies for Angel holding Child | 1847 | pencil |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Angel holding Child | 1847 | black chalk |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Arm and Hands for Angel holding Bowl of Water | 1847 | black chalk |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Drapery Study for Angel holding Bowl of Water | 1847 | black chalk |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Head for Angel holding Bowl of Water | 1847 | black chalk with rubbing and grey wash |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study of Child seated on Knees of the Virgin and two separate Studies of the Child's Legs | 1847 | pencil on brown-toned paper |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Frieze Design | c. 1847 | pencil and black pen and ink |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Three Studies of Arms and Legs of Child | 1847 | pencil |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Three Studies of Child's Legs on Virgin's Knees | 1847 | pencil |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Studies of Right Foot and Left Hand of Child | 1847 | pencil on light brown paper |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Drapery Study for Virgin | 1847 | black chalk |
| Oure Ladye of Saturday Night: Study for Head of Virgin | 1847 | black chalk with wash |
| Parisina’s Sleep: Study for Prince Azo and Parisina | 1842 | black chalk with pencil side drawing |
| Parisina's Sleep: Study for Head of Prince Azo | 1842 | black chalk with grey wash |
| Parisina's Sleep: Study for the Head of Parisina | 1842 | black and white chalk with grey wash |
| Poets of the Nineteenth Century: The Prisoner of Chillon: Compositional Sketch | 1856 | pencil |
| Profile of a Man's left Eye and Nose | c.1856 | pencil |
| Poets of the Nineteenth Century: The Prisoner of Chillon: Study of a Corpse | 1856 | pencil |
| Designs for Decoration | c.1856 | pencil |
| Poets of the Nineteenth Century: The Prisoner of Chillon | 1857 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| Portrait: Head Study of Daniel Casey (three-quarter view) | 1848 | black chalk |
| Portrait: Head Study of Daniel Casey (full-face) | 1848 | black chalk |
| Portrait: Miss Iza Duffus Hardy | 1872 | pastel and coloured chalks on brown paper |
| Portrait: Emma Hill (later Mrs Madox Brown) | 1848 | black chalk |
| Portrait: Emma Hill (later Mrs Madox Brown) | 1852 | pencil |
| Portrait: Mrs Madox Brown (neé Emma Hill) | 9 May 1854 | pencil |
| The Repose in Egypt: Compositional Sketch | 1847 | pencil |
| Study of a Statue of the Discobolus | 1845 | Black chalk |
| William Shakespeare: Study | 1849–1850 | pencil |
| William Shakespeare: Invitation Card | 1850 | wood engraving; designed by Brown, print execution by an engraver |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for Baron and his Advisor, with Sketches of Erudition and Wisdom | 1844–1845 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| The Spirit of Justice: Drapery Study for Erudition | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| Drapery Study and Sketch of Two Legs | Undated | Black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for Wisdom | 1844–1845 | black chalk with grey wash |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of the Baron | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for the Head of central Bishop | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for the Head of a Bishop | 1844–1845 | black chalk with grey wash |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for the uplifted left Arm of Justice | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of Counsellor in a Coronet | 1844–1845 | black chalk with touches of blue chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of Counsellor | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Drapery Study for the Central Bishop | 1844–1845 | Black chalk |
| Part of a Drapery Study | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| The Spirit of Justice: Study for Head of Widow | 1844–1845 | black chalk |
| Stages of Cruelty: Study for the Child (Catherine Madox Brown) | 1857 | black chalk on pale grey paper |
| Stained Glass Design: Cartoon for Zachariah, The High Priest | 1872 | black chalk |
| Stained Glass Design: Cartoon for The Young Milton | 1874 | black chalk |
