The Virgin of the Host by Ingres Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 22, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

The Virgin of the Host

A white disc rests above a golden chalice. Behind it, Mary lowers her eyes, her hands joined beside her face; two saints emerge from the shadows at her shoulders. Ingres makes the smallest, plainest object in this richly coloured painting its devotional centre. The Virgin’s blue mantle occupies much of the canvas, yet the pale circle below her arrests the eye with equal force.

The 1841 painting in Moscow presents a sacred encounter in which very little happens outwardly. [1] Its interest lies in the relationships between the figures, the ceremonial objects and the person looking at them.

At a Glance

  • ArtistJean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres
  • Date1841
  • MediumOil on canvas
  • Size116 × 84 cm
  • CollectionPushkin Museum of Fine Arts, Moscow, Ж-2761. [1]
  • SubjectMary adoring Christ in the Eucharist, accompanied by two saints. [2]
  • Look forThe contrast between the broad blue mantle and the small white Host.

This work across Ingres’s career

Contents

  1. Looking across the altar
  2. What the Host means here
  3. A Russian commission and its saints
  4. From an earlier Madonna to the finished painting
  5. Raphael and the discipline of the image
  6. How Ingres changed the subject in later versions
  7. From private devotion to public exhibition
  8. Annotated details

Looking across the altar

The white altar cloth runs almost horizontally across the bottom of the painting. Its shallow expanse establishes a boundary: the vessels and figures stand beyond it, while we approach from this side. The chalice rises at the centre, balanced by two slim candlesticks. Their flames are small, but the metal catches enough light to make each stem, foot and swelling ornament legible. Along the lower edge, the patterned hanging introduces another register of colour beneath the white cloth.

Above this carefully ordered foreground, Mary’s body produces a larger, less regular arrangement. Her face is almost frontal, but her hands move to our left, and her mantle extends across the opposite shoulder. The two sides answer one another without becoming mirror images. The praying hands give one side a cluster of pale, slender forms; the blue fabric gives the other a broad, uninterrupted weight. It is an unusually effective way of making a motionless figure feel composed rather than rigid.

The mantle deserves time. Gold edging draws a fine diagonal across the chest, with a fringe of small hanging threads. Below it, blue folds divide into deep shadows and broad illuminated surfaces. The cloth alternately conceals and suggests the body beneath. At the bent arm, the red sleeve and gold lining create a compact passage of warmth beside the cooler expanse of blue. Colour helps articulate the figure as clearly as an outline could.

Mary’s face is quieter than her clothing. The light forehead narrows towards the nose and small mouth; lowered lids interrupt the otherwise smooth surface. A centre parting in her hair reinforces the face’s balance. Fine golden circles surrounding her head remain visible against the dark background without becoming a solid disc. They distinguish a sacred person while allowing the shadows and fabric behind her to continue through the same pictorial space.

The saints occupy that space differently. The older figure at the left turns inwards from deep shadow, while the younger, bearded figure at the right has a more exposed face. Their heads sit lower than the top of Mary’s halo. Dark architectural uprights at the edges enclose the group, and red fabric behind them deepens the recess. These surrounding forms make the central face seem unusually clear and available to sight.

There is a revealing difference between how the painting treats flesh and metal. The face is softly continuous; the chalice and candlesticks are broken into glints, edges and tiny ornaments. The eye can move from broad human form to minute workmanship without leaving the same concentrated scene. Its stillness contains an abundance of carefully differentiated surfaces.

Annotated Details from The Virgin of the Host

The numbered points identify visible features discussed in this article. Return from each detail to the whole composition. Ingres, The Virgin of the Host, 1841. Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts, Moscow, Ж-2761. Wikimedia Commons. Image source. Public domain.

Annotated details from The Virgin of the Host by Ingres

Details from THE VIRGIN OF THE HOST

Compare the central face and joined hands with the flanking saints and the objects set across the altar.

1

The lowered face and joined hands

The face inclines above two joined hands within the blue covering. The pale fingers and face form a compact group between the darker figures at either side.

The lowered face and joined hands detail from The Virgin of the Host by Ingres
2

The saints at either side

Two saints stand behind the central figure within the darker sides of the picture. Compare the different directions of their faces with Mary’s more frontal, lowered head.

The saints at either side detail from The Virgin of the Host by Ingres
3

The Host, vessel and candles

The circular Host rises above the central vessel between two burning candles. Their repeated upright forms rest on the broad white altar in front of the blue mantle.

