Cliff Dwellers by George Bellows, 1913 Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
/
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Cliff Dwellers: Introduction

George Bellows’s Cliff Dwellers fills a Lower East Side street with children, adults, traffic, washing and summer light. Painted in 1913, it neither keeps the tenement neighbourhood at a safe distance nor compresses its residents into a single message. Crowded housing is unmistakable, but so are play, work, movement and sociability. The painting’s force comes from that tension: Bellows shows material pressure while making the street feel intensely alive.[1][6]

At a Glance

  • ArtistGeorge Bellows (1882–1925)
  • TitleCliff Dwellers — without a leading article
  • Date1913; completed in May according to Bellows’s record book
  • MediumOil on canvas
  • CollectionLos Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA)
  • Accession16.4

George Bellows in context

Works
19051910191519201925

My Family

1916

A Stag at Sharkey's

1917

Dempsey and Firpo

1924

Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. The Exact Painting and Its Title
  3. A Street Built from Many Speeds
  4. Heat, Air and the Tenement Walls
  5. Social Criticism or Urban Vitality?
  6. Three Colour Chords
  7. Pinhole Geometry and Its Limits
  8. The Armory Show Year and the 1916 Purchase
  9. How to Look at Cliff Dwellers

The Exact Painting and Its Title

LACMA records Cliff Dwellers as an oil on canvas measuring 40 3/16 by 42 1/16 inches (102.08 by 106.84 centimetres). It entered the collection through the Los Angeles County Fund and carries accession number 16.4.[1] These details identify the square-format painting, rather than any of the related drawings through which Bellows reconsidered parts of its design.

The absence of “The” is deliberate. Bellows’s record book indicates that he completed the canvas in May 1913 and crossed out the definite article in its written title, leaving Cliff Dwellers. LACMA’s current catalogue follows that evidence.[1] Some older captions and titles of related works on paper retain an article, but they do not override the painting’s present name. The Commons file record likewise identifies its digital reproduction as the 1913 LACMA painting, rather than one of those studies.[3]

The title is a metaphor as well as an identifier. The Met explains that the period phrase alluded to Indigenous cliff settlements in the American Southwest, then applied that image of layered dwelling to New York tenements.[6] It is not a description of the residents’ identity. In the canvas, stacked balconies, windows and fire escapes make the people above the pavement seem lodged in vertical strata, while the crowd below spreads across the street.

A Street Built from Many Speeds

The first impression is density, but the scene is not an undifferentiated mass. A market cart flares with orange and yellow at the left. Behind it, a streetcar pushes through the middle distance, its row of windows marking a slower horizontal movement. Figures lean from windows and gather along balconies; sheets and garments cross the upper half of the picture. At the right, a woman climbs the steps while seated adults and children occupy the pavement below.[1]

Bellows makes the lower centre especially active. Young women in pale clothes catch the sun, children tug, turn and collide, and darker figures pass behind them. No single incident governs the whole painting. Instead, small encounters overlap, much as traffic, trade, household labour and play would overlap in the street itself. The viewer must keep shifting attention between foreground bodies, the vehicle, the cart and the inhabited walls.

That restless structure belongs to Bellows’s larger engagement with New York City. He had moved from Columbus to New York in 1904 and studied with Robert Henri, whose teaching encouraged direct attention to ordinary urban life.[4][5] The Smithsonian notes Bellows’s particular ability to convey moving crowds.[5] Here, that ability is not simply a matter of rapid brushwork: it depends on distributing different actions across an unusually compressed field.

Heat, Air and the Tenement Walls

The buildings establish pressure before any social interpretation begins. A large block at the left lies in deep shadow, its facade broken into dark rectangles. The lighter building on the right rises close to the picture edge, while the street seems to narrow behind the streetcar. Bodies spill into the available open ground. The Met reads the residents at windows and in the street as seeking relief from overcrowded rooms in summer heat.[6]

Yet the atmosphere is not sealed. Sunlight strikes the foreground and the right-hand facade. A stiff breeze lifts washing above the street, introducing visible air into the canyon of masonry.[1] Bellows therefore makes enclosure and release coexist. The walls hem people in, but light, fabric and human motion keep the composition from becoming static.