| Stained Glass Design: Cartoon for St Simon | 1874 | black chalk |
| Sterne's 'Sentimental Journey': Study for Yorick and La Fleur talking to Maria’s Mother | 1842 | brown pen and ink over pencil |
| The Body of Harold brought before William the Conqueror: Eight Sketches of Figure Groups | c.1844 | pencil |
| Sterne's 'Sentimental Journey' : Yorick (Laurence Sterne) and Maria Walking | 1842 | pen and ink, watercolour and bodycolour over pencil |
| Study of Tree Trunk with Roots | c.1847 | black chalk, heightened with white chalk on buff paper |
| Two Studies of Tree Trunks | c.1846 | black chalk |
| Unknown Subject: Compositional Sketch | 1843–1850 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study for Chaucer | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Chaucer | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study of Gower | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Gower | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study for John of Gaunt and Chaucer's right Hand | 1847 | pencil and black chalk |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of John of Gaunt and Chaucer's Left Hand | 1847 | pencil and black chalk |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Wycliffe | 1847 | black chalk |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Nude Study for Wycliffe | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Drapery Study for Wycliffe | 1847 | black chalk |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Drapery Study for Chaucer | 1848 | black chalk |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of Legs for John of Gaunt and two Studies of Feet for Wycliffe | 1848 | black chalk |
| Wycliffe Reading his Translation of the Bible: Studies of Hands for John of Gaunt and Gower | 1847 | black chalk |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Head of Wycliffe | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Constance and Child | 1847 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Unfinished Study for Head of Constance | 1847–48 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Portrait of Elizabeth Bamford modelling for Constance | 1848 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Head of Constance | 1848 | chalk over pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study for Head of Chaucer | 1848 | pencil |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of Monk representing the Catholic Faith | 1848 | black chalk with brown pen and ink, squared up |
| Wycliffe reading his Translation of the Bible: Study of young Woman representing the Protestant Faith | 1848 | black chalk |
| Cathy Madox Brown at the Age of Three (Tate N01356) | 1853 | Graphite on paper |
| King René‘s Honeymoon (Tate N02409) | date not known | Ink on paper |
| Sheepshearing (Tate N02410) | c.1887 | Ink and graphite on paper |
| Studies for ‘Work’ (Tate N02411) | 1855 | Graphite and ink on paper |
| Design for Badge for Gillum’s Homes (Tate N02412) | date not known | Ink and graphite on paper |
| Arkwright’s Mill (Tate N02413) | 1878 | Graphite on paper |
| Study for ‘John Kay’ (Tate N02414) | 1889 | Graphite on paper |
| Study for ‘Southend’ (Tate N02415) | date not known | Graphite on paper |
| ‘Where are you going, my pretty maid?’ (Tate N02416) | date not known | Graphite on paper |
| Section of the Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02417) | 1890 | Ink on paper |
| A Barge on the Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02418) | 1890 | Graphite on paper |
| Study of the Tow-Path on the Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02419) | 1890 | Graphite on paper |
| Our Lady of Good Children (Tate N02684) | 1847–61 | Pastel, watercolour and gold paint on paper |
| Arkwright’s Mill (Tate N02791) | 1881 | Graphite on paper |
| The Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02792) | 1890 | Ink on paper |
| The Bridgewater Canal (Tate N02793) | date not known | Chalk and graphite on paper |
| The Last of England (Tate N03064) | 1864–6 | Watercolour on paper |
| Mauvais Sujet (Tate N03228) | 1863 | Watercolour on paper |
| Study of a Man Painting (Tate N03472) | 1839 | Graphite on paper |
| The Brent at Hendon (Tate N03528) | 1854–5 | Oil paint on board on mahogany |