The Host, vessel and candles detail from The Virgin of the Host by Ingres

What the Host means here

The title names the white sacramental wafer above the chalice. Ingres’s own account explains the relationship between this object and the Virgin. In a letter dated 5 September 1840, preserved in Henri Delaborde’s posthumous compilation, he described Mary as having already ascended to heaven and appearing again to the faithful. Before an altar, she adores her son’s divinity in the sacred Host and chalice, which he associates with humanity’s redemption. Two saints accompany her. [2]

This is a useful guide to an image that could otherwise be mistaken for a familiar Madonna whose child has somehow been omitted. Christ’s presence takes Eucharistic form. Mary’s joined hands and lowered eyes establish her as an adoring participant. In the artist’s explanation, her appearance brings the heavenly figure into a devotional encounter with the faithful. [2]

The visual arrangement makes that explanation intelligible. Mary does not hold the chalice, display the wafer in her hand or turn towards us to explain it. The objects stand independently on the altar, in the nearest accessible part of the sacred space. We see them before we reach her. Her prayer offers an example of how to attend to them, while the frontal presentation leaves the viewer directly before the same focus of devotion.

The scale of the Host is particularly striking. It is much smaller than Mary’s face and dwarfed by her mantle. Its light colour, simple outline and isolated position give it a force that physical size alone could not supply. Against the blue, the disc is immediately legible. The richness of the surrounding painting therefore serves a very spare central form.

Delaborde’s book appeared in 1870, after Ingres’s death, and brings together the artist’s letters, notes and an early catalogue. It transmits valuable testimony without functioning as a treatise prepared by Ingres for publication. Here the letter is especially helpful because it gives a specific account of the subject, rather than a general statement about religious art. [2] It supports a reading of apparition and adoration; it does not require us to invent a private mystical experience behind the painting.

A Russian commission and its saints

The Pushkin Museum’s archived record identifies the patron as the future Alexander II, then heir, and names Nicholas as his father’s patron saint alongside Alexander Nevsky. [1] The saints give the commission a dynastic association while sharing the Virgin’s act of devotion. [1] The commission names a patron. [1] Ingres’s letter describes an apparition and its devotional focus. [2] These documents leave the intended setting uncertain.

From an earlier Madonna to the finished painting

Delaborde’s catalogue preserves an account of an earlier conception: Mary, with joined hands, adoring the sleeping infant Jesus laid before her. It says that Ingres became dissatisfied and covered the picture with white paint, later removed by Raymond Balze. A separate painted study of the child also survived in the collection of Édouard Gatteaux. These are reports about related earlier works, not a description of the visible subject in the Pushkin canvas. [2]

The change from a sleeping child to the Host alters the whole encounter. A mother contemplating her infant gives the viewer a recognisable human relationship to observe. In the completed composition, prayer is directed towards sacramental objects. Much of the emotional communication has to pass through posture, light and the relationship between the altar and the people beyond it. The concentrated arrangement can be understood more clearly when placed beside that earlier idea, even though Delaborde’s account does not establish each intermediate stage of development.

Dating also requires care. Delaborde lists the Russian painting under 1840, the year of the explanatory letter; the Pushkin Museum dates it 1841. [1][2] A second letter provides a useful contemporary check. Writing to the architect Louis-Hippolyte Lebas on 21 March 1841, Victor Schnetz reported that Ingres had finished two paintings the previous day: a Madonna with two saints and the portrait of Cherubini accompanied by a muse. He included small sketches of both compositions. Eric Bertin published this evidence in the 2000 corrections to the Ingres portrait catalogue. [3] Schnetz’s single letter places the Madonna and the allegorical Cherubini portrait at the same moment of completion. [3]

The September letter should therefore be read as evidence of the project’s developed conception, rather than used by itself to date the completed canvas. It tells us that Ingres could already explain the subject precisely; Schnetz supplies testimony about its later completion. [2][3]

Raphael and the discipline of the image

The Pushkin Museum connects the Virgin with Raphael, without naming one exclusive model. [1] For a broader statement of Ingres’s attitude to earlier art, Delaborde records his advice to turn to the masters and speak to them because they remain alive. [2] Read alongside this canvas, that metaphor suggests an active relationship with inherited painting. The old forms are available for renewed use: they can be made to address a new patron, a different setting and a particular devotional subject.

Start with the long horizontal edge of the altar, then follow the chalice upwards to the Host. The red sleeve leads the eye left towards the pale hands; the gold fringe carries it back across the blue. Each route connects a small detail to a larger surface.