The destination sign on the streetcar and the irregular meeting of streets led LACMA’s curator to suggest a Lower East Side area between the Bowery and Catherine Slip, below Chatham Square.[1] That is a reasoned location, not proof of one precisely observed corner. Like Bellows’s New York, the scene works as a concentrated urban construction even when individual signs make its geography plausible.

Social Criticism or Urban Vitality?

Cliff Dwellers has often been treated as a denunciation of tenement conditions. There is strong visual support for taking poverty and crowding seriously: neglected buildings dominate the scene, domestic activity has moved into public space, and adults and children compete with commerce and transport. The Met stresses the way residents appear constrained by brick walls and by circumstances they cannot readily escape.[6]

LACMA’s longer curatorial note complicates a purely condemnatory reading. It argues that much of the painting’s reputation for explicit social criticism derives from its relation to Bellows’s drawing Why Don’t They Go to the Country for a Vacation?, published as an August 1913 frontispiece in the socialist journal The Masses. Bellows’s record book calls that work a study for Cliff Dwellers, but the museum also observes that its transfer-and-reworking method resembles other illustrations made specifically for the magazine. The drawing may have prepared the painting and then acquired an editorial use, or it may have been conceived for publication from the outset; the available evidence does not settle the sequence.[1]

This matters because a satirical title attached to a magazine drawing does not automatically become the painting’s statement. Bellows held left-wing views and contributed illustrations to The Masses from 1912 to 1917.[4] Even so, LACMA distinguishes the direct address of editorial imagery from the tone of Ashcan painting. Its account finds bustling activity, pleasure and resilience here, especially in the bright group of women and children, the lively boys, the working mother on the steps and the produce cart.[1]

The two interpretations need not cancel one another. Vitality does not make overcrowding harmless, and social awareness does not require every figure to appear defeated. A stronger reading holds the visible constraints together with the residents’ agency. Bellows presents people making use of the street, not merely serving as evidence in an argument about it.

Three Colour Chords

The apparent spontaneity rests on a recorded colour plan. Bellows noted that the painting used three “chords,” a concept associated with the colour theorist and paint supplier Hardesty G. Maratta. Like harmonies in music, these triads were meant to establish relationships across a composition. LACMA identifies one combination of orange, red-purple and green-blue around the produce wagon and through the lower crowd; a second helps organise the blue-purple shadow, green shutters and brick at the left; a third contributes to the yellow-green light on the right-hand building.[1]

These are not three sealed zones. Related hues recur, and white alters their apparent temperature and brightness. Bellows also mixed colours wet into wet on the canvas, producing intermediate tones that soften the limits of the scheme.[1] The result explains why the market cart, pale clothing, shadowed facade and sunlit wall can each command attention without breaking the painting apart.

Colour also shapes the social encounter. Light gathers around the central children and women, while faces and bodies in the middle distance emerge more intermittently from dark paint. The eye moves because the palette gives it successive places to land. Bellows’s paintings often translate collective energy into contrasts of value and hue; here the method is both controlled and sensuous.

Pinhole Geometry and Its Limits

Close technical examination reveals a second kind of order. LACMA reports at least ninety tiny pinholes arranged in horizontal, vertical and diagonal rows. Some surviving red diagonal marks coincide with them, and the spacing can form equilateral triangles, a key element in compositional systems associated with Maratta. Certain alignments are striking: pinholes touch the head and elbows of the woman holding a fan at lower right, while a strong building edge follows another row.[1]

The evidence does not provide a complete diagram of Bellows’s intentions. Pins may have helped locate figures, establish proportional intervals or transfer elements from a related design. Numerous geometric patterns could be drawn through such a network, and LACMA explicitly calls for further study before identifying which forms Bellows actually used.[1] The responsible conclusion is modest: the marks prove careful construction, but not one fully decoded formula.