| Study for the Dean in the ‘Execution of Mary Queen of Scots’ (Tate N04280) | c.1840 | Oil paint on paper |
| Sketch for ‘Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet’ (Tate N04281) | 1852 | Graphite on paper |
| Sketch for ‘Cromwell on his Farm’ (Tate N04282) | c.1853 | Graphite on paper |
| The Coat of Many Colours (Tate N04584) | 1867 | Watercolour and gouache on paper |
| Stages of Cruelty (Tate N04625) | c.1856 | Watercolour on paper |
| Head of a Girl (Tate N04803) | date not known | Oil paint on paper |
| Portrait of Dykes Barry as a Child (Tate N04866) | 1853 | Oil paint on mahogany |
| Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet (Tate N05301) | 1857–8 | Watercolour on paper |
| Platt Lane (Tate N05383) | 1884 | Oil paint on canvas |
| Study of F.G. Stephens for ‘Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet’. Verso: A Head Crowned with Laurels (Tate T00571) | 1852 | Graphite on paper. Verso: graphite on paper |
| Sketch for ‘Jesus Washing Peter’s Feet’ (Tate T01035) | c.1851 | Ink and graphite on paper |
| Chaucer at the Court of Edward III (Sydney) | 1845–1851 | Oil on canvas |
| Wycliffe Reading His Translation of the Bible to John of Gaunt (Bradford) | 1848 | Oil on canvas |
| Work (Birmingham replica) | 1859–1863 | Oil on canvas |
| The Spirit of Justice (Book of Art reproduction) | Published 1846 | Wood engraving after Brown’s cartoon; engraver unknown |
| The Execution of Mary Queen of Scots | 1840–1842 | Oil on canvas |
| The Prisoner of Chillon (Manchester oil) | 1843 | Oil on canvas |
| The Parting of Cordelia from Her Sisters (oil) | 1853 | Oil on canvas |
| Cordelia’s Portion (Lady Lever) | 1866–1872 | Watercolour, gouache and pastel |
| The Ascension | 1844–1845 | Oil on canvas |
| Manfred in the Chamois Hunter’s Hut (oil sketch) | 1840 | Oil on canvas |
| Dr Primrose and His Daughters (The Vicar of Wakefield) | 1840–1841 | Oil on canvas |
| The Body of Harold Brought before William the Conqueror | 1844–1861 | Oil on canvas |
| The Seeds and Fruits of English Poetry (Bedford cartoon) | 1845 | Black chalk on paper |
| Wycliffe Reading His Translation of the Bible (oil sketch) | 1847–1848 | Oil on board |
| Cromwell Discussing the Protection of the Vaudois (Nottingham) | 1877–1878 | Oil on canvas |
| Two Drawings of Men in Hoods | c.1845 | Pencil on paper |
| The Seeds and Fruits of English Poetry: Study of the Right Side | c.1845 | Brown pen and ink with pencil |
| Chaucer: A Man in a Hood with a Liripipe and Two Drapery Studies | 1848 | Oil on canvas |
| The Prisoner of Chillon Entreating His Jailors (Yale watercolour) | 1858 | Watercolour heightened with bodycolour |
| Elijah and the Widow’s Son (Birmingham oil) | 1864 | Oil on panel |
| He That Soweth (Lyra Germanica) | Published 1868 | Wood engraving by the Dalziel Brothers after Brown |
| The Entombment (NGV) | 1871–1878 | Watercolour, gouache, gold paint and gum arabic over pencil |
| The Sower (Morris firm tile) | c.1864–1873 | Tile; design by Brown, workshop execution |
| Childe Harold’s Pilgrimage (Byron illustration) | Published 1870 | Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown |
| The Two Foscari (Byron illustration) | Published 1870 | Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown |
| The Corsair (Byron illustration) | Published 1870 | Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown |
| Sardanapalus (Byron illustration) | Published 1870 | Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown |
| Don Juan (Byron illustration) | Published 1870 | Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown |
| Byron’s Dream (roundel title-page design) | Published 1870 | Steel engraving by Herbert Bourne after Brown |
| The Finding of Don Juan by Haidée (Birmingham oil) | 1870–1873 | Oil on canvas |
| The Dream of Sardanapalus (Delaware) | 1871–1872 | Watercolour on paper |
| The Traveller (Once a Week) | Published 1869 | Wood engraving by Joseph Swain after Brown |
| The Infant’s Repast | 1848 | Oil on board |
| Oliver Madox Brown Aged Four (Dwale Bluth frontispiece) | Published 1876 | Etching |
| Oliver Madox Brown as a Young Man (Dwale Bluth frontispiece) | Published 1876 | Etching |
| A Beggar and Other Fantasies: Title-page Illustration | Published 1889 | Photo-engraving after Brown |
| Dramas in Miniature: Title-page Illustration | Published 1891 | Photo-engraving after Brown |