This is also why the rich blue matters so much. The mantle is the largest coloured field, supporting the luminous face above and the white Host below. Its folded surface links them while preventing the lower half of the image from becoming visually empty. The composition’s order is made through colour and volume as well as contour.

How Ingres changed the subject in later versions

The Russian commission became the starting point for further paintings. The Metropolitan Museum’s account records that Ingres showed the original in Paris in 1842 before sending it to Saint Petersburg. [4] Its departure did not end his engagement with the arrangement.

The smaller Virgin Adoring the Host, now at the Metropolitan Museum, dates from 1852 and measures 40.3 × 32.7 cm. Ingres gave it to Louise Marcotte, who had introduced him to Delphine Ramel, his second wife. [5] Here the accompanying saints are Louis and Helena, replacing the saints of the Russian commission. [4]

Seen beside the original, the smaller work makes the portability of the central design particularly clear. Mary keeps the joined hands, lowered eyes and blue mantle; the altar still separates her from the viewer, and the chalice retains its central place. The companions, however, bring different faces, costumes and attributes into the margins. These substitutions change the painting’s associations without dissolving its devotional structure.

The visible differences are worth attending to in their own right. In the Metropolitan painting the figure at the left wears an elaborate crown and holds a large cross. The right-hand figure’s patterned clothing and ermine create a much more decorative passage than the shadowed garments in the Russian painting. The blue mantle appears brighter in the available reproductions, although reproductions alone cannot establish the canvases’ original relative colour. What can be seen securely is how differently the surrounding details frame a remarkably persistent central figure.

Another substantial transformation came in 1854. The French state acquired a circular version, 113 cm in diameter, now associated with the Louvre’s long-term deposit at the Musée d’Orsay. Its commission had first been proposed in 1841 and was renewed in 1851. [6] Delaborde describes this version as replacing the two saints with angels. [2]

A circular painting, or tondo, necessarily changes the relationship between a central figure and the enclosing edge. In this case, the change of format accompanies a change in the surrounding sacred company. The later work is a separate object with its own history, not a round presentation of the Moscow canvas. Its state commission also gives a different context to a design first made for the Russian heir.

Delaborde lists further versions dated 1860 and 1866, describing modifications and a smaller repetition. His account associates the latter with the final weeks of Ingres’s working life. [2] The useful point is the persistence of the subject across decades. These paintings need to be distinguished by date, format and companions; a title alone cannot tell us which one we are seeing.

Ingres, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1852.
Ingres, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1852. [7]

Ingres, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1854. Louvre, deposited at the Musée d’Orsay, INV 20088. The circular version.
Ingres, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1854. Louvre, deposited at the Musée d’Orsay, INV 20088. The circular version. [8]

From private devotion to public exhibition

The subject also acquired a public life. The 1854 tondo appeared in Ingres’s studio that year and at the 1855 Exposition Universelle. [6] Robert Rosenblum notes that it hung below The Apotheosis of Homer, between portraits of Comte Molé and the Comtesse d’Haussonville. He reads the arrangement as a meeting of the ideal world and contemporary portraiture, with the Virgin extending the symmetry of the classical composition above into a Christian subject below. [9]

This setting offers a different way to think about the family of paintings. An image organised for sustained devotion could also enter an exhibition in which viewers compared genres, careers and artistic traditions. Its concentrated frontality could work in both circumstances, inviting prayer in one context and close formal comparison in another. The documented display concerns the later tondo; it should not be transferred to the Russian original. The Apotheosis of Homer comparison is illuminating because it brings us back to the figures’ shared attention. In the Pushkin painting, the central object of that attention is tiny. The organisation of the whole scene makes its significance visible.

Artworks directory

Explore 150 paintings, drawings and an original lithograph. This selection includes related versions and studies; dates distinguish completed works from later revisions.