That caution changes how the surface looks. Broad strokes and crowded incidents can suggest a scene seized all at once. The pinholes and colour notes reveal extended planning beneath that impression. Bellows did not have to choose between immediacy and design; he engineered a structure capable of carrying apparent disorder.

The Armory Show Year and the 1916 Purchase

The year 1913 placed Bellows at the centre of changing American art. He helped organise the Armory Show, exhibited works there and became a full member of the National Academy of Design.[4] The Met dates the New York exhibition to February and March and discusses the expanded colour and technique of Bellows’s work that year.[6]

Whether the finished Cliff Dwellers itself hung in the New York Armory Show requires qualification. A short LACMA feature says that it was featured in the 1913 show.[2] The museum’s detailed object note, however, says Bellows’s record book places completion in May, after the New York dates given by The Met.[1][6] On those records, it is secure to connect the painting with Bellows’s Armory Show year and participation; an exact New York display claim remains difficult to reconcile without fuller exhibition documentation.

The later history is clearer. The painting won a $500 third prize at the Carnegie Institute’s 1914 annual exhibition, travelled to other venues and was shown in Los Angeles. LACMA records that the museum bought it directly from Bellows on 16 September 1916.[1] The institution describes it as among its earliest paintings, while its 2015 feature calls it the first artwork to enter the collection that became LACMA.[1][2] Its accession, 16.4, still carries that early place in the museum’s history.

How to Look at Cliff Dwellers

Begin at the bright produce cart, then follow the streetcar into the narrowing middle distance. Let the diagonal steps pull you back towards the woman climbing at the right. Only then look upward, where washing, balconies and figures extend the crowd into the architecture.

Next compare the central pool of light with the shadowed building. The painting does not assign virtue to one side and hardship to the other; both belong to the same street. Finally, return to the children. Their physical intensity gives the work much of its vitality, but the walls, traffic and adult labour around them prevent play from becoming an escape from social circumstance. That double attention—to pleasure and pressure—is the most useful way into Bellows’s picture.

Researched works directory

This searchable evidence census was assembled from public museum records and a reproducible Wikidata snapshot. It is not a catalogue raisonné, not a claim to complete oeuvre coverage, and not a substitute for the published catalogue literature, which was not used to claim absolute completeness.