| The Brown Owl: Frontispiece | Published 1892 | Photo-engraving after Brown |
| The Brown Owl: Central Illustration | Published 1892 | Photo-engraving after Brown |
| The Feather: Frontispiece | Published 1892 | Photo-engraving after Brown |
| The Ascension: Study for Christ | 1844 | Pen and ink |
| King Lear: Lear Questions Cordelia (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: France Claims the Dispossessed Cordelia (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Cordelia Parts from Her Sisters (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Goneril and Regan Together (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Goneril Tells Oswald How to Treat Lear (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Oswald’s Insolence to Lear (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear Rebukes Oswald (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Kent Trips Oswald (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Goneril’s Complaint to Lear (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear Curses Goneril’s Infidelity (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Kent Challenges Oswald (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Kent in the Stocks (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear Recounts His Wrongs to Regan (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear Parts from Regan and Goneril (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear and the Fool in the Storm (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear Mad on the Beach at Dover (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Alternative Study: Lear Curses Goneril (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| King Lear: Lear Imagines His Daughters’ Trial (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil |
| King Lear: Alternative Study: Lear in the Storm (Whitworth) | 1844 | Pencil, pen and brown ink |
| The Last of England (Fitzwilliam) | 1860 | Oil on canvas |
| The Convalescent (Metropolitan Museum) | Dated 1872 | Pastel |
| Self-Portrait (Walker drawing) | 1850; retouched 1853 | Black chalk |
| Byron’s Dream (Whitworth) | 1889 | Watercolour over graphite |
| Cordelia Parting from Her Sisters (Cleveland sketch) | 1854 | Pen and oil on paper mounted on panel |
| David and Goliath: Cartoon for Stained Glass Window at Jesus College, Cambridge | 1872 | Charcoal and graphite on Japanese paper |
| The Virgin Swooning (recto) | 1844 | Black chalk on laid paper |
| Two Drapery Studies (verso) | c.1844 | Black chalk |
| Architecture: King René’s Honeymoon (stained glass) | 1862 | Stained glass; designed by Brown, made by Morris, Marshall, Faulkner & Co. |
| The Romans Building a Fort at Mancenion (Town Hall mural) | 1880 | Spirit fresco |
| The Baptism of Edwin (Town Hall mural) | 1879–1880 | Spirit fresco |
| The Expulsion of the Danes (Town Hall mural) | 1880–1881 | Spirit fresco |
| The Establishment of the Flemish Weavers (Town Hall mural) | 1881–1882 | Spirit fresco |
| Crabtree Watching the Transit of Venus (Town Hall mural) | 1882–1883 | Spirit fresco |
| The Proclamation Regarding Weights and Measures (Town Hall mural) | 1883–1884 | Spirit fresco |
| Wycliffe on Trial (Town Hall mural) | 1885–1886 | Spirit fresco |
| Chetham’s Life’s Dream (Town Hall mural) | 1885–1886 | Mural on canvas |
| Bradshaw’s Defence of Manchester (Town Hall mural) | 1892–1893 | Mural on canvas |
| John Kay, Inventor of the Fly Shuttle (Town Hall mural) | 1888–1890 | Mural on canvas |
| The Opening of the Bridgewater Canal (Town Hall mural) | 1891–1892 | Mural on canvas |
Frequently Asked Questions
Cromwell is the armoured figure at the right, Milton the seated figure at the left, and Marvell the writer partly hidden between them. Brown conceived the action as Cromwell giving instructions, Milton formulating Latin and Marvell taking dictation. [2]
Brown’s correspondence describes his proposal for arranging the figures and their actions. It supports an account of how he invented the pictorial encounter, rather than establishing a historical meeting with these precise poses and surroundings. [2]
Discussion
Look again at the images and ideas explored in Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois by Ford Madox Brown. These editorial prompts invite your observations.