150 artworks

NameDateMedium
The Apotheosis of Homer1827Painting
Grande Odalisque1814Painting
The Turkish Bath1859–1862Painting
Madame Moitessier Seated1856Painting
Portrait of Monsieur Bertin1832Painting
Napoleon I on His Imperial Throne1806Painting
Odalisque with Slave1839Painting
The Ambassadors of Agamemnon in the Tent of Achilles1801 (competition)Painting
The Valpinçon Bather1808Painting
The Source1856Painting
Oedipus Explaining the Enigma of the Sphinx1808; revised probably before 1827Painting
The Vow of Louis XIII1824Painting
Antiochus and Stratonice1840Painting
The Comtesse d’Haussonville1845Painting
The Princesse de Broglie1851–1853Painting
Jupiter and Thetis1811Painting
The Dream of Ossian1813Painting
The Martyrdom of Saint Symphorian1834Painting
Venus Anadyomene1808–1848Painting
Portrait of Madame de Senonnes1814Painting
Madame Rivière1805Painting
Mademoiselle Caroline Rivière1805Painting
Portrait of Philibert Rivière1805Painting
Bonaparte First Consul1804Painting
The Death of Leonardo da Vinci1818Painting
Joan of Arc at the Coronation of Charles VII1854Painting
Madame Duvaucey1807Painting
La Belle Zélie1806Painting
Madame Panckoucke1811Painting
Portrait of Charles Marcotte d’Argenteuil1810Painting
Joseph Antoine Moltedoc.1810Painting
Madame Leblanc1823Painting
Delphine Ingres-Ramel (Portrait of Madame Ingres)1859Painting
Portrait of Amédée de Pastoret1823–1826Painting
Portrait of Baronne de Rothschild1848Painting
Madame Marcotte de Sainte Marie1826Painting
Madame Gonse1852Painting
Aretino in the Studio of Tintoretto1848Painting
Don Pedro of Toledo Kissing Henry IV’s Sword1831/1832Painting
Raphael and La Fornarina1814Painting
Roger Freeing Angelica1819Painting
Romulus’ Victory over Acron1812Painting
Self-Portrait at the Age of Twenty-Four1804; revised 1841–1851Painting
Male Torsoc.1800Painting
Odalisque in Grisaille (Ingres and workshop)c.1824–1834Painting
The Small Bather1826Painting
The Little Bather Harem Interior1828Painting
Jesus Among the Doctors1862Painting
The Virgin Adoring the Host1852Painting
The Virgin of the Host1841Painting
Virgin of the Adoption1858Painting
Paolo and Francesca1814Painting
Homer Deified (revised composition, Louvre RF5273)1865Drawing
Odalisque with Slave (Louvre RF4622)1858Drawing
Odalisque (Walters Art Museum; Ingres and Paul Flandrin)1842Painting
Madame Moitessier Standing (National Gallery of Art)1851Painting
Jacques-Louis Leblanc (The Metropolitan Museum of Art)1823Painting
Ferdinand-Philippe, Duke of Orléans (Louvre RF2005-13)1842Painting
Ferdinand-Philippe, Duke of Orléans (Versailles MV5207; Ingres and workshop)1843Painting
Ferdinand-Philippe, Duke of Orléans (Versailles MV5209; Ingres and workshop)1844Painting
Antiochus and Stratonice (Musée Fabre; Ingres and Raymond Balze)1866Painting
Antiochus and Stratonice (Kunstmuseum Bern, Gurlitt bequest)Undated (early dating proposed)Drawing
Composition study for Antiochus and Stratonice (MIB867.2193)1806Drawing
Study for the Figure of Stratonice (Met63.66)1834–1840Graphite, black chalk and charcoal
Nude figure study for Stratonice (Boijmans F II 36 PK)c.1834–1840Drawing
Paolo and Francesca (The Barber Institute,54.6)c.1814–1820Painting
Paolo and Francesca (The Hyde Collection,1971.24)c.1855–1860Painting
Paolo and Francesca (Amsterdam Museum TA10970)1820Drawing
Paolo and Francesca (dedicated to Artaud de Montor)1816Drawing
Study for the Bust of Francesca (MIB867.1398)1819Drawing
Study for the Bust of Francesca (MIB867.1396)1819Drawing
The Archangel Raphael, first idea (MIB867.2488)1842Drawing
The Archangel Raphael (MIB867.2500)1842Drawing
The Archangel Raphael Carrying Human Prayers to God (Chantilly DE513)1844Drawing
Louis-Philippe as Saint Philip, stained-glass study1844Drawing
Marie Frédéric Eugène de Reiset (Ford Collection RBF171-2)1844Drawing
Virgil Reading the Aeneid (Toulouse)Begun 1811Painting
Tu Marcellus Eris (Brussels, inv. 1836)c.1814 (museum dating)Painting
Jean-François Gilibert1804Painting
François-Marius Granet1807 (museum dating)Painting
Count Nikolai Dmitrievich Guryev1821Painting
Caroline Murat, Queen of Naples1814Painting
Count Mathieu Molé1834Painting
Cherubini and the Muse of Lyric Poetry (Louvre)1842Painting
Luigi Cherubini (Cincinnati)1841Painting
Comtesse de Rayneval (Louvre RF4505)1841Drawing
Venus on Paphos (Antonie Balaÿ)c.1852Painting
Prince Napoléon1855Painting
Study for The Apotheosis of Napoleon I (Petit Palais)Late 1853Painting
The Apotheosis of Napoleon I (destroyed ceiling)1853Painting