268 artworks

NameDateMedium
A Cloudy Day / Hudson River: Coming Squall1908Painting
A Day in June1913Painting
A Fresh Breeze1913Painting
A Grandmother1914Painting
A Knockout1921Print
A Morning Snow--Hudson River1910Painting
A Stag at Sharkey's1917Print
A Winter Day - Under the Elevated near Brooklyn Bridge1907Painting
Allan Donn Puts to Sea1923Print
An Irish Girl1922Drawing
Anne1915Painting
Anne 19211923Print
Anne and Her Mother1917Drawing
Anne in Black Velvet1917Painting
Anne in White1920Painting
Anne with a Japanese Parasol1917Painting
Approach of Rain1913Painting
Approach to the Bridge at Night1913Painting
Arms of a Boxer1916Drawing
Artists' Evening1916Print
August Lundberg (No 2)1907Painting
Aunt Fanny1920Painting
Barnyard and Chickens1924Painting
Bethesda Fountain (Fountain in Central Park)1905Painting
Between Rounds, large, first stone1916Print
Between Rounds, small, second stone1923Print
Blue Morning1909Painting
Blue Snow, the Battery1910Painting
Both Members of This Club1909Painting
Boy in a Blue Coat1915Painting
Boy with Eton Collar (Portrait of Meredith Hare)1921Painting
Breaking Sky, Monhegan1916Painting
Bridge, Blackwell’s Island1909Painting
Builders of Ship1916Painting
California Headlands1917Painting
Caricature of Adam and Eve and Two Female Portrait SketchesDate unknownDrawing
Central Park1905Painting
Chester Dale1922Painting
Children Playing in a Park1905Drawing
Cleaning Fish1913Painting
Cliff Dwellers1913Painting
CliffsDate unknownPainting
Club Night1907Painting
Coming Storm1914Painting
Coopers Lake, Woodstock1924Painting
Counted Out, first stone1921Print
Counted Out, second stone1921Print
Criehaven Wharf1916Painting
Cross-Eyed BoyDate unknownPainting
Dance in a Madhouse1917Print
Dancing Town (The Top of the World)1922Drawing
Dempsey and Firpo1923Print
Dempsey and Firpo1924Painting
Dempsey through the Ropes1923Print
Dempsey Through the RopesDate unknownPainting
Deserted Factory1924Painting
Dock Builders1916Painting
Edge of the Pasture - Glow of the Sun1916Painting
Edith Cavell1918Painting
Elinor, Jean and Anna1920Painting
Elsie, Emma and Marjorie, First Stone1921Print
Elsie, Emma and Marjorie, second stone1921Print
Elsie Reading to Emma, First Stone1921Print
Elsie Reading to Emma, Second Stone1921Print
Elsie Speicher [verso]1920Drawing
Emma and Her Children1923Painting
Emma at the Piano1914Painting
Emma at the Window1920Painting
Emma, Elsie and Gene1921Print
Emma in a Purple Dress1920Painting
Emma in the Black Print1919Painting
Emma in the Purple Dress1919Painting
Evening Blue1916Painting
Evening Swell1911Painting
Excavation at Night1908Painting
Family in a Surrey1921Drawing
Fern WoodsDate unknownPainting
Five Cows1919Painting
Floating Ice1910Painting
Florence Davey1914Painting
Fog Breakers1913Painting
Forty-two Kids1907Painting
Frankie, the Organ Boy1907Painting
Garaldine Lee, No. 21914Painting
Gardiner's Bay from Sag Harbor1899Painting
Ghost of Sergeant Pelly1918Drawing
Golf Course, California1917Painting
Gorge and Sea1911Painting
Grandma Bellows1919Painting
Gray Sea1913Painting
Harbor of Monhegan, Fish Boats1911Painting
Haystacks and Barn1909Painting
Head of Boy (aka Gray Boy)1905Painting
Hungry Dogs, second stone1916Print
Hunter and Mountains1920Painting
In a Rowboat1916Painting
In an Elevator1916Print
In the Park, Dark1916Print
Introducing Georges Carpentier1921Print
Introducing John L. Sullivan1916Print
Introducing John L. Sullivan1923Painting
Introducing the Champion1916Print
Introductions1921Print
Jackie (Jacqueline Hudson)1914Painting
Jean 19231923Print
Jean in a Black Hat1923Print
Jean with Blue Book and Apple1916Painting
Jim Twadell's Place1924Painting
Julie Hudson1914Painting
Katherine Rosen1921Painting
Kids1906Painting
Lady Jean1924Painting
Lady of 1860 - The Actress1922Drawing
Lady with a Fan1921Print
Launching1913Painting
Little Girl in White (Queenie Burnett)1907Painting
Love of Winter1914Painting
Lychnis and Her Sons1923Print
Madeline Davis1914Painting
Man and Dog1905Painting
Matinicus1916Print
Maud Dale1919Painting
May Day in Central Park1905Painting
Men of the Docks1912Painting
Mill Dam1924Painting
Miss Bentham1906Painting
Monhegan Island1913Painting
Mother and Children1916Print
Mother and Children, Second State1916Print
Mountain Farm1922Painting
Mr. and Mrs. Phillip Wase1924Painting
Mrs. Chester Dale1919Painting