Reader Insights
Trace the exchange from Cromwell’s papers and map to Milton’s gestures and Marvell’s pen. Which hand first draws your attention, and how does its action lead you to another figure?
Cromwell dominates the foreground, but Milton’s raised hands interrupt that dominance. Consider whether physical size, control of language or possession of the pen gives a figure the greatest authority within this particular scene.
The Vaudois appear through a map, documents and signs of mourning rather than as figures. Consider how that distance shapes the painting: does the enclosed setting make diplomatic intervention more understandable, or draw attention away from the people it concerns?
Join the Conversation
Share a detail, comparison or question about Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois by Ford Madox Brown below.
References
- Manchester Art Gallery / Art UK. Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois , collection catalogue entry for the Manchester painting, 1877. View source .
- Ford Madox Hueffer. Ford Madox Brown: A Record of His Life and Work , Longmans, Green, 1896, pp. 311–316: description, making chronology and duplicate; Brown’s letters to Frederic Shields, 13 February, and Charles Rowley, 24 February, reproduced on pp. 315–316. View source .
- Laura MacCulloch. Ford Madox Brown: Works on Paper and Archive Material at Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery , PhD thesis, University of Birmingham, 2009, vol. I, pp. 104–106, especially p. 105 n. 91; vol. II, list of illustrations, p. 5, fig. 82. View source: volume II View source 1 . View source 2 .
- Charles Firth. Oliver Cromwell and the Rule of the Puritans in England , 1900, pp. 378–379, on the 1655 intervention; digitised edition. View source .
- Oliver Cromwell, in Thomas Carlyle’s edition. Letter to Louis, King of France, no. 205, English translation of a Latin state letter, reproduced by the Cromwell Association, pp. 1–2. Brown identifies his chosen dispatch as May 1658 in the letter reproduced by Hueffer. View source .
- Ford Madox Brown. “On the Mechanism of a Historical Picture. Part I. The Design,” The Germ , 1850, pp. 70–73, especially pp. 70–72. View source .
- Ford Madox Hueffer, Ford Madox Brown: A Record of His Life and Work, 1896; selected career, object and mural passages. View source.
- Laura MacCulloch, Ford Madox Brown: Works on Paper and Archive Material at Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery, 2009, volumeI; catalogue entries. View source.
- Tim Barringer, Ford Madox Brown, Work, MAVCOR, 2014. View source.
- Tate, official historical collection dataset; Ford Madox Brown accession records. View source.
- National Portrait Gallery, Henry Fawcett and Millicent Garrett Fawcett, NPG1603; portrait and frame record. View source.
- Laura MacCulloch, Ford Madox Brown: Works on Paper and Archive Material at Birmingham Museums and Art Gallery, 2009, volumeII; illustration lists, pp1–24. View source.
- Fitzwilliam Museum, The Last of England, M.Add.3. View source.
- Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Convalescent, 10.46. View source.
- Carol Blackett-Ord / National Portrait Gallery, Ford Madox Brown: all known portraits. View source.
- The Whitworth / Art UK, Byron’s Dream, 1889 watercolour. View source.
- Cleveland Museum of Art, Cordelia Parting from Her Sisters, 2013.261. View source.
- Cleveland Museum of Art, David and Goliath: Cartoon for Stained Glass Window at Jesus College, Cambridge, 1872, 2013.247. View source.
- National Gallery of Art, The Virgin Swooning, recto, 1987.73.1.a. View source.
- National Gallery of Art, Two Drapery Studies, verso, object70237. View source.
- Victoria and Albert Museum, Architecture: King René’s Honeymoon, CIRC.516-1953. View source.
- Manchester City Council, The Ford Madox Brown Murals; cycle and individual scenes. View source.
- Splash image, Ford Madox Brown, Cromwell, Protector of the Vaudois, 1877. Oil on canvas. Manchester Art Gallery.