The Journalist (MIB867.2733)1834?Drawing
Henry VIII, after Holbeinc.1815–1820 (?)Drawing
Madame Récamier, after David (MIB867.3637)Undated (early Paris period)Drawing
Study for Comtesse d’Haussonville (MIB867.259; background possibly by another hand)1842–1845Drawing
La Source (reduced version reported by Delaborde)Date unrecorded; reported 1870Painting
Odalisque (autograph lithograph,NGA1946.21.117)1825; published1826Lithograph
Portrait of a Seated Lady1814Graphite
The Kaunitz Sisters (Leopoldine, Caroline, and Ferdinandine)1818Graphite
Portrait of a Man1814Graphite
Study for the Portrait of Louis-François Bertin (1766–1841)n.d.Black chalk and graphite
Studies for the Cadaver of Acronca. 1810–12Graphite on wove paper
Study for the Drapery of Molière in "The Apotheosis of Homer"n.d.Black chalk with stumping
Madame Guillaume Guillon Lethière, née Marie-Joseph-Honorée Vanzenne, and her son Lucien Lethière1808Graphite
Niccolò Paganini (1782–1840)ca. 1830Counterproof or tracing strengthened with graphite and gouache on translucent paper
Lady Mary Cavendish-Bentinck (?-1843)1816Graphite
Madame Alexandre Lethière and Her Daughter Letiziaca. 1815Graphite
Merry Joseph Blondel (1781–1853)1809Graphite
Ursin-Jules Vatinelle (1798–1881)1820Graphite
Bust of a Gypsy Girl (ascribed to Ingres)1819Graphite on wove paper
Study of a Seated Nude Malen.d.Graphite
The Archangel Raphael (Study for a stained-glass window in the chapel of Notre-Dame de la Compassion-Saint-Ferdinand, Neuilly)ca. 1842Graphite
Lancelot-Théodore, comte Turpin de Crisséprobably 1818Graphite
Study for the Figure of the Iliad in "The Apotheosis of Homer"ca. 1827Graphite and black chalk heightened with white chalk on brown paper
Comtesse Turpin de Crisséprobably 1818Graphite
Nude Figures for L'Âge d'Or, Château de Dampierren.d.Graphite on brownish paper
Study of Figures (attributed to Ingres)n.d.Graphite
Study of Figures (attributed to Ingres)n.d.Graphite; squared in graphite
Admiral Sir Fleetwood Broughton Reynolds Pellew1817Graphite on wove paper
Madame Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres, née Madeleine Chapelle1814Graphite on off-white wove paper
Virgil Reading the Aeneid to Augustus, Livia, and Octavia1809/1819 (?)Pen and black ink, graphite, brush and gray wash, white gouache heightening, Conté crayon on blue paper
General Louis-Étienne Dulong de Rosnay1818Graphite (hard and soft pencils)
Madame Alexandre Lethière, née Rosa Meli, and Her Daughter, Letizia1815Graphite
The Lawyer Paul Grand1834Graphite
Jean-Joseph Fournier1815Graphite
Armand Bertin1842Graphite
Madame Armand Bertin, née Marie-Anne-Cécile Dollfuss1843Graphite
The Architect Charles-Victor Famin1836Graphite
Henri Lehmann1850Graphite
Portrait of a Ladyca. 1815–17Graphite
Edmond Cavé (1794–1852)1844Oil on canvas
Head of Saint John the Evangelistprobably ca. 1818–20Oil on canvas, laid down on wood
Madame Edmond Cavé (Marie-Elisabeth Blavot, ca. 1806–1883)ca. 1831–34Oil on canvas
Madame Félix Gallois1852Graphite with touches of gold in oil to highlight jewelry, on buff wove paper.
Dr. François Mêlier1849Graphite with graphite framing lines, corrected with white, on buff wove paper
Portrait of Madame Rhode (Rhoda?)1810–20Graphite on pale buff wove paper
Study for "Raphael and the Fornarina"(?)ca. 1814(?)Graphite on white wove paper
Portrait of Madame Paul Meurice, née Palmyre Grangerca. 1845–50Graphite on wove paper
Alexander the Great presenting Campaspe to Apelles1810Graphite, brush and brown wash; squared in graphite
Study of Hands for "Christ Among the Doctors"1852–62Graphite on tracing paper
Study for The Turkish Bath (RF34502)about 1850Pen and brown ink with graphite, partially squared
Study for The Turkish Bath (RF23354)UndatedPen and brown ink with graphite on joined sheets
Study for The Turkish Bath (RF54702)about 1859Pen and brown ink
Studies of women for The Turkish Bath (RF12292)UndatedBlack chalk
Achilles Receiving the Envoys of Agamemnon (Nationalmuseum sketch, NM2161)1801Oil on wood
Half-Length Bather (Musée Bonnat-Helleu,89)1807Oil on canvas
Oedipus and the Sphinx (National Gallery,NG3290)about1826Oil on canvas
Oedipus and the Sphinx (Walters,37.9)1864Oil on canvas
Oedipus and the Valpinçon Bather, after David (MI.867.2035)UndatedGraphite on tracing paper, after David
Study of the Virgin for The Vow of Louis XIII (Dijon,1758)about1822Black chalk, stump and white chalk on brown wove paper
First Thought for The Vow of Louis XIII (MI.885.11.21)1822Oil on canvas