Mrs. T. in Cream Silk, No.11919Painting
Mrs. T. in Cream Silk, No.21920Painting
Mrs. Walter H. Richter1922Painting
Murder of Edith Cavell1918Print
My Family1916Painting
My Mother1921Painting
New York1911Painting
North River1908Painting
Nude Girl, Miss Leslie Hall1909Painting
Nude Girl Reclining1919Drawing
Nude Study, Girl Standing on One Foot1923Print
Nude with Fan1920Painting
Nude with Hexagonal Quilt1924Painting
Nude with Parrot1915Painting
Nude with Red Hair1920Painting
Old Barn, Grey Day1920Painting
Old Fisherman1904Painting
Ox Team, Wharf at Matinicus1916Painting
Paddy Flannigan1908Painting
Padre1917Painting
Paradise Point1919Painting
Pennsylvania Station Excavationc. 1907–1908Painting
Pigs and Donkey1920Painting
Polo at Lakewood1910Painting
Portrait of a Boy1921Painting
Portrait of a Laughing Boy1907Painting
Portrait of Florence Budd1914Painting
Portrait of Florence Pierce1914Painting
Portrait of Geraldine Lee, No. 11914Painting
Portrait of My Mother No. 11921Painting
Portrait of Prosper Invernizzi1907Painting
Portrait of Walter Littlefield1915Painting
Porträt der Anne1915Painting
Porträt der Laura1922Painting
Prayer Meeting, second stone1916Print
Preliminaries1916Print
PreliminariesDate unknownPrint
Pueblo Tesuque, No. 21917Painting
Rain on the River1908Painting
Return of the Useless1918Painting
River Front No. 11914Painting
Rock Bound1913Painting
Rock Reef, Maine1913Painting
Rock Ridge FarmDate unknownPainting
Rocks and Coast1911Painting
Rolling Breakers1913Painting
Romance of Autumn1916Painting
Romance of Criehaven1916Painting
Roumanian Girl1921Painting
Samuel Knopf1922Painting
Santuario de Chimata1917Painting
Seated Female Nude (Emma Story Bellows)Date unknownDrawing
Seated Nude1910Painting
Self-Portrait1921Print
Shipyard Society1916Painting
Sixteen East Gay Street1923Print
Sketches of Heads, Including One of Chester DaleDate unknownDrawing
Sketches of Three Female Heads [recto]Date unknownDrawing
Snow-Capped River1911Painting
Snow Dumpers1911Painting
Society Ball [verso]1907Drawing
Splinter Beach1916Print
Stag at Sharkey's1909Painting
Steaming Streets1908Painting
Storm Sea1913Painting
Street Fight [recto]1907Drawing
Studies of Jean1920Drawing
Study for "Mr. and Mrs. Philip Wase1924Drawing
Study for Nude with Hexagonal Quilt1924Drawing
Study for "Riverfront No. 11915Drawing
Study of Emma and the Children1917Painting
Summer City1909Painting
Summer Fantasy1924Painting
Summer Night, Riverside Drive1909Painting
Sun Glow1913Painting
Sun Shadows (Rocks at Monhegan)1913Painting
Sunday 18971921Print
Sunlit surf1913Painting
Swans in Central Park1906Painting
Tennis1920Print
Tennis at Newport1919Painting
Tennis at Newport1920Painting
Tennis Tournament1920Painting
The Barricade1918Painting
The Beach, Newport (In the Sand)1919Painting
The Big Dory1913Painting
The Black Derby / Head of a man with a red nose1905Painting
The BrookDate unknownPainting
The Charge1918Print
The Cigarette1918Print
The Coming Storm1916Painting
The Dock1913Painting
The Donkey Cart1922Drawing
The Fish Wharf, Matinicus Island1916Painting
The Fisherman1917Painting
The Germans Arrive1918Painting
The Grove — Monhegan1911Painting
The Gulls, Monhegan1911Painting
The Harbor, Monhegan Coast, Maine1913Painting
The Kindliness Came Not from Her1922Drawing
The LaunchingDate unknownPainting
The Law Is Too Slow1923Print
The Lone Tenement1909Painting
The Newsboy1908Painting
The Novitiate1916Print
The Palisades1909Painting
The Red Vine, Matinicus Island, Maine1916Painting
The Sand Cart1917Painting
The Sea1911Painting
The Shower-Bath1917Print
The Studio1919Painting
The Teamster1916Painting
The Tournament1920Print
The Village Houses1920Painting
The Warships1909Painting
The White Hope1921Print
The White Horse1922Painting
The Widow1917Painting
Three Children1919Painting
Three Pigs and a Mountain1922Painting
Three Rollers1911Painting
Through the Trees, Monhegan Island, Maine1913Painting
Tumble of Waters1913Painting
Two Girls1917Print
Two Women1924Painting
Up the Gorge1913Painting
Up the Hudson1908Painting
Village on the Hill1916Painting
Vine Clad Shore--Monhegan Island1913Painting
Waldo Peirce1920Painting
War Series1918Painting
West Wind1913Painting
Willard in Training Quarters1916Print
Winter Afternoon, Riverside Park1909Painting
Winter Road1912Painting
Woodstock Road, Woodstock, New York1924Drawing

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Cliff Dwellers, and when was it painted?

The painting belongs to the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, where it is accession 16.4. LACMA dates it to 1913, and Bellows’s record book says it was completed in May of that year.[1]

Why is it called Cliff Dwellers rather than The Cliff Dwellers?

Bellows crossed out the definite article in his record book, so LACMA’s current title is Cliff Dwellers. The title uses a period metaphor for people living in stacked tenements; it does not identify the Manhattan residents as the Indigenous peoples to whom the phrase originally referred.[1][6]

What part of New York does the painting show?

It represents the Lower East Side. From the street angles and the streetcar’s destination sign, LACMA suggests an area between the Bowery and Catherine Slip, south of Chatham Square. That is an informed identification rather than a documented street-corner address.[1]

Was Cliff Dwellers shown at the 1913 Armory Show?

LACMA’s 2015 collection feature says it was, but the museum’s detailed record places completion in May, whereas The Met dates the New York Armory Show to February–March. Bellows certainly helped organise and exhibited at the show; the finished painting’s precise exhibition history needs that chronological caveat.[1][2][4][6]

Is the painting social criticism, and how was it constructed?

It supports a social reading through its crowded tenements, shared street and visible labour, but LACMA also emphasises the residents’ energy and pleasure. Bellows organised the surface with three Maratta colour chords, wet-into-wet mixing and a network of pinholes. The pinholes show geometric planning, although their complete purpose has not been proved.[1][6]

Discussion

Use this evidence-led guide as a starting point for close looking rather than a final verdict.

Share an observation about Cliff Dwellers or a source that adds useful context.

Reader Insights

Close Looking

Which detail most changes your reading of Cliff Dwellers?

Context

How do scale, support, medium or present museum evidence shape the encounter?

Open Question

What remains uncertain when visual inference is separated from documented fact?

Join the Conversation

Add your reading below, keeping observations specific and evidence clear.

References

  1. Los Angeles County Museum of Art, “Cliff Dwellers”, accessed 31 August 2026.
  2. Linda Theung, “From the Collection: Cliff Dwellers”, LACMA, 20 January 2015, accessed 31 August 2026.
  3. Wikimedia Commons, “George Bellows — Cliff Dwellers (1913)” file record.jpg), accessed 31 August 2026.
  4. National Gallery of Art, “George Bellows”, accessed 31 August 2026.
  5. Smithsonian American Art Museum, “George Bellows”, accessed 31 August 2026.
  6. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, “George Bellows” exhibition overview, accessed 31 August 2026.