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is the 1841 painting?

The Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts, Moscow, holds the original. The later versions discussed here are separate canvases. [1][5][6]

Why is there no infant Jesus?

Ingres described Mary adoring her son’s divinity in the Host and chalice. Christ is present in Eucharistic form; an earlier conception with a sleeping infant was a different work. [2]

Are all versions of The Virgin of the Host the same?

They retain a related devotional arrangement but change its companions and, in the 1854 version, its format. Delaborde distinguishes the Russian saints, later angels and further repetitions. [2]

Discussion

Look again at the images and ideas explored in The Virgin of the Host. These editorial prompts invite your observations.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Close Looking

What holds your attention longest: Mary’s face, her joined hands or the small white Host? How does following that detail change the way you look at the rest of the group?

Editorial prompt · Comparison

Compare the rectangular 1841 painting with the later circular composition. How does the outer shape change the space around Mary?

Editorial prompt · Context

Which differences between the saints help you keep this Russian commission distinct from the later Marcotte gift?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about The Virgin of the Host below.

References

  1. Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts, The Virgin before the Communion Chalice, Ж-2761. Archived collection entry. (In Russian.) View source.
  2. Henri Delaborde, Ingres, sa vie, ses travaux, sa doctrine, d’après les notes manuscrites et les lettres du maître. Paris: Henri Plon, 1870, p. 139; catalogue nos. 10–14, pp. 181–182, including Ingres’s letter of 5 September 1840. (In French.) View source.
  3. Eric Bertin, addenda and corrigenda, in Gary Tinterow, Charlotte Hale and Eric Bertin. “‘Portraits by Ingres: Image of an Epoch’: Reflections, Technical Observations, Addenda, and Corrigenda”. Metropolitan Museum Journal 35 (2000), pp. 214–215, fig. 23 and Schnetz’s letter to Lebas, 21 March 1841. View source.
  4. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, “The Virgin Adoring the Host,” Recent Acquisitions: A Selection, 2005–2006. The Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 64, no. 2 (Fall 2006), p. 48. View source.
  5. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1852, 2005.186. Collection entry. View source.
  6. Musée du Louvre, La Vierge à l’hostie, 1854, INV 20088. Collection entry, description and history. (In French.) View source.
  7. Supporting image. Ingres, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1852. The Metropolitan Museum of Art; Gift of Lila and Herman Shickman, 2005. Image source. CC0 / Public domain.
  8. Supporting image. Ingres, The Virgin Adoring the Host, 1854. Louvre, deposited at the Musée d’Orsay, INV 20088. The circular version. Wikimedia Commons. Image source. Public domain.
  9. Robert Rosenblum, “Ingres’s Portraits and Their Muses,” in Gary Tinterow and Philip Conisbee, eds. Portraits by Ingres: Image of an Epoch. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1999, pp. 3–4, 9–10, especially fig. 11. View source.
  10. Splash image. Ingres, The Virgin of the Host, 1841. Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts, Moscow, Ж-2761. Wikimedia Commons. Image source. Public domain.